News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Chisel: A Modern Hardware Design Language by UncleOxidant on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @12:49PM (#38784438)
> For example SystemVerilog has no real typing which sucks, so a typical thing to do is to build a massively improved type system for a new HDL. However in my experience good use of verilog style guides and decent linting tools solves most of the problem

This is why I prefer VHDL. It's strongly typed. I worked at an EDA company on an HLS tool that generated HDL (Verilog, VHDL and SystemC). Customers would report linting problems with the generated Verilog. Since backend code generation was what I worked on I got to fix them. We had almost 0 problems with the generated VHDL mostly due to strong typing. But lots of issues with the generated Verilog that needed fixing.

> Another typical improvement you'll find in an alternative HDL is vastly improved parameterization and generics

Another area where VHDL was already there. SystemVerilog makes some improvements over Verilog.

Re:Chisel: A Modern Hardware Design Language by gchadwick on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:05PM (#38784647)
Yeah I should really get around to learning VHDL!
Re:Chisel: A Modern Hardware Design Language by ur-whale on Wednesday December 27, 2023 @01:27PM (#38784901)
> This is why I prefer VHDL. It's strongly typed.

I agree, and I must say I feel much "safer" when coding in VHDL than I do in Verilog, but OTOH, VHDL's strong typing sometimes cuts the other way.

I have found myself way too many times at the receiving end of VHDL's type system furiously trying to prevent me from casting something of type A to something of type B when I knew the underlying bit representation made the cast absolutely trivial.