Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by gexaha on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:39AM
(#38580263)
Do you consider Whitehead's philosophy also vacuous?
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by cyber_kinetist on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:18AM
(#38580514)
I have heard that Deleuze’s works highly derive from Whitehead’s process philosophy (along with influences of Bergson and Nietzsche). Which was pretty unexpected to me, since I’ve previously known Whitehead as a mathematician who tried creating a foundation of modern mathematics with Bertrand Russell (writing the book Principia Mathematica together). So I wouldn’t have expected that he’s actually one of the more foundational people behind continental philosophy, which has a (mis-understood) image of being illogical and vacuous!
Anyways, should read Process and Reality someday, since my interest in panpsychism is growing… (And which might be more useful than reading Deleuze/Guattari since they’re just too cryptic)
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by voldacar on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:34PM
(#38585770)
You're mixing up two Whiteheads
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by arketyp on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:00PM
(#38586034)
No
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by dlkf on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:04AM
(#38580420)
Motte (principia) and bailey (process philosophy).
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by mannykannot on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:19AM
(#38581714)
I'm not sure this would be entirely fair to Whitehead unless he tried to pass off the latter as being justified by the former.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by dlkf on Sunday December 10, 2023 @03:50AM
(#38590173)
I’m not accusing Whitehead of the fallacy, I’m talking about the parent post.
Parent is suggesting that if we don’t take Deleuze seriously, we should also not take Whitehead seriously. (Despite Whitehead being a fav of the analytic crowd.)
But the Deleuze comparison, to the extent that it makes any sense, only applies to the later Whitehead. We don’t have to reject the Pricipia. The obvious position is that Deleuze is not-even-wrong, process philosophy is not-even-wrong, and the principia is merely wrong (which is amazing in philosophy.)
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by gexaha on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:06AM
(#38626158)
yeah, sorry for not being more specific, I meant "process philosophy"
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio]
by CiteXieAlAlyEtc on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:49AM
(#38582839)
the most underrated comment on this thread; i cackled out loud, thank you.
Shaviro's "Without Criteria" which discusses this connection was an absolute delight.