I guarantee you nothing. There are alternative business models that don't require artificial scarcity. Returns are not guaranteed.
> OR, how do you propose we get along without the value that we get out of IP?
I propose we don't.
> You can whinge about your pet libertarianism all you want but it doesn't actually get you any closer to being relevant.
It's just information, numbers. Therefore you can just input it all into stable diffusion models and LLMs and generate an infinite number of similar enough numbers at negligible costs. And there's nothing anyone can do about it short of tyranny the likes of which this world has never seen. And even then it's doubtful it's gonna work.
It's just information, numbers. Therefore you can copy and transmit it with no limits and with complete impunity. The only success they had at stopping it was making it easier not to infringe copyright but their greed destroyed even that. Doesn't matter how many billions they invest into DRM, copyright infringement still happens at scale literally every day. Copyright infringement is natural, it's how people think. It happens every single time someone right clicks and saves a picture off a website, every single time someone makes a little meme. And there's virtually nothing they can do about it short of destroying the internet as we know it.
How's that for relevance?
The only ones who are "whinging" about anything here are these dinosaurs. They're the ones who are irrelevant. They are so absolutely and thoroughly irrelevant they need government intervention, literal government granted monopolies, in order to not be completely and utterly wiped out by technology. They're sacrificing computing, everything we love, so that they can continue their rent seeking with centuries-long monopolies on bits. All I'm saying is we should sacrifice them instead. And let the chips fall where they may.
Which you might note is not an "answer" so much as it is succumbing to the chaos that you don't feel is important enough to control.
I do appreciate you making that explicit though! It's often hard to get people to admit to such naked dismissal of functional societal mechanisms that actual people get practical, tangible value from. Definitely contextualizes the framing more vividly.
Nothing wrong with that. Intellectual property proponents will "burn down" the entire technology field to get their way. Every day it's some new DRM bullshit. They couldn't care less about hacking and values like computing freedom. Then you have governments who want to do things like stop citizens from using strong cryptography.
The fact people currently get value from it doesn't justify its continued existence.
> succumbing to the chaos that you don't feel is important enough to control.
Controlling it requires destroying everything I care about. I'd sacrifice the entire copyright industry to keep it.
> I do appreciate you making that explicit though!
It's what I strived to do from the beginning. I want to see things clearly, as they are. If the conclusion is the current status quo is a lie and should be abolished, so be it.
If you find instances where I'm contradicting my beliefs, I give you free license to call me out on it in public. I will either try to justify myself or try to change immediately if I can't.
What I hope for you is that when you are reliant on something, it is stripped from you without regard for how you need it, and hopefully using a particular kind of logic that you find repugnant. That would be an appropriate reversal of the ideology you are preaching. I hope that you lose something you NEED and that the people that could help you simply won't. Not out of inability but out of ideology. I hope that it happens to you not because it would be distressing to you, but because I am confident that such experiences can make one understand how ideological purity (in any specific aspect, logic included) is not a particularly useful measure of the validity or utility of an ideology as it pertains to applicable function. And if it doesn't, then your argument is only enriched by having experienced it. It's a win-win, if you're interested in the type of rigidly structured nonsense you're expressing.
I relied on my country being a democracy but it's not. I also relied on socialists not being in power but they are. I also relied on my country growing economically but things are looking pretty bad, and they seem to get worse everyday. There's a never ending list of these things. There are people out there who could have prevented it and they did nothing due to self-interest rather than ideology. Those who couldn't have stopped it but protested anyway are currently rotting away and dying in prison, having received worse punishments than murderers and rapists.
If you check my submissions you'll find threads about it. I'm sure you'll get a kick out of reading my comments. Enjoy.
I'll take your silence as a realization of said pinnacle, and any future responses as indicative of your need for further education. And, in those cases, please understand that I am continually hoping for your success in that. Bonne soirée!
Man, this kind of tit for tat arguing is really not what HN is made for and it is very uninteresting to read, especially with thinly veiled insults like this one.
The more mature of us needed to put an end to the comments. Eventually, that happened. No fuss, no muss! To that end, HN ill needs comments like yours, serving only to nag about something that no one cared about and mature readers would have ignored.
And, luckily, HN has a remedy for poor behavior! You can flag my comment, or all of my comments on the thread! That's not even inappropriate. It is the reasonable consequence of my actions.
Finally, if you think your nagging or any amount of downvoting will ever stop me from getting the last word in on myopic, self-centered, faux-liberal libertarian wonks, you are sorely mistaken. So long as anyone endeavors to miss points and twist logic such that they can sea-lion a debate partner into submission, I will be happy to frustrate, complicate, and interfere with such attempts. To believe that forcing them to give up spewing their incessant bullshit is the lesser evil than "not engaging" is folly, because to let incessant bullshit stand unanswered leaves bullshit for perpetuity. At least, now, when people read the thread they will think "what a couple of self-absorbed losers", instead of "huh. what this guy said makes sense, and nobody bothered him about it. might be something to it."
Very happy to be hated for this kind of bullshit than to let that kind of bullshit appear valid, however superficially.
(Obviously the other user was equally at fault)
Now, on to that actual engagement with the problem that I asked you to do...?
How do you guarantee the same value we get out of IP, without IP? OR, how do you propose we get along without the value that we get out of IP? What does that world look like, in a practical sense.
You can whinge about your pet libertarianism all you want but it doesn't actually get you any closer to being relevant. No matter how much you think anybody "should" care.