News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by AlbertCory on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:38PM (#38607583)
If you're serious about "reforming" software and standards patents, you should first carve off that area from pharma and bio patents. Make software just plain not patentable.

Why? Strategically, you don't want those drug people as enemies. They have an extremely powerful lobby in D.C. and many "reforms" that make sense in software would get them up in arms. Choose your battles.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:19PM (#38607947)
I'm not convinced that pharma or bio patents are justified, either.

>Strategically, you don't want those drug people as enemies.

Oh, actually, yes, can we please ream the m*****f*****s already? To talk about a group of people like that, suggests that they wield far too much power. It gets worse when you learn about what they actually do. Enough already.

An "extremely powerful lobby" is not so scary when you outlaw the type of corporate lobbying they engage in. And the American people don't have to let you have a business.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by AlbertCory on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:22PM (#38608500)
ok, bro. 100% or nothing? Guess which one you'll get?
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:43PM (#38609140)
Under the current system, it's already effectively "nothing" for

>People who can't afford existing drugs

>People who can't get corporations to develop drugs for their conditions because they wouldn't be "profitable"

>People who can't make their farm's business model work even though they're fully capable of growing the crops people want and getting them to market

and so on. But thank you for being my daily encounter with Better Things Aren't Possible Guy.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by AlbertCory on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:06AM (#38609757)
wishful thinking's always better than facing reality. At least in some worlds.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:30AM (#38613430)
Pessimists don't have a monopoly on reality, and society isn't obligated to limit itself to your low expectations just so that you can feel good about being right.

Face the reality that the status quo is unsustainable. Throw off your wishful thinking that things can go on like this without repercussion.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by AlbertCory on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @11:30AM (#38614372)
rather than me wasting even more time responding, why don't you go forth and pursue your all-encompassing patent solution, and report back on how it went?
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @06:48PM (#38620525)
And so we circle back around to the character of the status quo, where powerful lobbying groups have made it untenable to do anything without just straight-up murking them first. I suppose your suggestion was right: it truly is "100% or nothing." I appreciate your endorsement for the campaign to completely wreck these people's livelihoods for the greater good of society. Hope to see you on the front lines.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Pxtl on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:55PM (#38608295)
Without drug patents drug discovery would completely stop.

I'm not averse to looking at alternative models for providing revenue to the drug discovery and testing infrastructure (the current model of patents is flawed as hell), but if you like new medications like the COVID vaccines then you have to respect the important of protecting the incentive to create them.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by senderista on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:09PM (#38608403)
The whole premise is flawed. Drug research is a public good and should be publicly funded. Private funding horribly distorts incentives (only drugs that are lucrative enough to recoup R&D costs are funded).
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Monday December 11, 2023 @10:46PM (#38609161)
>Without drug patents drug discovery would completely stop.

I don't believe that, but I won't convince you. Instead, I invite you to try to convince yourself. Imagine a world where drug discovery happens without patents. Talk it out, falsify your propositions as you go, see if you can come up with something workable.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Pxtl on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @03:34PM (#38618050)
I don't doubt that a workable alternative could be invented (and could improve on the deep flaws in the drug patent system), but it would be absolutely necessary to implement that alternative before removing the drug patent system.

"Remove the drug patent system" = Upset Kanye

"Replace the drug patent system with a new way to encourage drug discovery besides the honor system" = Smiling Kanye

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by underlipton on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @06:42PM (#38620441)
You can use an intermediary and (quickly) transition. I'm not concerned about preserving economic value or whatever, just research and expertise. It would be nice to get this done before a crisis that tests the system (again).
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by mschuster91 on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:57PM (#38607737)
Pharma and bio patents are a troubling issue on their own. We're already seeing this with the patent issues surrounding the Covid vaccines in pharma and with Monsanto and their accomplices monopolizing the agricultural high-yield seed markets. They need to be broken as well.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Pxtl on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:52PM (#38608263)
Not only that, but the patent system is 100% essential to pharma research. Pharma takes a crapload of time from patent to market because of the many layers or trial safety. There are drugs that just plain miss their deadline -- setbacks during the testing process for enough time and then the patent expires and a medication with useful applications get lost to history.

If you substantially screwed with that without a very careful and thorough knowledge of the consequences, drug discovery could grind to a halt.

Remember, this is an industry that's more than happy to just stop making drugs and let all the sufferers die if it's not profitable enough.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by thayne on Monday December 11, 2023 @11:24PM (#38609452)
Patents as a driver for drug discovery has problems too. The most obvious is it means there is very little incentive to research and get FDA approval for treatments that aren't patentable, even if those might lead to better outcomes than patented treatments.

I don't really have a good alternative though.

Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by terragon on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:09PM (#38608407)
Drug discovery has already mostly ground to a halt, so I don't think we'd be breaking much of a system.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by Pxtl on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:18PM (#38608472)
I think mRNA vaccines provide a pretty strong counter-argument. And do you know how many heart patients are alive today thanks to apixaban? Before that drug people were taking literal rat-poison as an anticoagulant.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents by defrost on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:22PM (#38608503)
> Before that drug people were taking literal anticoagulant as an anticoagulant.

and now they are taking a different literal anticoagulant as anticoagulant.

w00t!

Quick question- will a massive dose of apixaban kill a rat the same as a massive dose of an anticoagulant will?

mRNA's are novel, on this we can agree, and I have no issue with their use.

Other sectors of the drug market are less novel and more about slightly different for the purposes of starting the clock on drug copyrights and licencing again.