Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by thadk on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:18PM
(#38785452)
Is it possible that Apple is fighting so hard on this because the Masimo patent also covers applications in blood glucose which Apple has sunken nearly a decade of intense fairly independent R&D into at this point?
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by HumblyTossed on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:01PM
(#38785286)
Isn’t this backwards? They don’t validate a patent but assume it is until it is invalidated.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by hedora on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:30PM
(#38785583)
That’s the beauty of this process from a patent troll perspective. It is expedited, and therefore can’t be blocked by having a proper review that could invalidate the patent.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by andsoitis on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:52PM
(#38785841)
> That’s the beauty of this process from a patent troll perspective
I know you didn't draw the connection explicitly, but I just wanted to point out that in this particular case, Masimo isn't a patent troll - they're a company that sells actual devices - https://www.masimopersonalhealth.com and is listed on the NASDAQ with market cap of $6 billion.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by mergejoin on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @05:56PM
(#38787894)
Within the healthcare sector, Masimo is well-known to use very aggressive legal procedures against their competitors.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by pests on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @07:53PM
(#38788721)
And? Nintendo is known to use very aggressive legal procedures against their own customers but they are still a beloved company.
What does expressing their legal rights / etc have to do with morality?
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by NewJazz on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @08:10PM
(#38788821)
Well known would imply multiple sources. I see none.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by dmd on Thursday December 28, 2023 @07:20AM
(#38792733)
Well, as someone who works in the healthcare sector - it’s a household name, like “Philips” or “Baxter” or “Medtronic”.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by matwood on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:54PM
(#38785867)
I’ll add that many were already invalidated as part of the ongoing legal battle. Apple was also not found to be infringing on others. There are only a few left in question at this point. Given the direction it has gone so far, Apple has a pretty good chance of being found to not infringe on any of them.
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by gnicholas on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:03PM
(#38785294)
IIRC the ITC can rule that patents are invalid (or not infringed). ITC trials are more expedited than patent trials in District Courts, and an appeals court would also do a deeper dive. But that doesn't mean that the ITC's determination of infringement doesn't indicate that the ITC also found them to be valid. It's also possible that Apple didn't raise this argument at the ITC trial, but that would be very unlikely (it's one of the most obvious arguments to make when being sued for patent infringement).
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by justahuman74 on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:48PM
(#38785133)
I'd presumed that patents are presumed valid unless invalidated (which I think is a problem in itself)
Re:Apple wins bid to pause Apple Watch ban at US appeals court
by ClumsyPilot on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @02:46PM
(#38785769)
What? If you presume that a patent is invalid, then what is the patent office for?
You pay them to make sure the patent in valid before granting it. Why would one part of the government always preaume that the other part of the government is wrong?
In all likelihood, the patent will eventually be tossed out, but that process takes a year or two.