Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents
by m4rtink on Monday December 11, 2023 @11:16PM
(#38609401)
LCD drawing tablets were another victim - Wacom sitting on their EMR patents, selling only overpriced pro gear cost the world a couple generations of digital artists!
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents
by mensetmanusman on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:16AM
(#38612326)
We have already run the experiment nearly 100 years ago shortly after WW2 (and prior to the Bahl Dole act) on what happens when people have idea requiring capital investments that aren't protected by risk mitigation IP.
People don't invest because of first mover disadvantage in game theory.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents
by TaylorAlexander on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:01PM
(#38618457)
Genuinely curious for my own research, can you give me more information? What exactly happened? What projects failed to gain investment? What projects subsequently were only funded due to IP restriction grants?
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents
by mensetmanusman on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @04:59PM
(#38619256)
The Bayh-Doke Act at 40 : J health Polit Policy Law (2022)
Anything by William B. Bonvlian
Vitamin D fortification is a fun one, involved the creation of WARF in madison and proceeded Bayh Dole.
Re:The Secret Behind Qualcomm's Margins? Patents
by TaylorAlexander on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:34PM
(#38636281)
Thanks!
The more I look at the small innovators, they are all hungry to improve upon things the big companies are sitting on for 20+ years with a big moat to protect them, and I really get to thinking that in aggregate we are doing more harm than good.
A response I hear is "then no one would invest" and I think that's false. The investment landscape would change from a small number of big investments to a larger number of smaller investments - investing in tooling to help you beat the competition next year, but not necessarily giving you a 10 year investment for your big dream. And I think that's fine - people still want to innovate and the market already rewards innovators. It is not clear to me that government mandated restrictions on innovation are a good idea at all, and none of the common talking points really engage with the facts as I see them.
Take a look at FDM 3D printers. They went from $50k to $25k in the 13 years they were for sale and under patent protection, and then 10 years after patent protection ended they were $250 and sold by a wide variety of companies all over the world.
How many of today's patented goods could be made for 100x cheaper without patents and what is the cumulative effect of manufacturing machinery, medical equipment, washing machines, computers, and more being 100x cheaper? Is our world really better without that?