News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by chasil on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:22PM (#38536429)
The problem is that a single unlocked door led to the unavoidable termination of these animals.

There were no attempts to lure them back to the enclosure (to which they would likely have returned due to the low temperature), no other attempts at capture, and no other plan than termination.

When escape of the enclosure is a lethal threat, then the enclosure needs greater protections to prevent mandatory termination. There should be at least three levels of containment, using doors with mechanisms that the animals cannot manipulate.

Facilities that cannot meet these containment standards should be forced to surrender them to those who can.

Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by tptacek on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:27PM (#38536493)
Part of the calculus behind shooting them appears to have been the likelihood that they would have suffered a worse death from the cold if they didn't return to the building, and with the light failing, the opportunity to spare them that death was passing.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by chasil on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:44PM (#38536665)
I don't think that was a factor at all.

They likely would have returned to their enclosures because of the cold.

  "Many other experts have pointed out that since
  chimpanzees do not like the cold, they would have been
  likely to return to the ape house."
The risk to human life was the paramount concern.

  'Beldt told me he had relived those days perhaps 1,000
  times, wondering if they could have done anything
  different. Every time, he comes to the same conclusion:
  no. Chimpanzees can turn, and the line between play and
  violence is thin. Beldt remembers a time when he sat
  talking to Linda through the bars of the enclosure, and
  Manda snuck up and jabbed him with a stick she had
  sharpened with her teeth, just centimetres from his left
  eye.

  '“People without any experience of chimpanzees say: if I
  had done it, I would have got some bananas, and they would 
  have gone back,” Beldt said. “And maybe, but maybe not.
  Maybe you would have ended up in a body bag, or in 1,000
  body bags, because chimps like to tear things from limb to 
  limb.”'
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by scythe on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:39PM (#38537299)
Most animals are more dangerous when they are in what they perceive as "their territory" versus the field. A dog that is very timid on walks might jump on visitors to their house; bees that fiercely defend their hives will rarely sting when foraging; maybe you can think of other examples.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by RationalDino on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:46PM (#38537364)
I read that as, "Person who made bad decisions concludes that there was no alternative but the bad decisions made."

The former keeper should have been given a chance to try. Sign a waiver, the keeper knows the risks.

If the chimps leave the zoo, then shoot them. But not when they are in the ape enclosure. And for Pete's sake. Don't put people who want to run rollercoasters in charge of animal welfare.

Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by chasil on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:34PM (#38538445)
She wasn't an employee at that point. It likely wasn't possible.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by RationalDino on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @07:21PM (#38538863)
The hunters that they brought in who actually did the shooting were also not employees. If they could be there, she could be there.

The fact that outside primatologists say that she was the likely best option supports the fact that she should have been given the chance. Before shooting.

Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by chasil on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @09:07PM (#38539693)
Well, all I can do is quote this section of the article as to why Persson was ignored after her communication attempts:

'(A spokesperson for Furuvik Zoo told me that that they didn’t take Persson up on her offer because they believed that “those currently working with us are the ones who know the chimpanzees best.”)'

I don't think she would have been permitted on the grounds for ideological problems, in addition to legal liabilities.

...and I'm upvoting your comments, as the ratings above aren't fair.

Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by tptacek on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:45PM (#38538556)
I only have what the article says to go off of, and the article says both concerns were in play.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by PeterisP on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @04:01PM (#38536840)
Chimps aren't so stupid that they would freeze to death a few minutes away from a warm place they know.
[dead]
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by tptacek on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @03:37PM (#38536578)
They're extremely intelligent animals that can, to a first approximation, in a built environment, move along any axis at over 20MPH. You're probably putting more faith in the power of flashlights than the experts did.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by suzzer99 on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @05:13PM (#38537667)
This is what bothers me the most. Design the system so it doesn't rely on keepers remembering to lock doors. For one shift door to open, everything else must be locked down.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by SV_BubbleTime on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:21PM (#38538335)
Automatic closing and locking doors with keypads. There, problem solved without getting into double door “airlocks”.
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by vanattab on Thursday December 07, 2023 @01:05AM (#38553372)
I would think that may violate fire codes no?
Re:Seven Escaped Chimpanzees by pvaldes on Tuesday December 05, 2023 @06:10PM (#38538221)
> The problem is that a single unlocked door led to the termination of the animals.

The problem is that this "can't" happen.

Zoo animals in harsh climates always sleep indoors in a big inner room heated. This main room can be accessed by a minimum of 2 doors. One (or several) leads to the external part of the exhibition. This play area will typically have a moat, that gradually gets deeper, and a high wall. Chimps are poor swimmers (they sink like a rock on water) and the wall is designed to avoid escapes. If the animals escape to this enclosure they can't proceed further and are not a danger for the public so shooting them wouldn't have any sense.

The other door leads typically to a small logistics area, used to store needed stuff (brooms, fresh hay etc) or to interact with the animals safely. This small hall is accessed trough a second locked door. Sometimes you can't open the room door without locking first the pre-cage door. The design encourages having at least one locked door at any time.

The building itself will typically have a main door, the third, to allow access from the outside

One unlocked door means that the chimps will be contained in the broom's hall. Even with two unlocked doors this could end with the chimps trapped inside as long as you have solid windows (as expected in Sweden).

In this case both locks were left opened at the same time,

two or maybe three doors unlocked by night, in the middle of a harsh weather (any opened door would lead to a noticeable chill air current inside the building, or even maybe to the electronic heater system triggering automatically an alarm)