News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by lstodd on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:03PM (#38621254)
Well, this sort of reinforces the point - there are about zero places in Europe where you have Wifi but do not have cheap almost-unlimited 4G/LTE. In fact it's wifi that's dying out here, the only thing that keeps it alive is that in a cafe setting it's still somewhat faster, and it eats a bit less battery.
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by eightysixfour on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:24PM (#38621449)
I’m not sure we are talking about the same thing - just because you have cheap unlimited 4G doesn’t mean you get that 4G signal in a basement. VoWifi lets you still call someone with your phone number when the signal is bad but you have wifi access…
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by lstodd on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:53PM (#38621682)
I was never into insisting to only talk on the phone from the basement of my medieval castle. The view from the battlements is much better.

We're not all jamesbondesque supervillains here.

Like I said above, for like $8/mo you have in fact unlimited 4G at decent speeds here. Or for idk maybe $15 you can get a gpon, unlimited traffic, 30+Mbit to the house, depending on local laziness of course. And that is for a rural place in Balkans, not something in more civilized places.

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by kelnos on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:42PM (#38621986)
I do love how, seemingly to counteract the US-centric nature of many discussions, some Europeans act as though Europe is this one homogeneous block where everything works the same everywhere.

I guarantee you there are quite a few people in various countries in Europe where they don't have great cellular coverage, whether because of their location, or because of the building materials used in whatever house or office building they spend a lot of time in.

Regardless, I don't really get the hate toward VoWifi. Like... it's an added option. In some cases it might be redundant (or worse than the normal VoLTE option), but... it's an added option, that you don't have to use, that can be a great fallback in some cases.

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by macNchz on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:36PM (#38621948)
I just got back from a week in Paris where I frequently had limited cell service indoors on a major provider. Even with antennas all over there’s just a lot of masonry for signals to get through.

I’ve been really happy on many occasions to have Wifi calling, both where I live in NYC (where service sometimes behaves similarly to Paris) and the rural places I visit frequently (where having the cellular modem off while at home saves tons of battery vs constantly having no service).

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by eightysixfour on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:19PM (#38621854)
Yes, and VoWifi lets your cell phone make a call over that fiber when your wireless coverage isn’t great. Not really sure where castles and battlements come to play here - there are plenty of completely normal places people visit with connectivity issues.

Maybe it is your experience in the rural balkans, where cellular congestion and significant building density aren’t factors, and your assumption it must be better in “civilized” places that is confusing the issue…

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by sib on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:33PM (#38621513)
Europe is approximately 7% of the land surface area of the world. We don't all live in small, densely populated places :)
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by lstodd on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:45PM (#38621611)
And US is 6.1% Your point?
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by callalex on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @01:30AM (#38623452)
Would you describe the entirety of the US as “densely populated”?
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by sib on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @02:33PM (#38633002)
My point is exactly what I said. There are lots of parts of the world where mobile service is not good (or available at all) because it's not economically sensible to build out coverage where populations are very low.

You wrote "there are about zero places in Europe where you have Wifi but do not have cheap almost-unlimited 4G/LTE" on a site with a global audience.

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by iggldiggl on Thursday December 14, 2023 @12:18PM (#38643975)
And even where the connectivity is there, the "cheap almost-unlimited" bit might not necessarily be true – that, too, significantly varies from country to country.
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by cyberax on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:35PM (#38621537)
That's not quite true. There are older buildings with brick walls that have bad cellular reception.

Conversely, some high rises have a too _good_ reception and the radio spectrum can get congested.

Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by lstodd on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @08:43PM (#38621589)
Where it does matter they put a femtocell which is about as complicated as a wifi AP.
Re:Hardening Cellular Basebands in Android by wrboyce on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @04:12AM (#38624638)
I live in the UK and pretty much rely on VoWifi to make/receive calls when at home. I can also think of a few places within an hours drive where my reception drops to “No Service”.

You are completely wrong in your assertions.