Users want to pay a fixed monthly fee and get unlimited access.
Spotify has figured out the best way to combine the two, and this involves pooling all the money paid by all users – regardless of what they listen to – and then allotting it to artists based on the number of streams they served to the platform.
Yes this means that plenty of users are subsidizing artists they don't like, but this is also what works best for everyone in the system. Trying to paint it as "fair" or "unfair" is pointless.
This seems to be begging the question.
Spotify has figured out a way to combine the two. Many people clearly feel that it is not the best way, and some that it is not even working.
Otherwise we get no new genres, no innovation, aand fewer up and coming artists.
I'd also argue that "fairness" is not really that important. One could in theory charge a fixed monthly rate to customers and pay a fixed constant fee to artists as long as the company's finances work out favorably. It's not really the customer's business how the company's costs are distributed.