News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by paxys on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:34AM (#38841982)
Artists want to be paid per stream rather than get a fixed amount.

Users want to pay a fixed monthly fee and get unlimited access.

Spotify has figured out the best way to combine the two, and this involves pooling all the money paid by all users – regardless of what they listen to – and then allotting it to artists based on the number of streams they served to the platform.

Yes this means that plenty of users are subsidizing artists they don't like, but this is also what works best for everyone in the system. Trying to paint it as "fair" or "unfair" is pointless.

Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by jp57 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @09:54AM (#38842228)
Yeah. I said “a constant amount to the artist for every stream.” So yes. Per stream.
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by terminous on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:48AM (#38842794)
Yeah pretty much no normal consumer wants to pay per stream.
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by jp57 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @04:49PM (#38847570)
There are plenty of flat-rate customer billing models that would support paying artists a fixed price per stream. If the argument is that it would be "too expensive" -- i.e. it would end up paying the artists "too much" -- well, that's something to think about, isn't it?
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by danaris on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @12:10PM (#38843998)
> Spotify has figured out the best way to combine the two

This seems to be begging the question.

Spotify has figured out a way to combine the two. Many people clearly feel that it is not the best way, and some that it is not even working.

Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by chrisco255 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:14AM (#38842462)
It doesn't work better for niche artists and it makes it very hard for new music to get revenue.
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by pc86 on Tuesday January 02, 2024 @10:47AM (#38842789)
"Niche artists" sounds like another way to say "artists nobody listens to" so it seems like a bad business decision to try to create a model that would funnel money their way, doesn't it?
Re:Reductive Thinking and the Unfairness of Spotify Payments by chrisco255 on Friday January 05, 2024 @10:06AM (#38879805)
No, they should be paid proportional to their listeners. As it is, it's the popular artists being subsidized by the niche music fans. Niche music should get the niche music fan revenue. Very simple concept. If there are 1M niche genre music fans and they're spending 100% of their time listening to that genre, their money should go to that genre, not siphon it off to popular artists.

Otherwise we get no new genres, no innovation, aand fewer up and coming artists.