News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by zvmaz on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:21AM (#38580149)
"Deleuze's work is characterized by his emphasis on difference and multiplicity, which he saw as fundamental to understanding the world. He developed a philosophy of becoming, which emphasizes the importance of change and transformation."

Vacuous.

Reminds me of David Stove's "What is wrong with our thoughts" [1].

[1] https://web.maths.unsw.edu.au/~jim/wrongthoughts.html

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by bangkoksbest on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:20AM (#38580527)
The Stove essay (in truth it's a prolonged rant) supposedly extols the virtues of empirical thinking, and you invoked it to back up the sense you had that the description of Deleuze's philosophy is vacuous... And yet...

Difference and multiplicity are core to empirical data and scientific & engineering modelling. To make a measurement you assume there is a scale to measure difference. To have a variable is to assume that something can vary. To be a cause is to assume something can make a difference. To have a process is to assume a system that can change and transform. There's nothing vacuous about this.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by dash2 on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:31AM (#38581775)
I'm pretty sure Deleuze never said anything about difference, multiplicity, variables, or process that has proved useful to a scientist or engineer, but I'd be very interested to be proved wrong.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by bangkoksbest on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:42PM (#38586877)
I'm an engineer and I find some of his stuff useful, particularly when it comes to thinking through how to think about how to use large p, small n data.

But I also don't have a strong reactionary anger to Deleuze's penchant for writing in an obscurant quasi-post-modern literary style, and I get that many do. In any case, it's not like similar ideas are not also worked through in less cryptic ways in contemporary philosophy of science journals.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by dash2 on Sunday December 10, 2023 @02:23AM (#38589795)
That's interesting. Could you give a specific example?
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by mrkeen on Saturday December 09, 2023 @06:31AM (#38581011)
> To have a variable is to assume that something can vary.

Tautology.

> To be a cause is to assume something can make a difference.

Tautology.

> To have a process is to assume a system that can change and transform.

Tautology.

Vacuous is exactly how I'd describe the above.

The only statement with potential depth is:

> To make a measurement you assume there is a scale to measure difference.

This invokes quantum mechanics a little. But if those are Deleuze's words, he's a bit late to the party. That stuff was being quantified and mathematically modelled decades before.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by bangkoksbest on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:41AM (#38581489)
Of course they're tautologies in a logic sense, and I deliberately wrote them that way (whether they are pejorative tautologies is not really a material point.) They're statements about the methods for empirical thinking, the statements were not supposed to have empirical content themselves.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by beepbooptheory on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:12AM (#38581290)
This is very strange.. Those are not what tautologies are.

In order for something to be tautological, you need to be working within some formal system of proof. Proposing definitions to terms could never be tautological.

I think you just want to say "I know that already!"

Also, Deleuze would love this comment, precisely because of your confusion in the term.

https://en.m.wikipedia.org/wiki/The_Logic_of_Sense

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by bangkoksbest on Saturday December 09, 2023 @07:53AM (#38581561)
To be fair, I did intentionally write them in a style to mimic propositional logical statements (which are tautologies) but you are correct that they're not in a formal system so they can't actually be tautologies.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by mrkeen on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:31AM (#38582680)
> This is very strange.. Those are not what tautologies are.

> I think you just want to say "I know that already!"

> “All humans are mammals” is held to assert with regard to anything whatsoever that either it is not a human or it is a mammal. But that universal “truth” follows not from any facts noted about real humans but only from the actual use of human and mammal and is thus purely a matter of definition. [1]

Moving on.

I assumed parent was trying to make (non-vacuous) statements, firstly because he was replying to a comment, and secondly because he followed them up with "There's nothing vacuous about this."

> Proposing definitions to terms could never be tautological.

If you treat them as statements, the tautologies clearly appear by substituting the terms' definitions in:

* To have a (thing which can vary) is to assume that something can vary.

* To be a (something that can make a difference) is to assume something can make a difference.

But if parent was just defining his terms, then let's hear those terms used in non-vacuous statements.

[1] https://www.britannica.com/topic/tautology

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by bangkoksbest on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:25PM (#38586736)
As the parent commenter, I already put a reply you could respond to
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by ChainOfFools on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:48PM (#38586948)
> This invokes quantum mechanics a little.

It also invokes politics, economics, and all that implements some form of notional value, because as some other philosopher quipped, what gets measured gets treasured.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by modernpink on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:46AM (#38581885)
All of modern science is possible without philosophy. In fact, it is when what was called natural philosophy broke off into the natural sciences that philosophy per se devolved into a series of language games on metaphysics that became of little relevance aside from those in the philosophy profession itself.

All our modern advances from hypersonic missiles, large language models, quantum physics and spaceflight and are in spite of what is called philosophy, not due to it.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by dleeftink on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:10AM (#38582504)
To turn this around, is all of modern philosophy possible without science? And critically, do we want it to be?

Advances, musings and insights in one domain do not preclude those in others, just as the ethical and epistemological boundaries (and possible trajectories) of missiles, models and spacecraft do not suddenly disappear just because we invented them.

Even moreso, the surrounding language games can be just as impactful: doomsday clocks, Turing tests and space supremacy have informed many policies on the docket, well before any practical applications were feasible. In these instances, it would be (and has been) quite difficult to seperate the science from our language, just as the other way around.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by kelseyfrog on Saturday December 09, 2023 @01:15PM (#38584195)
Let me see if I got this right by echoing it aphoristically: science doesn't care about epistemology?

How do you feel about falsifiability?

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by espe on Saturday December 09, 2023 @06:28AM (#38580983)
deleuze was actually pretty well read in the natural sciences of his times, especially physics. even if you find this short snippet vacuous-sounding, he is actually one of the few philosophers whose metaphors about impenetrable parts of reality are grounded.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by tomtomistaken on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:27AM (#38580179)
Check out all the parts available on Philosophize This!. In particular, parts 4[1] and 5[2] talk about flows and difference.

[1] https://www.philosophizethis.org/podcast/deleuze-flows

[2] https://www.philosophizethis.org/podcast/deleuze-difference

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by gexaha on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:39AM (#38580263)
Do you consider Whitehead's philosophy also vacuous?
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by cyber_kinetist on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:18AM (#38580514)
I have heard that Deleuze’s works highly derive from Whitehead’s process philosophy (along with influences of Bergson and Nietzsche). Which was pretty unexpected to me, since I’ve previously known Whitehead as a mathematician who tried creating a foundation of modern mathematics with Bertrand Russell (writing the book Principia Mathematica together). So I wouldn’t have expected that he’s actually one of the more foundational people behind continental philosophy, which has a (mis-understood) image of being illogical and vacuous!

Anyways, should read Process and Reality someday, since my interest in panpsychism is growing… (And which might be more useful than reading Deleuze/Guattari since they’re just too cryptic)

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by voldacar on Saturday December 09, 2023 @03:34PM (#38585770)
You're mixing up two Whiteheads
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by arketyp on Saturday December 09, 2023 @04:00PM (#38586034)
No
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by dlkf on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:04AM (#38580420)
Motte (principia) and bailey (process philosophy).
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by mannykannot on Saturday December 09, 2023 @08:19AM (#38581714)
I'm not sure this would be entirely fair to Whitehead unless he tried to pass off the latter as being justified by the former.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by dlkf on Sunday December 10, 2023 @03:50AM (#38590173)
I’m not accusing Whitehead of the fallacy, I’m talking about the parent post.

Parent is suggesting that if we don’t take Deleuze seriously, we should also not take Whitehead seriously. (Despite Whitehead being a fav of the analytic crowd.)

But the Deleuze comparison, to the extent that it makes any sense, only applies to the later Whitehead. We don’t have to reject the Pricipia. The obvious position is that Deleuze is not-even-wrong, process philosophy is not-even-wrong, and the principia is merely wrong (which is amazing in philosophy.)

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by gexaha on Wednesday December 13, 2023 @07:06AM (#38626158)
yeah, sorry for not being more specific, I meant "process philosophy"
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by CiteXieAlAlyEtc on Saturday December 09, 2023 @10:49AM (#38582839)
the most underrated comment on this thread; i cackled out loud, thank you.

Shaviro's "Without Criteria" which discusses this connection was an absolute delight.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by asplake on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:37AM (#38580626)
Multiplicity, because relationships become important. Difference, because that drives emergence. Becoming, because when you're dealing with the emergent (eg social structures), how they come into being is essential to understanding them.
Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by keiferski on Saturday December 09, 2023 @12:55PM (#38583979)
These words have specific meanings in Deleuze’s philosophy. They aren’t that complicated.

Your comment is tantamount to someone that doesn’t speak German saying “vacuous” when they come across a word like Geist. Lazy and uninformed.

Re:Gilles Deleuze – What is Philosophy? [audio] by specialist on Saturday December 09, 2023 @05:45PM (#38586909)
I know almost nothing about philosophy and exactly nothing about Deleuze.

I do know the ancient philosophers cared a lot about change.

So I assume Deleuze's notions wrt change are serious too, and not just some self-help new age crap.