News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by cmeacham98 on Friday January 05, 2024 @07:50PM (#38887111)
From my understanding, they're relying on GitHub for the hosting of the blog posts themselves.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by TylerE on Friday January 05, 2024 @07:57PM (#38887152)
So the opposite of decentralized then. Why do crypto people love inventing new middlemen to take a cut? Oh right, they’re the middleman. That’s why.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by mhluongo on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:35PM (#38888461)
> Why do people love inventing new middlemen to take a cut?

FTFY.

Remember many on this site are partially responsible for the ad-ridden web and a proliferation of all sorts of spyware.

OTOH, we wouldn't skewer someone for charging for yet another toy SaaS and posting a Show HN, so... let's be a little more balanced.

Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by TylerE on Friday January 05, 2024 @11:49PM (#38888523)
I don't think it's unbalanced to call BS on a service claiming to be decentralized that in fact relies on a single centralized service they do not control, twice over. (Once for auth, second for content).
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by dnpotter1 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:50AM (#38888811)
Yeah, I guess it’s more accurate to call it an [almost] fully decentralised discovery service rn. Decentralised hosting should come later. The almost is for the oauth server, which can be improved by adding other independent trusted servers in a permissioned network.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by TylerE on Saturday January 06, 2024 @02:28AM (#38889300)
Totally fair! Sorry if my initial response was perhaps a tad harsh... my bullshit-0-meter goes to a million for anything even vaguely crypto/blockchain related.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by soap- on Friday January 05, 2024 @10:24PM (#38888085)
But why specifically GitHub, instead of just git? Every git hosting provider could work with this model
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by dnpotter1 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @12:44AM (#38888776)
That’s true but I am trying to discourage people publishing other people’s work. Hence users need to link their account through oauth. Other hosts can be added.
Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by Terretta on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:37AM (#38892804)
> I am trying to discourage people publishing...

A common motivating concept for decentralized is no authoritarian oversight to deplatform you.

You're seeking editorial influence (control) from the start.

Setting aside what users want versus what you want, as a platform technology you need to be careful here.

You way want to brush up on the safe harbor laws for Internet infrastructure/pipes/hosting firms and technologies versus the lack of safe harbor for platforms with desire or ability to exercise editorial influence or control on a user or content basis.

You can navigate this, by having reasons such as "I'm not editing, but by associating users with a non-anonymous identity they will self moderate", as you've noted. You can, with such reasons, still have a bit of cake after eating it. But be careful not to veer into actual editorial control unless you're prepared for full liability.

Re:Show HN: Seedling – A Decentralised Medium by dnpotter1 on Saturday January 06, 2024 @11:51AM (#38892941)
Useful. Thanks