News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 21, 2023 @04:36PM (#38727322)
Pumped hydro is geographically limited. You might as well say we should just build more dams to decarbonize the electric grid.
Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by mayama on Thursday December 21, 2023 @10:34PM (#38730672)
Offriver closed loop pumped hydro just needs two football size fields hundreds of meter apart in elevation. Most continents have plenty of suitable locations for PHS, though they are distributed unevenly. According to the paper, there are 600k feasible locations for PHS world wide, or capacity to store 70% of global energy demand in 2017.

https://www.nature.com/articles/s41467-020-14555-y

Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by Manuel_D on Thursday December 21, 2023 @11:45PM (#38731026)
> Offriver closed loop pumped hydro just needs two football size fields hundreds of meter apart in elevation

A football field sized reservoir isn't going to hold much water unless it's deep. Realistic pumped hydro sites are much larger than 500 square meters. And those two reservoirs can't be too far apart, because excess lateral distance reduces output and increases the energy required to refill it.

It also needs to be close to a source of water in order to fill the reservoir and refill any loss due to evaporation.

It also needs to be close to a major highway otherwise the costs of construction will be immense because of the long distance that materials and equipment must be shipped. This is particularly problematic because most pumped hydro potential is in mountainous terrain where transportation is expensive.

And lastly, this site has to be close to places that have energy demand, otherwise you'll need to build miles and miles of transmission lines. This is also a problem because the places that have pumped hydro potential also have hydroelectric potential, and usually already generate electricity from dams. Norway and Brazil have huge pumped hydro potential, but already generate most electricity from dams.

The conditions for a viable pumped hydro sites are much more narrow than "two football field sized reservoir a few hundred meters apart in elevation".

The paper you cited just ran an algorithm over a terrain height map. It did not attempt to account for accessibility. Good luck developing the immense pumped hydro potential in Tibet. Pumped hydro would be great if we could teleport concrete, excavators, and turbo machinery into some of the most remote parts of the world. But unfortunately this is not in our capabilities.

Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by adrianN on Friday December 22, 2023 @03:21AM (#38732142)
Even if the 70% of global energy demand in 2017 estimate is off by a factor of five or so, that's still plenty of storage to cover for renewable intermittency.
Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by Manuel_D on Friday December 22, 2023 @04:18AM (#38732449)
I wouldn't be surprised if less than 1% of the identified hydroelectric sites were viable to build at all, and 0.1% were more cost competitive than batteries. Huge amounts of the identified hydropower sites are located in Tibet, which is far too remote to conduct big construction projects. Another big region with hydro electric storage potential is Brazil. But they already generate almost all of their electricity from renewables and they don't need pumped hydro. Again, the paper you cited just ran an algorithm over a height map. There was zero consideration of proximity to transportation, proximity to energy demand, and proximity to water to fill the reservoirs.
Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by defrost on Friday December 22, 2023 @04:29AM (#38732525)
There are other fun options, a number already tested and being expanded upon.

China is building several "gravity towers" (different design to [1] but same concept), Australia is designing third generation (after a 1MW test pilot, and current 288MWh plant under construction) high temperature molten salt thermal energy storage tanks to night time buffer solar plants used to produce green methanol for use as a sustainable shipping fuel.

[1] https://www.wired.com/story/energy-vault-gravity-storage/

[2] https://reneweconomy.com.au/australias-biggest-solar-thermal...

Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by Manuel_D on Friday December 22, 2023 @05:30AM (#38732880)
None of these have actually been used for grid storage. Heated sand has been used for district heating, but electric generation is more challenging because it requires higher temperature gradients. There's plenty of other ideas people are pursing: hydrogen electrolysis, compressed air, giant flywheels, ammonia, I could go on.

Why are people exploring all these alternative energy storage methods? Because grid storage is not feasible with current storage options. We're still looking for the silver bullet to solve grid storage. Will these new ideas yield storage at lower cost than the existing systems? Maybe, maybe not. A grid powered by primarily intermittent sources is viable if such a silver bullet is found, but that's a pretty big if to bet the future of the electric grid on. A very realistic outlook for wind and solar is that we saturate peak production, waste a ton of excess electricity, and keep burning fossil fuels because the silver bullet never materializes.

Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by defrost on Friday December 22, 2023 @07:02PM (#38740231)
> None of these have actually been used for grid storage.

So what? As is clearly implicit to the meanest intellect in my comment above these are alternatives that are being built right now after having already passed pilot testing and now being scaled up for grid storage.

> A very realistic outlook for wind and solar is that we

overproduce during daytime here in Australia, have sufficient wind through much of the night to tick over, and use the excess to produce green hydrogen, ammonia, methonal, etc to buffer nighttime demand and for use in mining, transport and agriculture.

Re:Nuclear energy is more expensive than renewables, CSIRO r... by Manuel_D on Friday December 22, 2023 @09:04PM (#38740973)
> So what? As is clearly implicit to the meanest intellect in my comment above these are alternatives that are being built right now after having already passed pilot testing and now being scaled up for grid storage.

No, they are not. They are still in the prototype stages. Gravity storage is still being prototyped. Heated sand is only being used for district heating. If you've got news about a real production deployment of grid storage using these systems, I'd be eager to read it.

> and use the excess to produce green hydrogen, ammonia, methonal [sic], etc to buffer nighttime demand

If we find a feasible way of doing these things. These storage schemes are theoretically possible, but as of yet they are not demonstrated to be viable at grid scale. The reason why most of the talk is around batteries is because they're the most viable storage option at the moment. Will one of the systems you listed deliver much better grid scale storage? Maybe, maybe not.

If your point is that intermittent sources are viable contingent on an energy storage breakthrough, then yeah I'm in agreement. But it's not exactly wise to bet the future of your electrical grid on a technological breakthrough that may or may not happen.