News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by duskwuff on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:44PM (#38631117)
This option was almost certainly a holdover from the bad old 32-bit x86 days, when disabling frame pointers gave you a seventh valuable general-purpose register. It's no longer beneficial on x86_64 -- even with rbp locked down, you still have fourteen registers there.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by jandrese on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:09PM (#38632587)
Yeah, back in the 32 bit days -fomit-frame-pointer was the only optimization you could count on to really make a difference. It wasn't small either, often 10-15% speedup. No other flag on gcc would make even a full percentage difference in my testing.

The Amd64 architecture fixed the underlying problem, so this is pretty much just a holdover. I'm surprised they even enabled it by default.

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by grrandalf on Thursday December 14, 2023 @11:04AM (#38642817)
(iirc) I think I used `-fomit-frame-pointer` with DJGPP on DOS on a 486. It was an [unimpressive :)] software-rendered 3D graphics demo, and I was very happy with the substantial free speedup I got.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by cesarb on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:25PM (#38632848)
To emphasize this point: on 64-bit x86 with frame pointers, you have twice as many registers as on 32-bit x86 without frame pointers, and these registers are twice as wide. A 64-bit value (more common than you'd expect even when pointers are 32 bits) takes two registers on 32-bit x86, but only a single register on 64-bit x86.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by jamesfinlayson on Thursday December 14, 2023 @02:54AM (#38638900)
So there's no point in disabling frame pointers for 32-bit code running on a 64-bit processor then?
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by bodyfour on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:01PM (#38633407)
That much is true -- the difference between 6 and 7 registers is much larger than the benefit of going from 14 to 15.

However, even under zero register pressure having a frame pointer is still an extra register that needs to be touched on every function invocation, extra instructions taking space in the I-cache, etc. It's a small thing, but it's still a cost that has to be paid by all compiled code.

I'm not going to claim that re-enabling frame pointers was the wrong choice -- the people involved in the debate know the tradeoffs and I have to start with the assumption that I would have made the same decision if I were in their position. It does make me slightly sad, though. The idea behind removing frame pointers isn't that backtraces aren't important, it's that computing the frame pointer after-the-fact is possible -- i.e. for normal functions without alloca() or dynamically-sized stack arrays map %rip -> frame size.

The problem seems to be that despite years of experience with "no-frame-pointer" being the default I guess the profiling tools never got as reliable or good as the with-frame-pointer variants. My personal hope was that the problem would fade over time as tools improved, but it seems that's unlikely to ever happen. After all, once no-frame-pointer stops being the default there won't be any pressure for tools to improve. The towel has been thrown in.

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by brancz on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @03:06PM (#38633457)
Profiling tools have already solved the ability to reliably unwind in the absence of frame pointers[1], but there are plenty of tools that this kind of investment is simply too much that it won't ever happen, like bpftrace or bcc-tools.

[1] https://www.polarsignals.com/blog/posts/2022/11/29/dwarf-bas...

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by account42 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @07:00AM (#38640440)
Do those tools really need to implement their own unwinding though? This really should just need to be implemented once in a library and then used wherever unwinding is needed.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by brancz on Thursday December 14, 2023 @09:59AM (#38642041)
With the combination of eBPF and DWARF-based it's not quite that simple, there's a pretty elaborate dance between user-space and kernel-space that needs to happen for this to work. With frame-pointers it's walking a linked list in kernel-space.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by rightbyte on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:26PM (#38634350)
Ye. Bytecode interpreters very much benefit from the extra register. And any function that looks similar to one.

I mean e.g. getter and setter functions get alot of extra code to run.

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by account42 on Thursday December 14, 2023 @07:03AM (#38640461)
Note that even without -fomit-frame-pointer, the compiler can still omit the frame pointer for in some cases. From the GCC documentation:

> Note that -fno-omit-frame-pointer doesn’t guarantee the frame pointer is used in all functions. Several targets always omit the frame pointer in leaf functions.

Fully inlined functions also won't have a seperate stack frame at all. I imaging that is is a big part why the perf impact of turning the frame pointer back on is as small as it is.

It however also means that a complete stack trace will still require using debugging information, in which case you don't really need a frame pointer at all.

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by brancz on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @12:57PM (#38631328)
100% the way I see it! On 32-bit the performance benefits is very major on just about everything, but not so on 64-bit.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by PaulDavisThe1st on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:01PM (#38632469)
and 14 registers should be enough for everyone!
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by mratsim on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:49PM (#38634637)
It's not. 14 is still low compared to other ISAs.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by peterfirefly on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:11PM (#38634909)
Spilling to an XMM register instead of memory is an option.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by kmeisthax on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:47PM (#38634613)
Also, apparently Intel is planning to extend x86_64 to 32 GPRs, with an extension called... sigh[0]... Intel APX[1]. So the overhead of frame pointers will be even lower in the future.

[0] Intel APX is extremely confusable with the iAPX 432, a failed non-x86 architecture Intel made that's completely unrelated to doubling the size of the x64 register file.

[1] https://www.intel.com/content/www/us/en/developer/articles/t...

Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by p1mrx on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @05:52PM (#38635350)
iAPX has been dead for almost 40 years; there probably won't be much confusion.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by hulitu on Thursday December 14, 2023 @03:22PM (#38646729)
It's not dead. It's sleeping.
Re:Ubuntu 24.04 LTS will enable frame pointers by default by p1mrx on Thursday December 14, 2023 @06:28PM (#38648893)
Intel processors prior to the 80386SL cannot sleep.