He's pointing out Ramsey's integrity here, not the position.
But the fact is that we're a minority and the majority of people are bad at managing money.
And so long as you're anything less than good at managing your money, a credit card represents risk. And so for those who don't pay off the debt, the risk grows.
I like Ramsey, he goes balls to the wall and is over the top, as the site mentions he can get repetitive painful at times. And the NO-Debt approach, as you are noting, is a bit crazy but for those who have proven they can't be trusted with debt, then this is the safe choice.
Your response is fine, but I think you're approaching it from a normal, well balanced and money conscious individual. There are people who call into his show with literally $250,000+ in debt between their house, car, boat, property lots, and they've got a sliver of that as income. These are the people he's marketing towards. Not you.
Not using a credit card costs you a ton when you go to get a mortgage. Building a solid credit history is well worth it.
Clearly he's going to need more help than just telling him to quit, but pretending that he can moderate his consumption of alcohol when he is biologically incapable of doing so is a betrayal.
Cons with CCs: If you don't manage your funds well, you git hit with a 20%+ interest rate and will never likely climb out of that hole. Solution: learn to manage debt. Seriously, most CC companies now allow direct account transfers. If you are that scared, whenever you make a purchase, go home, log in to your bank's website (every major bank has one, if yours doesn't, open an account with one that does), and pay off the card immediately. Its not rocket science, just basic financial management.
Pros with CCs: Fraud protection. Easily one of the biggest plus points of CCs. Concerned that there is a charge on you statement that you didn't approve? Just call the company and tell them that it is a fraudulent charge and then its their problem. If nothing else, this easily makes credit cards worth the time it takes to manage them. After this, we have the easy record of all transactions, cash back, convenience, safety from the fact that you don't have a giant wad of cash with you, and last but not least, a credit history which can be used to reduce interest rates on long term loans.
Seriously, this anti-debt attitude is in general ridiculous. Is excessive and badly-managed debt bad? Absolutely, its one of the worst situations to be in but there is a simple way to avoid it: manage your finances. Swearing off all debt is foolish and inefficient.