News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:38PM (#38894585)
Has there been any push to break up Boeing?
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by brewdad on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:45PM (#38894671)
Boeings breaking up is how we got here.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by sumanthvepa on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:54PM (#38895909)
I know we're not supposed to be funny on this website. But that just broke me up.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by davidw on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:23PM (#38896139)
Humor is fine here, it just has to be actually funny - no tired memes or chains of replies or that sort of thing.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by lmm on Saturday January 06, 2024 @08:55PM (#38897596)
Even that's predictably shifted in the last few years. HN is perpetually turning into Reddit in the sense of being on a level with where Reddit was 3-5 years ago.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by eunos on Saturday January 06, 2024 @03:38PM (#38895206)
The moment Boeing breakup discourse entering public discourse all of their lobbyists retinue will shout "Airbus, COMAC, Great Power Competition"
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by fullshark on Saturday January 06, 2024 @03:48PM (#38895284)
How about nationalizing it?
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by dclowd9901 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:59PM (#38895938)
Nationalize a critical piece of our infrastructure? Perish the thought!
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by ethbr1 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @03:06PM (#38894902)
The problem with breaking up Boeing is Airbus.

Nowadays, to realistically restore competiveness in an industry, you'd have to coordinate a worldwide breakup of similarly-integrated competitors.

Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by JumpCrisscross on Saturday January 06, 2024 @03:49PM (#38895302)
If the broken-up bits are uncompetitive with a monolith, that’s an argument against pursuing a break-up.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by notahacker on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:19PM (#38895588)
I believe that was the point. Aircraft economics barely sustains two airframers per market segment, and uncompetitive offerings aren't going to raise safety/QC bars in a regulated industry

(and whilst you've got the scope to leave the airframe design/sales op alone and [further] vertically disintegrate the supply chain instead, that might actually make it worse, with the Spirit/Boeing relationship plausibly having a causal relationship with this incident)

Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by ethbr1 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:17PM (#38895568)
Well, there's product-price-uncompetitive and then externality-inclusive-uncompetitive.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by delusional on Saturday January 06, 2024 @03:51PM (#38895320)
Is the argument here that it's more economically viable to run a plane building company whose planes accidentally falls out of the sky? Naively, it would seem to me to be a bad business decision to design aero planes that can't fly, but what do I know.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by czl on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:48PM (#38895858)
> it's more economically viable to run a plane building company whose planes accidentally falls out of the sky?

Business school may say if your product never fails perhaps you are overspending on it and some known small failure rate is acceptable to control costs to have better profits. Boeing leadership may have took that logic and applied it to airplanes.

Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by delusional on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:19PM (#38896118)
Is that argument wrong? If it isn't, then you've successfully identified capitalism as the problem. I'm all for anti-capitalism, but I don't think it's reasonable to expect that to start with Boeing.

This is not a problem of "pointy haired MBA's", we can either fix this within the current regime by imposing heavy fines on this sort of reckless behavior, or we can tear down the current regime and replace it with communism/fascism/monarchy/whatever. In the system we are currently in, what happened at Boeing looks to be "correct", in the sense that it's what the system incentivizes.

Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by rustymonday on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:32PM (#38896221)
It is wrong because people will not want to fly on this plane, and carriers will be less likely to buy this model. This hurts Boeing's bottom line.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by wasmitnetzen on Saturday January 06, 2024 @06:04PM (#38896506)
They've sold nearly 6000 Max's. Seems like the market accepts that behaviour.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by danpalmer on Saturday January 06, 2024 @06:47PM (#38896819)
It's a sticky product. There isn't an alternative from Boeing in this market segment that's viable in a modern fleet from what I understand, and airlines tend to be either Boeing or Airbus, so it would take a huge push to get an airline to migrate from one to the other – possibly multiple failed models and significant compensation to fund building up the maintenance infrastructure for the other manufacturer and pilot retraining.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by delusional on Sunday January 07, 2024 @04:55AM (#38899913)
Then it's not wrong.

PS: I realize you're not the person responding previously.

Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by AniseAbyss on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:21PM (#38895611)
It's functionally impossible for Airbus to take over all of Boeing's contracts. Airbus itself has an order backlog in the thousands. They're not REALLY competing with Boeing.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by kazen44 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:08PM (#38896000)
which will never happen. Airbus is a pan european political project asmuch as a competitor to boeing. (also, one which is hugely important for independence of european airtransport).
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by numpad0 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @04:14PM (#38895541)
Boeing was reasonably broken up until merged with McDonnell Douglas.
Re:FAA orders grounding of more than 170 Boeing 737 Max 9s by philwelch on Saturday January 06, 2024 @05:51PM (#38896376)
The consolidation in aerospace and defense was a much longer process than that. All of the companies with names like “McDonnell Douglas”, “Lockheed Martin”, or “Northrop Grumman” were formed by mergers. If you actually break apart Boeing’s merger history there were at least a half dozen WWII-era companies that slowly consolidated over half a century.

Part of this was because WWII subsidized an unsustainable and frankly absurd level of demand. For instance, Grumman almost exclusively built carrier-based fighters, and by the end of WWII they were producing planes so quickly that the Navy stopped doing periodic heavy maintenance of their aircraft in lieu of dumping them into the sea and replacing them with brand new planes. Obviously business for Grumman would never be quite that good ever again.