When LLM's start going to jail for killing people then we can consider them equivalent. Until that happens, they must be held to a higher standard specifically because the incentives aren't there otherwise.
What could be changed to make autonomous driving more acceptable without improving the underlying tech, but improving the blame game in law and civil liability?
Instead of letting AI in alpha state on the streets, I rather vote for consequently removing the worse humans, by making regular tests for everyone mandatory. Not discriminate by age, but by skill. And AI can come, after we stop seeing all those fails of them on youtube.
Now, care to guess why this isn't already the case?
The fact that they're a bad driver is only provable after they're in an accident from their own fault. And even then, it's only grievious fault that they get banned from driving (such as drunk driving).
However, this standard is not applied to autonomous driving, since they can pass the human driving test and yet is not accepted as capable.
And even if they did, AI are trained by rewiring their brains directly. It's not a 1:1 match to punishments for humans (or animals), but it is a de facto incentive.
My previous example was intended to illustrate the threat of jail is not a huge incentive to humans because humans don't take it seriously even though it exists — we think it's for other people, not people like us.
Further I would suggest LLMs can be incentivised by jail even without experiencing jail, just because they happened to have descriptions of jail in their training set.
When your brain messes up and you have an accident, isn't that a pretty similar scenario?
Sometimes people make misstakes - some more than others and we do tests to determine whether a human can do a job good enough by its results, without examining their brains.
With autonomous cars it can be the same. Lots of tests - and if it safely can handle complex situations reliable - that would be good enough for me. (But I think we are currently pretty far from it)