News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by jdewerd on Saturday December 23, 2023 @01:25PM (#38746597)
I've probably heard 1000 Bayesians rant about the alleged Frequentist consensus and 0 Frequentists complain about Bayesian analysis. I'd need some pretty steep priors to interpret this as anything other than the academic equivalent of "one WEIRD trick THEY don't want you to know" marketing.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by exe34 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:37PM (#38747370)
Every single statistics class I've ever taken or been sent to has been 95% frequentist with a rushed Bayesian digression near the end. I've submitted papers with Bayesian work and the reviewer asked for p-values and would not budge. I gave him his bloody p-values, because I could not afford not to get the paper published that early in my career.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by jdewerd on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:55PM (#38747530)
There's always a more complicated model.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by zozbot234 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @03:05PM (#38747649)
The "more complicated" version of frequentist statistics is called robust statistics. There's most likely a way to rephrase your favorite Bayesian analysis so as to make it fully kosher from a "robust+frequentist" point of view, even keeping the math unchanged. It just goes to show how silly the "controversy" is.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by PheonixPharts on Saturday December 23, 2023 @05:32PM (#38748951)
Bayesian statistics is fundamentally less complicated than Frequentist statistics since everything can be derived from a very simple set of first principles, rather than complex frameworks of ad hoc testing methodologies.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by ivan_ah on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:02PM (#38754795)
> Bayesian statistics is fundamentally less complicated than Frequentist statistics [...]

I broadly agree with you, but I'm wondering if you would reconsider your qualification as "less complicated" if you consider beginner learners. E.g. someone who knows basic descriptive statistics and probability theory, and is making first contact with inferential statistics. Specifically, assume a learner who knows what an integral is, but is far from proficient with it (UGRAD student, not a GRAD student).

I was reading this paper[1] recently, which highlights two difficulties of teaching Bayesian stats: 1) the mathematical complexity of understanding conditional probability distributions, and 2) the lack of well defined, broadly accepted conventions for what priors to use in specific data analysis scenarios.

I think a computational approach to prob theory could mitigate 1), but 2) remains a problem—the freedom to choose priors, is also a burden...

[1] https://www.stat.purdue.edu/~dsmoore/articles/BayesPedagogy....

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by ivan_ah on Sunday December 24, 2023 @12:29PM (#38754996)
For context, I'm not taking sides in the frequentist-vs-Bayesian debate, but coming from a practical problem: I'm working on a INTRO TO STATS book right now, and I would like to include a chapter on Bayesian statistics, but I'm not sure what specific analyses to showcase and recommend as "standard" approaches. Unlike the canonical t-tests and ANOVAs of frequentists, Bayesian statistics doesn't have canonical procedures (that I know of) that I can wholeheartedly recommend as "must know" and ready to use broadly.

Maybe someone here might have suggestions?

The closest thing that comes to mind is "Bayes factors," which has some traction (usage), but apparently they have lots of problems and limitations too, cf. https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=MqeWpR6S4XA

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by maltelau on Monday December 25, 2023 @04:27PM (#38766286)
Maybe you would find it useful to read a textbook on bayesian stats for inspiration. I can recommend Richard McElreath's "Statistical Rethinking" which makes it very clear how inflexible it is to just know recipes like t-tests or anovas.

The canonical approach is to build a generative model with a parameter (or multiple for ~anova) that codes for the difference between groups and do inference on that parameter of interest. Most of the recipes taught in statistics classes can be modelled as a regression of some kind (this counts for frequentist stats too, see https://lindeloev.github.io/tests-as-linear/ ). Some advocate to do that inference with bayes factors. Others, like discussed elsewhere in this thread, advocate combining the resulting posterior with a cost/value function, but either way the lesson is that there is less focus on "t-test-vs-anova" because they're the same thing anyways.

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by ivan_ah on Tuesday December 26, 2023 @09:01PM (#38778274)
Thanks for the "Statistical Rethinking" recommendation. I had watched some of McElreath's lectures so I knew of the book, but next year I think I'm finally going to read it from end to end and follow along the 2024 course schedule: https://github.com/rmcelreath/stat_rethinking_2024#calendar-...

I had previously started the BDA course, which is another famous Bayesian course, see https://avehtari.github.io/BDA_course_Aalto/ but I didn't finish it due to travel.

No more excuses in 2024... time to level-up the Bayesian modelling skill ;)

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by throwawaymaths on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:26PM (#38747250)
There's always room for a first time.

Bayesian statistics is sound but I suspect it's often just used to justify biases. It is technically valid to use a prior and de facto never update it, because you know I'll get around to updating my prior next week, or... eventually, cough cough let's be honest, never

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by marcosdumay on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:05PM (#38748228)
Bayesian statistics is the one where you must state your bias explicitly, and justify them one by one under the light.

It's the frequentist one that gets your biases implicitly, on the form of corrections and hypothesis formulation, so that people don't notice them.

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by derbOac on Saturday December 23, 2023 @07:12PM (#38749629)
I don't know. I've published Bayesian methodology papers and reviewed them and although I might call myself an objective Bayesianist maybe, Bayesianism has its own implicit biases. In the very least, I think it can take advantage of implicit biases people have in interpreting analyses.

One issue is that Bayes estimates are almost always produced, even if no information is coming from empirical data, and all the information is coming from a prior. So it's possible to produce results heavily influenced by the prior with Bayesian estimation that with frequentist methods would fail completely because of lack of identification of the model, sending a strong signal that something is wrong. This can all be sussed out with Bayesian methods but people often don't do it.

Another more subtle issue is people aren't quite aware of how a prior can deviate from "maximal conservativism". Sometimes, for example, depending on the model, a very flat prior is actually not conservative, and is overweighting tails.

There's other examples too. Basically, yes, Bayesianism forces you to be explicit with your biases, but people are really bad at interpreting the actual impact of those biases in a formal Bayesian framework, or at least, aren't any better at it than with frequentist methods that are available.

If you approach statistical inference from the perspective of accuracy (as the linked paper seems to do) Bayesianism is better to the extent the priors are accurate. This is true a lot of the time empirically, but it does lead to a kind of tautology, in that you're doing the analysis because you don't really know what "truth" is. So if you're right in your priors, Bayesianism is accurate, but then you didn't really need new data as much in the first place; if you're wrong, it's more biased. Basically in the bias-variance tradeoff, Bayesianism makes a bet on reduced variance assuming that the resulting bias will be small enough.

Philosophically, though, there's a completely different argument, which is one of competitive fairness. You might say this doesn't matter, but consider consequential decisions, like hiring or admissions decisions: if someone was making a prediction about you, would you want them to use a strong prior, or something that's maximally conservative and fair?

This philosophy leads to frequentism basically.

My preference is to be maximally conservative in a Bayesian framework, which leads to reference priors, which are often flat in many canonical situations, which is basically frequentism. In other situations you might have a different kind of prior.

To me the linked paper is pretty interesting and makes a good point. On the other hand, I'd rather not make any assumptions about a new result based on past studies on other effects. I'd rather just collect lots of diverse real data and meta-analyze it. There's no substitute for data -- and that includes priors.

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by light_hue_1 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @04:21PM (#38748355)
Yes, because Frequentists won a long time ago. And are responsible for producing garbage science ever since.

Of course the winners don't rant about anything. But any time we probe the consequences of Frequentist statistics they turn out to be horrific for science, our health, and our planet.

Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by therobots927 on Monday December 25, 2023 @09:11AM (#38762733)
How so? What’s an example of that?
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by paulsutter on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:12PM (#38747118)
If we were allowed one super-upvote per month, I would use mine right now on your comment
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by selimthegrim on Saturday December 23, 2023 @02:56PM (#38747552)
Dang is going to file this under the Bumble model of HN monetization in his desk drawer
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by causality0 on Saturday December 23, 2023 @03:28PM (#38747879)
There are times I'd be willing to pay a fiver to un-flag my comment.
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by jowea on Saturday December 23, 2023 @05:43PM (#38749036)
Or just HN Gold
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by abecedarius on Saturday December 23, 2023 @11:06PM (#38751012)
The frequentist ranting was concentrated around a century ago +/- one lifetime, and they called the enemy "inverse probability" (when being polite).
Re:Bayesians Moving from Defense to Offense by kgwgk on Monday December 25, 2023 @05:31PM (#38766853)
"Inverse probability" is just what statistical inference was called before frequentist ideas were introduced. It was in the second half of the last century when the "Bayesian" label was introduced - amusingly in opposition to the much newer "classical" methods.