Re:Commentary on Xunzi's "Discourse on Heaven"
by hmm37 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:33PM
(#38756050)
I would actually say that for Confucians, it's Confucius, Mencius then Zhu Xi. Xunzi comes 4th, and was regarded a bit heterodox.
Re:Commentary on Xunzi's "Discourse on Heaven"
by HuShifang on Sunday December 24, 2023 @02:55PM
(#38756251)
Yes, but as I said, I was talking about early Confucians.
Re:Commentary on Xunzi's "Discourse on Heaven"
by hmm37 on Sunday December 24, 2023 @04:05PM
(#38756859)
Oh. I missed that. In that case wouldn't Confucius grandson (子思) be higher up? After all he supposedly taught Mencius and wrote the Doctrine of the Mean 中庸, and that work is considered standard reading, while reading Xunzi would have been probably only read when you're already a scholar and mastered pretty much everything else.
That said, perhaps the Doctrine of the Mean wasn't considered all that important despite being part of the Book of Rites (礼记), or rather it wasn't considered prominent until around the Song dynasty.
That said, I had a teacher years ago from Taiwan who argued that 1) Xunzi was the first full-blown "philosopher" (in the Western sense of offering an epistemology etc and arguing in a logically reasoned way) in Chinese history, and that 2) Xunzi and Zhuangzi were the smartest Chinese thinkers of all time. Years later, I'm not sure she was wrong.