News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @06:56AM (#38761877)
> That's up for a through debate, but not today

Were it not for Tesla, America wouldn’t be on a path towards electrified transport. The tradeoffs are incredibly germane to the topic.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by lucideer on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:29AM (#38762417)
> on a path towards electrified transport

If not for Tesla, America (& the Western world in general) might not be on a path towards private inefficient electrified road transport, leaving much more room for investment in & upselling of vastly more sustainable non-road transport, as has been done in China.

Musk in particular has form here - consistently blocking & derailing all potential high-speed rail projects for the west coast in favour of white elephants (the material result being a maintained reliance on roads, and - by extension - his big cobalt-mine-dependent business).

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:33AM (#38762449)
> derailing all potential high-speed rail projects for the west coast

Musk ran California’s high-speed rail through the Central Valley?

I like public transport. But America isn’t built for it. Switching to trains would mean upending and dissolving tens of millions’ communities. There was no other path without EVs and trains galore; it was—and is—between EVs and ICE cars.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by beedeebeedee on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:59AM (#38763103)
> I like public transport. But America isn’t built for it.

You mean, America was un-built from it. We had it, but the car and oil industry lobbied it away. We can rebuild it. Don't believe the hype.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by lucideer on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:50AM (#38763016)
> Musk ran

Seems a very honest interpretation of events to purport that Musk has had no influence over transport in California.

> America isn’t built for it.

That rhetoric is used the world over as an excuse to bolster against progressive innovation of all kinds. It's been debunked countless times. "Dissolving" communities to make way for rail is of course also nonsense.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by badpun on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:10AM (#38763215)
Weren't communities dissolved to build the massive highway network US has?
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:49PM (#38765518)
> Weren't communities dissolved to build the massive highway network US has?

Yes. It was traumatic and widely regarded as a mistake. Given the precedent, and our massively increased per-capita resources today versus in the post-War era, you'd be fighting an army of suburban Jane Jacobs to remake America à la China or Europe.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by seanmcdirmid on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:34AM (#38763416)
China also would have invested heavily in EVs regardless of Tesla. They simply don’t have much oil, and importing it is a huge national security problem for them. Couple that with their huge pollution problem and tons of cars even with lots of mass transit options, EVs were inevitable and already coming along before the model 3 came out.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by DennisP on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:36AM (#38772098)
China may be investing in rail but that doesn't seem to be incompatible with BEV adoption. As of 2022, 22% of all new car sales in China were electrics.[1] In the US it was only 6% that year[2], and looks to be about 8% for 2023.[3]

[1] https://www.wri.org/insights/countries-adopting-electric-veh...

[2] https://cleantechnica.com/2023/02/25/us-electric-car-sales-i...

[3] https://electrek.co/2023/10/12/ev-sales-7-9-us-market-volvo-...

(Side note: the standard-range Teslas use lithium iron-phosphate batteries which don't contain cobalt.)

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by Someone on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:36AM (#38762122)
> Were it not for Tesla, America wouldn’t be on a path towards electrified transport

That, too, is up for discussion, but not for now. I’ll leave it by saying that, without Tesla willing to sell cars at a loss for a long time, it might be a bit less further on that path, but I think California and/or the EU would have forced it by now to get on that path, by setting goals for cars sold within their jurisdictions (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/California_effect, https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Brussels_effect)

There also can be discussion about whether Tesla’s path is the right pat, but that definitely is for another time.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:44AM (#38762162)
> California and/or the EU would have forced it by now to get on that path

For hybrids, maybe. California is a major oil producer [1]. That lobby counterbalanced the environmental wing for decades. If there wasn’t a mass-market EV, Sacramento wouldn’t have had many options.

> that definitely is for another time

Lol, is this a thing now? We’re obviously discussing it at this time.

[1] https://www.eia.gov/dnav/pet/pet_crd_crpdn_adc_mbbl_m.htm

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by fsloth on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:01AM (#38762262)
Without Tesla German incumbents would have lobbied EU just to mandate biofuels and there would be fever EV:s. Tesla did drag an industry kicking and screaming to EVs.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by mensetmanusman on Monday December 25, 2023 @03:02PM (#38765636)
They would have made new ICE vehicles that have zero emissions! (during testing only)
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by richardw on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:44AM (#38762525)
You think the GM and Ford gigafactories would have taken up the slack, ignoring the chance to milk existing ICE investments for another decade? The charging network would have spontaneously emerged and somehow been as good as what Tesla delivers?
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by mensetmanusman on Monday December 25, 2023 @03:02PM (#38765626)
They tried to force it with regulation, but everyone just cheated on emission tests instead.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by gizmo on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:21AM (#38762021)
I doubt that. The innovation in lithium ion batteries was fueled by the demand for consumer electronics, laptops in particular. It’s the batteries that made electric cars possible.

Tesla’s did kick off the trend of big screens in cars. I prefer buttons to touch screen interactions while driving, but many people want an iPad and Tesla made that happen.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:34AM (#38762111)
> innovation in lithium ion batteries was fueled by the demand for consumer electronics, laptops in particular

The battery chemistry and production methods didn’t change fundamentally from Goodenough’s formulation. What did was scale manufacturing. China took the lead, with A123’s tech. But Tesla showed there was demand for EVs in the rich world, and that production could be tamed such that money could be made from it. (EV batteries share little to no production footprint with cells for consumer electronics. They drain differently.)

Pretty much every EV sold in America today was financed by investors looking for the next Tesla, or announced by manufacturers in response to Tesla.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by bayindirh on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:33AM (#38762106)
Giving where credit's due, some of the high-discharge long-endurance Li-Ion research is done by Tesla. Other electronic devices generally converge towards slow-discharge, semi-fast charge, low self-discharge batteries.

EVs are unique in their battery requirements. They demand high-discharge, high-endurance, very fast charge batteries, and Tesla did some research on that front. What's important that they were not the sole researchers in that area.

On the other hand, they lack the know-how required to make cars efficiently and assemble them with state of the art methods (minimal/standardized fasteners, fatigue management, fast manufacturing with consistent quality and finishing, etc.).

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by gizmo on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:26AM (#38763353)
The Roadster used completely standard 18650 cells that were already in mass production.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by DennisP on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:52AM (#38772222)
Tesla's manufacturing has come a long way in the past few years. In 2018, Sandy Munro famously tore down the new Model 3 with a lot of criticism for things like their excess of parts, fasteners, and welds. They made a lot of changes, including some he suggested, and now Munro tends to rave about how well they're engineered for ease of manufacture. This is a guy who gets paid by Big 3 auto companies to help improve their manufacturing.

A great visual is this video of someone snapping together much of a Model Y like legos, in ten minutes by himself: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lawGMl8sHzc

Another fun one is Munro's comparison of the thermal management systems for a Model Y and Ford Mach-E: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=m1kHsd3Ocxc

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by _Algernon_ on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:16AM (#38761998)
Even if we take for granted that Tesla is a net positive, Tesla isn't SV. For every Tesla there is a Facebook that is a net negative. Just ask Myanmar.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:00AM (#38762254)
> Tesla isn't SV. For every Tesla there is a Facebook

Totally agree. But looking at specifics, and dissecting why they work or do not, helps suss out patterns.

For example, Tesla’s benefits are amplified—perhaps even characterised—by their ecosystem effect. That doesn’t happen when you have a quasi-monopoly like Facebook. On the other hand, their downsides are largely a function of lying. That’s common across Silicon Valley, and may similarly have a systematic treatment. (Or, at least, if you’re replicating the model, consider removing that in your iteration.)

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by nickpp on Monday December 25, 2023 @08:05AM (#38762280)
TV helped changing quite a few regimes in history, and not always for the better. However, I do not think anybody would dispute the fact that TV was, overall, a net positive for mankind.

Same with Silicon Valley. There are certain negative aspects to it but overall we are discussing this on the amazing supercomputer it created, with software it wrote, on platforms it maintains [1]. I seriously doubt the majority of people would want to go back to a world without SV's innovations.

[1] of course it wasn't SV alone, there were many contributions from all around the world, it's just that SV spearheaded the changes and lead us on this path.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by _Algernon_ on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:19AM (#38763297)
I can't recall him ever writing black on white that TV was a net negative for humanity, but the thesis of Neil Postmans Amusing Ourselves to Death seems to heavily imply it. It is - as far as I can tell - a pretty influencial thesis on these matters.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by nickpp on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:28AM (#38772028)
I am sure some aristocrats somewhere are pissed off that we’re not all listening to Bach and reading Kant for our entertainment, but that does not make TV a net negative. It just shows once again that we (as a society) should never give power to various “experts” over our individual choices.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by seanmcdirmid on Monday December 25, 2023 @10:37AM (#38763442)
> Just ask Myanmar

Do you mean the military dictatorship? I’m not sure if they are reliable sources. But yes, Myanmar blames lots of their ethnic violence problems on Facebook, it couldn’t be bad governance at all right?

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by _Algernon_ on Monday December 25, 2023 @11:57AM (#38764106)
As with most things it's probably a combination of factors, one of which is Facebook essentially monopolising internet access in the country while stoking the fire.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by seanmcdirmid on Monday December 25, 2023 @12:22PM (#38764326)
YouTube would also be popular, in most of SEA the internet means mostly Facebook and YouTube, to the chagrin of Chinese internet services who can’t even compete outside of China in their own backyard (well, TikTok is hugely popular there, as it is here, Myanmar is also blaming TikTok and YouTube for ethnic violence, so it just isn’t Facebook). But I’m not sure how Facebooks‘s popularity equals a monopoly, they aren't engaging in anti competitive behavior, the infrastructure is free for use by competitors. The only thing Facebook puts in beyond other markets is localization and marketing.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by _Algernon_ on Monday December 25, 2023 @03:33PM (#38765848)
Because they offered free service only to Facebook in developing countries (including Myanmar) using their FreeBASIC program[1], thereby establishing a defacto monopoly and building a anti-competetive moat against any competitors.

[1]: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Internet.org

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by seanmcdirmid on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:58PM (#38766526)
That would only be true if other companies couldn’t do that as well, like google did. And also, this hadn’t impeded TikTok’s ability to take market share away from Google when it became popular.
Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpinJack_Cash on Monday December 25, 2023 @02:07PM (#38765160)
> > For every Tesla there is a Facebook that is a net negative. Just ask Myanmar.

It's the opposite, Tesla is a huge net negative, whereas Facebook is a huge net positive.

People are so weird these days, they come to hate the stuff that they use everyday and idolise stuff that would never use nor need to use

I believe it has to do with the fact that most people really aren't happy with themselves or their lives

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by bayindirh on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:14AM (#38761987)
I look SV's effect on global scale, because I neither live in the US, nor located on the continent itself. Also, the debate is about SV's global impact at full spectrum, not only about Tesla.

So, yes, it's up for debate.

Lastly this doesn't change the fact that Tesla fared the worst in the automaking competition this year w.r.t. everyone else, and they're faking till they're making it. More automakers are always good, but more pretending is always bad (cough VW, Cummins, cough).

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpCrisscross on Monday December 25, 2023 @07:23AM (#38762036)
> So, yes, it's up for debate

I never disagreed. I’m saying the case at hand, EVs, provide a potent balance of the tradeoffs Silicon Valley’s methods involve.

On one hand, you get the capacity for transformational change. Change that can be for the general good. On the other hand, we have costs ranging from a culture of normalised lying to ideological nothingburgers gaining currency due to their proximity to, well, currency.

Put another way, remove Silicon Valley from the equation and yes, we have safer cars. But we also have little reason to be optimistic about ever hitting carbon zero in this country. The latter is more globally relevant than the former.

Re:Breakdown of faults by car brand: Tesla has replaced Daci... by JumpinJack_Cash on Monday December 25, 2023 @01:18PM (#38764751)
> > America wouldn’t be on a path towards electrified transport

And that is good news because? So that 100 year from now the avg temperature would be 0.005C less because we'd have substitued the black pollutant produced by Arabs with Star and Stipes Lithium (or lithium which comes from countries that are in the sphere of influence of the US)

This effort is a spit in the face of people who are alive and have big problems right now, that's the reason why they are engaging in rolling coal as a form of protest against this nonsense.