Everyone I know uses email. No one I know uses whatsapp. A couple of people I know use Signal. A handful use iMessage.
> But that doesn't matter, because in this discussion, the figure of merit is encrypted email,
Ok, let's consider one case where encrypted email is commonly used: reporting security vulnerabilities. Do you really think any of these would be a good medium for that? Do you see companies or other organizations putting a whatsapp username as the contact in their security.txt?
I do want there to be a more secure replacement for email. But most of the newer e2ee messaging systems can't really fully replace email.
How do you manage the keys? If you've shared them with a team, how do you ensure someone hasn't taken a copy? What if the key is lost? What if someone ends up replying to the thread without doing the encryption song and dance? It's just such a pain. I'd rather copy and paste something out of Signal and into my bug tracker a thousand times than have to deal with all the footguns of email encrypted with GPG.
This never made sense to me, can anyone explain?
It's not authenticity that matters here, it's confidentiality.
Right…
Despite my reluctance to use Meta projects, I read and write far, far more WA messages per day than emails.
None of which are anywhere close to as ubiquitous as email. None of which are well suited to long messages. Only one of those (matrix) is federated. Only one (matrix) wasn't designed specifically for use on mobile devices. Yes, the others can be used on a desktop, but the experience isn't great.