Re:Beeper Mini is back
by martinky24 on Monday December 11, 2023 @12:48PM
(#38602838)
Isn't Whatsapp a proprietary, single vendor implementation? Isn't Signal a single vendor implementation? I'm confused on your point.
Re:Beeper Mini is back
by theshrike79 on Monday December 11, 2023 @12:48PM
(#38602839)
Like Signal?
To my knowledge, you can't make a 3rd party Signal client and connect it to the official Signal instances.
> you can't make a 3rd party Signal client and connect it to the official Signal instances.
The Signal guy doesn't want you to do that (just like Apple), but it's absolutely possible. It's in fact much easier than in the iMessage scenario since all the client sources are available.
Giving your Apple ID to a third party is an incredibly bad idea for your security, full stop. Do not ever do this. Any argument that this helps user security because your messages are now E2E is completely undermined by the risk to your identity for literally all of Apple's other services, and that someone could now impersonate you in Messages. But it'd be encrypted!
Of course, if you're on Android -- which you would be to use this service -- then maybe you don't even have any other Apple services (I don't). So this is not a problem.
In fact, can't I not just create an new Apple ID specifically for this?
There are some very weird takes around security on this to somehow twist it into an "Apple good" scenario. No, like literally every other time in history, closed & controlled does not make it more secure.