This is just "fashion" and you're arguing against a fashion. How on earth people can claim consciousness doesn't exist when you're entire experience is indeed consciousness is really the most difficult and petulant "fashion trend" imaginable.
Me: "Hey I really enjoyed that surf" Internet guy: "No you were just responding to your training data because you're just a LLM"
It's ridiculous.
I'm not saying this has any meaningful implications for day to day existence, the illusion is a strong one. But LLMs have really shrunk the parts of the human experience that can't be explained by basic principles down to a wafer so thin it might not exist. In my view it is to thin to be worth believing in, but people will argue.
If there is no direct experience, and it really is just an illusion, do you mind if I cut off your genitals ? Because even if existence is an illusion, being that illusion and experiencing it is still obviously relevant?
Seems like a breathtakingly awkward position to take.
1) Transexualism and congenital analgesia are both things, so that isn't a meaningful test of consciousness if that is what you are going for.
2) I personally would be extremely upset ... but anything going on with me being extremely upset can be explained with analogy to ChatGPT + a few hardware generations + maybe some minor tweaks that are easy to foresee but not yet researched. Everything that would happen would be built up from basic stimulus-response's mediated by a big neural net and a bit of memory.
These ideas aren't that new, there have been schools of Buddhist thought that have been exploring them for around 2,500 years if you want a group that has thought through this more thoroughly. Probably other traditions that I haven't met yet. It is just that the latest LLMs have really put some practical we-know-because-we-have-done-it muscle behind what was already a strong theory.
I'm not confident enough (yet?) to take that all the way to its logical conclusions in how I live, but I think the evidence is strongest for that interpretation.
No it isn't. I observe consciousness in myself, right?