Did Facebook simply look at their activity, determine that 25% of their engagement is driven by photosharing, and decide that 1% of the company was more than reasonable to protect that space? Or something to that effect?
So Zuck decided to take them out of the competitive landscape now, while it could still afford to, rather than risk Systrom turning Instagram into a major social network that siphoned away significant amounts of activity from Facebook.com
More startups like Instagram are going to appear. No one can predict when or where but given the low barrier to entry, it's going to happen. If it costs Facebook $1B per "bullet" to kill them then they are going to run out of bullets.
Good question that I was also questioning why until I found this quote:
"... Posts that include a photo album or a picture generate about 180% and 120% more engagement than the average post respectively, according to Facebook’s internal data. ..." ~ https://www.facebook.com/business/fmc/guides/bestpractices?c...
I suspect the purchase was specifically in response to this metric.
However, if they purchased Instagram with mainly Facebook stock then it doesn't really matter since at such a high Facebook valuation, Facebook probably got a nice deal (because I don't think 100 billion is the right valuation).
One reason I think this is that I'm remembering the high valuations that Yahoo and AOL used to have.
Think about it, a lot of people do believe that Instagram had a real chance of taking Facebook out.
To put it in perspective, I do not believe there has been a startup that google has bought because there was a chance it would take them out. The main thing that google does is search, and they still do it better than anybody else. Facebook on the other hand seems to have a lot less moat, as evidenced by this purchase.
If their moat is that weak than 100 billion is too risky. It could implode at any moment. The next startup or the next hot new thing could take them out.
Who, pray tell, would these people be? Because that's a ludicrous assertion.
I'll argue by analogy here: I don't know anyone who uses Instagram. Everyone I know uses Facebook. Instagram was making zero dollars. Facebook is generating cash in the billions. Instagram has 30MM users. Facebook is approaching a billion.
Instagram has some strategic value to Facebook, obviously. But I don't know how anyone can claim that these companies are competitors.
>Who, pray tell, would these people be? Because that's a ludicrous assertion.
Well, I would guess the 'hip' people who write for the startup blogs (i.e., Pando, TechCrunch, RWW, etc.) think so, but I think among normal people, we would agree that was a ludicrous assertion.
Of late, that narrative has been wearing a bit thin. They're adding users at a crazy pace, but monetization has not kept pace and by the time the IPO comes out, by virtue of more actual information being public, the buzz around the company will take even more of a hit.
Instagram is only step towards shoring up that narrative and once they go public, I'll expect more such deals to come through. They did not acquire the company because they were scared of it.
With that, I'll end my amateur attempt at mind reading :)
Even if they wanted to try to do that such action wouldn't seem likely as that might interfere with the IPO / eventual stock price and would interfere with their wishes to make a load of cash on the IPO.
In short do you take a shot at the head of a company about to make you a ton of money even if you think they've made mistakes? Probably not.
In fact from my understanding from institutional investors they often are privy to concerns, actions, and screw ups by companies they're heavily invested in, but don't raise concerns because ... they're heavily invested and don't want to rock the boat if it is doing well otherwise.
There was. That is what several members of the board represent: They are chosen by the shareholders.
I was under the assumption you only need over 50%, which he has already. Or is it different US?
1) Zuck, with his 57% voting proxy, has absolute control over the company. He doesn't need to consult anybody for his decisions, even Sandberg or the board.
2) With that said, he made sure they voted. The board still needs to vote for it to be legal, but if they were to vote it down, Zuck could simply remove the dissident board members with his 57% share.
3) This acquisition was defensive, not offensive, in nature. Yes, Facebook could have created its own filters, but it was worried that Instagram could become THE social network for sharing images. That would be bad for Facebook, since that's it's the undisputed leader in that space. Zuck knew it would be more expensive to leave Instagram independent than to take it out now for a high price.
4) No matter who acquired Instagram, there were going to be conflicts of interest. Twitter's CoI is actually worse -- it's Executive Chairman, Jack Dorsey, was an angel investor in Instagram. This is why Zuck doesn't make investments, I suspect.