News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by taberiand on Saturday December 09, 2023 @09:58PM (#38588616)
Why are these scientists so desperate for a Magical Quantum Solution to consciousness? Shouldn't they first disprove the much more likely hypothesis that consciousness is an emergent property of the (macro level) structure and operation of the brain?
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by colanderman on Saturday December 09, 2023 @11:44PM (#38589151)
Because we're on the brink of creating machines whose observable behavior is indistinguishable from consciousness, and whose macro structure mirrors that of our own brains, yet it is tantalizingly tempting for many to cling to the belief that humans are in some way special.

(My bet: within 5 years someone has glued together the in-retrospect obvious macro components of what we call "consciousness" into a technological golem which causes a mass crisis of faith in those who haven't made peace with the idea that consciousness is neither magical nor unique to humans. Personally I believe it's likely someone already has.)

Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by sublinear on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:17AM (#38589570)
Have you considered it's more likely that mere subjective macro-level observations are becoming obsolete?
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by junon on Sunday December 10, 2023 @03:02AM (#38589959)
I think you're giving way too much credit to LLMs.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by yetihehe on Sunday December 10, 2023 @08:00AM (#38591249)
He didn't say anything about LLMs, I too think someone will do a real thinking machine, but more like in 10 years. LLMs maybe will be a part of such creation, but only a part.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by colanderman on Sunday December 10, 2023 @10:47AM (#38592298)
Sibling is correct. LLMs are missing most of the macro structure that known existing consciousnesses have (memory, emotion, desire, self-observation of internal and external processes, etc.) They do however provide an important stepping stone towards creation of an artificial consciousness and recognition thereof, as a mechanism by which an artificial consciousness can integrate qualia into action, and as a bonus, communicate in a language which us humans understand.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by BeautifulSynch on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:55PM (#38588896)
Scientists are people too. These efforts have always struck me as a desperate attempt to cling to conventionally intuitive views of what humanity and sapience actually means, in the face of physical laws which don't seem to treat "personhood" as anything special (aside from the "observer-interaction" of quantum physics, which some claim involves impact on the universe being observed rather than just what parts of reality the sensor/observer can perceive).

EDIT: Though to be fair, I wouldn't be surprised if neurons just so happen to use quantum decoherence in their computations. I just don't think it has any relevance to the macro-level phenomenon we call "consciousness".

Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by mensetmanusman on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:54PM (#38588891)
People realized long ago you can't wave around the word 'emergent' to solve this problem.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by anonzzzies on Sunday December 10, 2023 @01:50AM (#38589676)
Emergent can be the first step; something emerges. Then you have to explain why/how. Emergent alone is never enough but it’s the first step. Consciousness is emergent until we explain how it comes to be and then it’s just an understood process.
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by taberiand on Sunday December 10, 2023 @04:05AM (#38590250)
Oh really? Who, and when - and with what proof?
Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by mensetmanusman on Sunday December 10, 2023 @12:51PM (#38593335)
I'm just referencing the existing debates on the topic. It doesn't appear we are at a stage to prove or disprove subjective experience.

One hint we will know our understanding is solved is when others can enter the plane of our mind and add or subject imaginative objects.

Re:Own Consciousness Can Interact with the Universe, Scienti... by 1letterunixname on Sunday December 10, 2023 @12:13AM (#38589298)
The intelligent design crowd knows it needs more than Ark Encounter to sell religion by using science against itself to "find" the ghost in the machine.