News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by LordKeren on Monday December 11, 2023 @12:42PM (#38602710)
I think one of the underlying issues is that many are now going to be hesitant to even bother with Beeper Mini anymore. I don’t think there is going to be a high tolerance for this game of cat and mouse from the end user perspective

I also don’t think goading apple is going to do much here either. Regardless of the current feelings around apple’s walled garden, they are not going to suddenly keel over and give up on locking out these commercialized attempted to bypass their security

Re:Beeper Mini is back by seanp2k2 on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:24PM (#38605013)
All Apple needs to do is send a few scary C&D letters from their army of lawyers and this will be done. If they run the infrastructure for imessage, I'm sure there's something in a ToS somewhere that talks about spoofing device IDs and unauthorized use of their services blah blah Apple's sole discretion.

In theory I love it but in reality it'll be dead soon as Apple has too much to gain from the walled garden they've spent decades and billions building and defending.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by mmastrac on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:32PM (#38605118)
A $3T monopolist sending scary C&D letters tends to get the attention of the government.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by JoshuaRogers on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:22PM (#38605664)
If it was obviously bogus (think SLAPP territory) then that would make sense, but I don't think it is as likely to get their attention if the offending behavior can reasonably be classified as a potential violation of the CFAA.

(Whether it is a violation or not, I certainly couldn't say, but my point being that there is a reasonable good faith interpretation of the behavior that would not raise eyebrows.)

Re:Beeper Mini is back by andrethegiant on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:44PM (#38606500)
what is SLAPP in this context?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by technothrasher on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:00PM (#38606696)
Strategic Lawsuits Against Public Participation. In other words, "Sue somebody when they criticize you, hoping the legal expense will make them stop." This isn't exactly the same scenario, but would be similar (in the poster's hypothetical) in that it was a lawsuit meant to intimidate rather than to seek justice.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by blep_ on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:56PM (#38606654)
Re:Beeper Mini is back by Pikamander2 on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:00PM (#38605443)
I'm sure they're quaking in their boots over the prospect of paying a $2m fine a decade from now.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by tycho-newman on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:37PM (#38605861)
That decade of lawyer fees is much more than $2m.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by aetherson on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:36PM (#38605181)
What is your evidence for this assertion?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by bongodongobob on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:51PM (#38605344)
Since when? What country?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by nicce on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:46PM (#38607090)
The problem is that Apple has valid case, because these guys are making money with the app, by using Apple’s private backend services without permission.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by rootusrootus on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:39PM (#38608633)
Eh, just being really big isn't going to be enough by itself. Apple has just a bit over half the market, they're definitely not a monopoly. The gov't won't get involved.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by mrajcok on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:47PM (#38605310)
I've been on the receiving end of this - as an individual maybe, but as a committed startup not necessarily. Rooting for them!
Re:Beeper Mini is back by sneak on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:22PM (#38605661)
Beeper isn’t using Apple services (at least not in Beeper Mini, their new e2ee iMessage client), and thus is not subject to any Terms of Service from Apple.

They’re publishing client software, which is protected expression provided it’s original and doesn’t infringe any trademarks or copyrights.

The end users are the ones potentially violating the ToS by connecting to Apple APIs.

Apple has no basis to tell Beeper to cease and desist from the publication of software that it is legal to publish.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by jcheng on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:18PM (#38607394)
That sounds a lot like the P2P file sharing companies' argument that didn't hold up in court: https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/MGM_Studios,_Inc._v._Grokster,....
Re:Beeper Mini is back by ehsankia on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:12AM (#38609785)
I believe that reverse engineering for the purpose of interop is different and has been found to be fair use by the courts.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by clwg on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:32PM (#38607533)
They could take it the other way and start suspending accounts that use a spoofed device id. For me that's my main hesitation, I don't want to have my apple accounts suspended for violation of ToS.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by mongol on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:40PM (#38605891)
But as part of developing the application? Can they realistically do that without violating ToS?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by IshKebab on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:50PM (#38606572)
Someone said they are embedding Apple binaries for crypto stuff. Clear copyright infringement if so.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by crazysim on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:07PM (#38606754)
They might argue that this is like the inclusion of the Gameboy logo to boot a Gameboy game.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by sneak on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:35AM (#38610283)
Only in the open source example PoC, not in the proprietary/closed source Beeper Mini. (They are not the same.)

That would be a clear and avoidable error and would get them shut down instantly.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by turquoisevar on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:31AM (#38613451)
Apple doesn’t even need to do that. They can send the DOJ after Beeper.

Many people hear about a reverse entering exception in the DMCA and call it a day. But it’s not that simple.

Reverse engineering is allowed for a very narrow case, namely interoperability between two software programs (for which you have a license granting you legal permission to use), as defined in paragraph 4 of Section 103(f).

The DMCA decidedly does not permit you to use reverse engineering to package someone else's software or service and sell it.

Jurisprudence also established that EULAs that explicitly prohibit reverse engineering supersede the exception granted in the DMCA, see Bowers v. Baystate Technologies, 320 F.3d 1317 (Fed. Cir. 2003)[0]

Apple has explicitly forbidden reverse engineering in their macOS license agreement[1], the iOS license agreement[2], and the Apple Media Terms of Service[3].

Agreement with those terms is necessary to reach the parts that need reverse engineering.

There’s also the matter that the pypush repository seems to include Apple’s proprietary code, which wouldn’t fall under reverse engineering.

Worst of all, even if reverse engineering was allowed, it still doesn't allow you to connect to other people's servers. The Computer Fraud Abuse Act of 1986 explicitly prohibits unauthorized access to computer systems, and the DMCA exception doesn't supersede the CFAA.

A lot of states have criminal statutes that mirror the CFAA.

So, at this point, it wouldn’t be inconceivable for Apple to try and get the DOJ involved.

0: https://law.resource.org/pub/us/case/reporter/F3/320/320.F3d...

1: https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/macOSSonoma.pdf

2: https://www.apple.com/legal/sla/docs/iOS16_iPadOS16.pdf

3: https://www.apple.com/legal/internet-services/itunes/

Re:Beeper Mini is back by pathartl on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:36PM (#38605850)
I'd be willing to put up with it if it were free, like the good ol MSN messenger / AIM days.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by m4jor on Monday December 11, 2023 @07:32PM (#38607528)
"We’ve made Beeper free to use. Things have been a bit chaotic, and we’re not comfortable subjecting paying users to this. As soon as things stabilize (we hope they will), we’ll look at turning on subscriptions again. If you want to keep supporting us, feel free to leave the subscription on ."
Re:Beeper Mini is back by Miner49er on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:43PM (#38605937)
It is free
Re:Beeper Mini is back by lolinder on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:48PM (#38606541)
From their website [0]:

> We currently offer a 7 day free trial, afterwards there is a $1.99 per month subscription. Beeper Mini is available to download today with no waitlist.

That doesn't sound free to me. Am I missing something?

[0] https://www.beeper.com/

Re:Beeper Mini is back by Miner49er on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:53PM (#38606623)
The article we are commenting on says they have made it free for now. I just don't think they've updated their main site yet.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by lolinder on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:18PM (#38606832)
Ah, thanks, I missed that (I skimmed until "What happened")!
Re:Beeper Mini is back by philomath_mn on Monday December 11, 2023 @01:00PM (#38603026)
Yeah I was super excited to try it out last week, but then it went down and I didn't receive important messages from my wife (didn't even realize the app was down).

I probably won't try it again until it has a few months of uninterrupted service.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by SparkyMcUnicorn on Monday December 11, 2023 @02:12PM (#38604085)
Right now Beeper Mini only works without registering your phone number, and I'd be ok if that's all I ever got. In fact, I hope they make number registration optional if they do get that working again.

I still have my Macbook if/when Beeper is cut off again.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by wvenable on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:08PM (#38604838)
It definitely might be better at the moment without registering your number as then you won't have messages disappear into nothingness if the service goes down again.

I missed a few messages when I switched from iPhone to Android because I hadn't deregistered my number from Apple.

I don't think I'd use my existing Apple ID for this -- probably easy enough to create a new one with a new email.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by lxgr on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:14PM (#38605570)
Number registration is and always was optional on Beeper Mini!
Re:Beeper Mini is back by Beached on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:36PM (#38605849)
let's be honest. it isn't for security. security is just the hand they wave to prevent people from tapping their walled garden.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by graphe on Monday December 11, 2023 @02:58PM (#38604700)
iMessage is reliable, ‘free’ and encrypted. Beeper mini is unreliable, paid, and encrypted. I wouldn’t recommend it anymore to my Android friends.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by unshavedyak on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:28PM (#38605066)
Is it free? I have it bundled as part of my hardware purchases. Is there somewhere to get it without paying?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by bee_rider on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:40PM (#38605228)
They put free in quotes because it is bundled in, I’m pretty sure. It is, from a user point of view, free if you are already buying an iPhone anyway.

I have no idea how to compute the actual price. It really isn’t any better than SMS anyway, so I put the value at $0.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by wharvle on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:50PM (#38605332)
> It really isn’t any better than SMS anyway, so I put the value at $0.

Depends on what you do with it. You can send much higher-quality photos and videos over iMessage than SMS/MMS. You can also do things like play games (chess, for example) entirely inside iMessage.

If you're just sending short messages of plain text, yeah, it's not much of an improvement.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by lancesells on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:09PM (#38605521)
It is free even without purchase. I could give someone an old iPhone and they can use it without issue.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by Tommstein on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:33PM (#38605810)
"Cars/TVs/insert-other-thing-here are free, because I could just give an old one to someone!" That ain't how it works bro . . . .
Re:Beeper Mini is back by frumper on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:46PM (#38605969)
One would say you can watch stations for free over the air even though you have to buy a TV.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by lxgr on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:49PM (#38606012)
A better comparison would be a free over the air station that only works on a particular brand of TV.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by claytongulick on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:20PM (#38606266)
Or XM Radio "free" stations that you can only listen to if you have XM radio subscription and hardware.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by lxgr on Monday December 11, 2023 @04:16PM (#38605590)
Even if old iPhones were free: There’s still a significant issue for people not wanting to carry two phones.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by bear141 on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:39PM (#38605220)
The quotations would indicate that he is using “free” facetiously.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Monday December 11, 2023 @03:41PM (#38605242)
It’s free. The fact it’s only available on Apple devices doesn’t change that fact.

You can only get Apple Fitness on Apple devices, but you also have to pay for it.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by unshavedyak on Monday December 11, 2023 @05:19PM (#38606254)
Seems a silly distinction. So you're saying Beeper could make paper clips, sell them to you for $2/m, and then give you Beeper Mini for free and you'd consider it free?

Imo the only thing that should be done here is only valid Apple IDs should be able to use this service. Then paying customers are the ones using it. Problem solved, right?

Re:Beeper Mini is back by wokwokwok on Monday December 11, 2023 @06:32PM (#38606966)
Come on, you can make arbitrary analogies until the end of time but it doesn’t change the facts:

1) you have a device

2) you have software

If you buy the software, it is paid.

If you do not buy the software, its free.

If the software is not available for your device that does make it not free; you just have an incompatible device.

Any other take on this is subscribing to some bias.

Paper clips, are not relevant.

There is a distinction, to be fair, between “free open source software” which is free and you can take it and port it to your device if you want.

…but no one is claiming iMessage is FOSS, and when someone says it is “free”, that is not what they mean.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by sterlind on Monday December 11, 2023 @11:13PM (#38609364)
Is Windows free because it comes pre-installed on your laptop when you buy it?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:19AM (#38611238)
No. Windows is not free - the manufacturer prepays for the license and it’s built in to your hardware purchase price.

Look up “windows oem” using your favorite search engine.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by sterlind on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @02:20PM (#38616963)
Right, I know Windows isn't free. My point is, it's the same situation with OS X, and with iMessage. Just because OS X is made by the hardwae developers doesn't change it. Windows still isn't free on Surface laptops, believe me that the OS team gets a cut of hardware sales.

Maybe it seems confusing because OS X isn't sold as a standalone product, but consider how Apple cracks down on Hackintoshes. They definitely consider it stealing.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by graphe on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:12AM (#38627606)
Hackintosh isn't cracked down on. Commercial use of it is. I had an osx snow leopard partition I hackintoshed and I was trying old HDDs and it booted on my netbook. Most of the times it doesn't work is based on broken APIs or changes that aren't related to osx. 10.8 or 10.7 was the first free osx and the first one that included iMessage.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by stavros on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:05AM (#38610100)
The difference is that my device isn't incompatible, Apple just doesn't want me to run iMessage on it. They don't just not care, they're actively blocking companies that released clients.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:15AM (#38611195)
There’s iMessage the app and then there’s the proprietary Apple Push Notification Service. that Apple use in its implementation.

The iMessage app is incompatible with non Apple devices - there is no iMessage app available period outside of those that run on Apple operating systems.

The APN is not licensed for “public” third party usage unless permission is explicitly and expressly granted by Apple.

So yes, your non Apple device is 100% incompatible with iMessage, and unauthorized usage of the underlying APNs is illegal under the Apple Terms of Service.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by stavros on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @07:35AM (#38611366)
So if I write an Android app that polls for messages, or uses my own notifier, that's fine by Apple? They'll leave it be?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:09AM (#38612246)
What?

I never said that. The Apple iMessage APNS is proprietary - and Apple explicitly state it cannot be used without their blessing.

In addition Apple have the right to terminate any Apple IDs that they feel are being used to circumnavigate their approved service access.

I’d be grateful if you’d stop putting words into my mouth here. I’m not claiming any analogies- just facts.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Monday December 11, 2023 @08:15PM (#38607914)
What? Where did I claim that?

You are the one asking if iMessage is “free” (as in beer) software.

It comes with iOS - the license of which is provided free of charge for each user to run on their respective device.

I never made any statement about Beeper - I was talking singularly and only about Apple.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by unshavedyak on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @09:11AM (#38612264)
> You are the one asking if iMessage is “free” (as in beer) software.

No, i was asking if it was free in respect to beeper, because the beeper not being free is literally the comment i replied to. I feel like you're looking at my comment in isolation, but expecting me to keep your comment in context - which also seems to be lacking context.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @10:35AM (#38613500)
graphe: “iMessage is reliable, ‘free’ and encrypted. Beeper mini is unreliable, paid, and encrypted. I wouldn’t recommend it anymore to my Android friends.“

You: “Is it free? I have it bundled as part of my hardware purchases. Is there somewhere to get it without paying?”

Not sure where the confusion is. Seems from the quoted text you were expressly asking if iMessage was free or not.

If not, what is the “it” you were referring to in your reply? Your initial response did not seem to compare cost to beeper.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by unshavedyak on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @09:33AM (#38627897)
I was definitely referring to iMessage. I was just saying that the conversation is about Beeper and iMessage. The comparison was taken place in the quote you posted.

Anyway, i'm just saying that the mints on a hotel pillow are "free" too, but if you cannot acquire them without paying for another service or hardware, they're hardly free.

Best i can give iMessage is that it's complementary. Please correct me if i'm wrong, but almost no one gets iMessage without paying Apple for an associated product to gain access. It's a mint on your pillow.

Re:Beeper Mini is back by MissTake on Thursday December 14, 2023 @05:06AM (#38639684)
There’s barely a nuance between “free” and “complementary”.

Both are essentially the same thing.

https://thecontentauthority.com/blog/free-vs-complimentary

Re:Beeper Mini is back by unshavedyak on Thursday December 14, 2023 @10:10AM (#38642164)
I dunno, it just feels some silly definition or thought experiment to define away the money missing from my wallet.

I'll concede all day long that i may be using the wrong definition, that's definitely not my objection. However free is pretty simple. Entrance fees or any price blocking you from the "free" thing is in any practical sense, hardly free. At least imo.

A lot of things are free if you ignore what you paid for in the first place.

Out of curiosity, how would you even define what is free and what isn't? Lets say a snickers bar released an April Fools edition where you paid the standard price, but only for the wrapper. The snickers bar inside is free. Or the silly paper clip example i gave, with beeper mini. Is there some definition that you would see apt to describe these as practically (as in, how people would interpret them) not being free?

Re:Beeper Mini is back by rootusrootus on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:44PM (#38608678)
Is Linux free? I have a computer that won't run it.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by stavros on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:02AM (#38610085)
What kind of computer is this that Linux doesn't run on, and can't you just make Linux run on it?
Re:Beeper Mini is back by oxguy3 on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:08PM (#38608394)
Read the post; they've made it free now. They said they'll consider charging again if/when things stabilize.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by graphe on Monday December 11, 2023 @09:41PM (#38608654)
They said they made ‘beeper’ free, not ‘beeper mini’ free. Unless they combined them since the last post. But maybe they should say beeper mini is free.
Re:Beeper Mini is back by ehsankia on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @12:15AM (#38609794)
I agree that right now, most people shouldn't give this a try. But at some point it will reach a steady state.

Either Beeper manages to make a client that is truly indistinguishable from old iPhones, and gets to exist for a few years, or Apple somehow manages to patch all existing iPhones in a way that makes it impossible to spoof (not sure if that's possible with old hardware that don't have a secure enclave).

Re:Beeper Mini is back by okdood64 on Tuesday December 12, 2023 @01:47AM (#38610371)
> But at some point it will reach a steady state.

I highly doubt that these guys will win. I would bet 5 AAPL on it.