News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:OpenPGP Forked into "LibrePGP" by GnuPG's Maintainer Wern... by tptacek on Thursday December 07, 2023 @07:38PM (#38563897)
Yes: I think Signal is drastically better for reporting security vulnerabilities than email. I think if you're actually worried about operational security for accepting vulnerability reports, using email is practically malpractice. The fact is, most security teams, even the very large ones, are not especially concerned about operational security for inbound vulnerability reports.
Re:OpenPGP Forked into "LibrePGP" by GnuPG's Maintainer Wern... by thayne on Thursday December 07, 2023 @09:09PM (#38564555)
From a security point of view, absolutely. But there are logistical problems. Currently, a signal account has to be tied to a cell phone number. How does that work when you want it sent to a team instead of an individual? There isn't a sanctioned API, so it is difficult (and unsupported) to set up an integration with bug tracking software. Not to mention that the reporter may not have Signal set up yet.
Re:OpenPGP Forked into "LibrePGP" by GnuPG's Maintainer Wern... by tptacek on Thursday December 07, 2023 @09:44PM (#38564795)
Most reporters don't have PGP set up, either --- far fewer than have Signal set up. But this is all kind of a moot point: the industry norm is to use plaintext email, and to make ad hoc arrangements (including voice calls) for the very rare cases where things are too scary to email.
Re:OpenPGP Forked into "LibrePGP" by GnuPG's Maintainer Wern... by maximilianburke on Thursday December 07, 2023 @09:52PM (#38564875)
Honestly these seem like pretty minor issues compared to the task of properly managing a GPG install.

How do you manage the keys? If you've shared them with a team, how do you ensure someone hasn't taken a copy? What if the key is lost? What if someone ends up replying to the thread without doing the encryption song and dance? It's just such a pain. I'd rather copy and paste something out of Signal and into my bug tracker a thousand times than have to deal with all the footguns of email encrypted with GPG.

Re:OpenPGP Forked into "LibrePGP" by GnuPG's Maintainer Wern... by 0xDEAFBEAD on Friday December 08, 2023 @05:07AM (#38567245)
>The fact is, most security teams, even the very large ones, are not especially concerned about operational security for inbound vulnerability reports.

This never made sense to me, can anyone explain?