News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by sopooneo on Monday April 16, 2012 @01:27PM (#3848356)
Orthogonal to everything brought up in the article: I'm still stunned by how many parents have no problem with depictions of graphic violence but go nuts over sexuality and nudity. Arab culture is the most sexually repressed I've ever encountered, but we here in The States are not that far behind.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by lotharbot on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:09PM (#3848821)
Parents are usually wary of exposing their kids to violence when it's emotionally realistic. They may let their preteens play the latest Explode The Bad Guys game, but are less likely to let them watch surveillance footage of somebody being beaten to death.

Most of us want our children to grow up to have a positive, healthy sexuality. That means developing certain attitudes and emotions. Sexual content in media tends to distort or completely lack those emotions and attitudes; the same is true of decontextualized nudity.

Most of us don't want our children to grow up to have the attitudes that come from a life of violence. Adults who train to do violence (soldiers, police, etc.) often need help to deal with the emotional scars. That's not something we want to expose our children to. But "graphic violence" in movies and games tends to distort or completely lack that emotional content.

The unrealistic or disconnected nature of media violence makes it more acceptable, while the unrealistic or disconnected nature of media sexuality makes it less so.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by moe on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:21PM (#3848890)
You just said: Kids can handle unrealistic violence fine but unrealistic sexuality is a problem.

That makes no sense. None at all.

Either your kids can distinguish reality from fiction. Or they can't. Right?

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by tedunangst on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:34PM (#3848939)
I think "I can single handedly kill all the bad guys with poor aim" is more easily recognized as fiction than "I get to fuck all the girls because that's what studs like me do". Action movie directors responsible for the former are (I hope) at least kind of in on the joke, but I have my doubts as to how much sexual fiction is recognized as realistic or not by the author.

As a culture, we generally criticize real life violence. The message is fairly clear (ok in fiction, not ok in reality). However, sex is celebrated in real life, meaning it's a lot less black and white deciding what's ok.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by moe on Monday April 16, 2012 @05:16PM (#3849479)
I think "I can single handedly kill all the bad guys with poor aim" is more easily recognized as fiction than "I get to fuck all the girls because that's what studs like me do".

Not sure what else to say other than: Huh?

That doesn't remotely make sense to me. We are talking about kids, not about mental retards in the medical sense, are we?

As a culture, we generally criticize real life violence. The message is fairly clear (ok in fiction, not ok in reality). However, sex is celebrated in real life, meaning it's a lot less black and white deciding what's ok.

Again: Huh?

When reading such arguments I can only wonder what kind of kids the author is around, and whether he has lost all memory of his own youth (sorry, not meant as personal attack).

Obviously a minor below a certain age should not be exposed to either. However, by the teen years, when boys commonly gain access to both and consume large quantities of both, most seem to handle it really well.

Making an artificial distinction there just doesn't make sense to me.

If a kid develops behavioral patterns based on "because that's what studs like me do" (either in a sexual or a violent way) then that kid has deeper problems entirely unrelated to the kind of content that he prefers.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by tedunangst on Monday April 16, 2012 @06:53PM (#3849924)
It's really hard to explain without just restating the same thing. From my soapbox, it appears as if fictional sex is more likely to be portrayed as representative.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by lotharbot on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:55PM (#3849052)
I apologize if I was insufficiently clear. It has nothing to do with distinguishing reality from fiction. What matters is how the emotional content can affect a child's development.

Some fictional violence, even very graphic, simply has no emotional content of note. This means many parents are OK with it.

Other forms of fictional violence, as well as most real violence, has possibly traumatic emotional content (even for adults) and therefore parents are cautious about exposing their children to it.

Both fictional and real depictions of sexuality can carry emotional content which is likely to be inaccurate or unhealthy, often in very subtle ways. Therefore, parents are cautious about exposing their children to it (even if they have no particular sexual hangups.)

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by king_jester on Monday April 16, 2012 @05:05PM (#3849436)
What you've said is incredibly vague. You mention "emotional content" in regards to violence and sexuality depicted through media, but there is no way to know what that means and you offer no way to define it. In my experience, this kind of rationalization comes from those who have their own discomfort on these issues and using non-specific language is way to avoid making definite statements while still affecting the outcome of a discussion.

I don't mean to be harsh, but perhaps you could explain, in clear, concrete terms, why depictions of sexuality in media are of special concern compared to other depictions in media, unrealistic or not.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by lotharbot on Monday April 16, 2012 @07:03PM (#3849962)
Depictions of sexuality are of special concern (though certainly not the only area of concern) because sexuality is a deep thing, which most of us will deal with a lot in our lives, and which is easy to screw up in subtle ways. The difference between a great sex life and a mediocre one is often just a subtle shift in one's attitude in any of a multitude of ways.

We form our expectations about sex partly from our own experiences and partly from exposure to others' real or fictional experiences. We may not even realize we've formed an expectation; we may simply think that we're responding in the "natural" way and our partner is responding in an "unnatural" way. Consider how you interpret your partner undressing before bed -- to what degree does that signal desire or readiness for sex? Is it an invitation to a particular level of foreplay? If there's a small disconnect in expectation between you and your partner, that can cascade into an attitude of "he always wants sex when I want to talk first" or "she's always leading me on and then turning me down".

Every couple is going to have issues, disagreements, and disconnects large and small, which they will have to work through over the course of their relationship. Parents have the ability to make this better or worse for their children depending on what content they expose them to, under what circumstances, and what context they provide.

(For the record, my parents started teaching me about sex at around age 3 and were fairly explicit as I got older. I plan to do the same with my son.)

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by moe on Monday April 16, 2012 @04:55PM (#3849384)
You keep making that hand-wavy distinction, without any backup or precision.

Quote (emphasis mine):

You say: Some fictional violence [...] has no emotional content of note

You say: Both fictional and real depictions of sexuality can carry emotional content

I'll assume you're trying to make the point that fictional sex is worse than fictional violence. I further assume you don't really know why (hence your imprecise wording) but have this diffuse belly-feeling that this is how it must be, because that has always been your belly-feeling.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by tedunangst on Monday April 16, 2012 @05:10PM (#3849461)
Belly feeling is needlessly puerile.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by moe on Monday April 16, 2012 @05:27PM (#3849542)
Sorry, I didn't mean to attack him personally but tried to point out the reasons that I suspect behind this kind of lazy arguing.

These "belly-opinions" are very widespread, a more verbose description would have been: "I can't give exact reasons for my opinion but it feels like that's what my parents|peer-group|church|society|... would agree with".

I felt that the verbose version would have been even less polite.. but oh well.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by philwelch on Monday April 16, 2012 @05:04PM (#3849431)
Sexuality is such a taboo in American culture that kids don't know what realistic sexuality is. In some cultures, parents talk frankly and openly to their kids about it, and teach them how to respect and listen to their partners and protect themselves from unwanted pregnancy and STI's. American parents uncomfortably change the subject whenever they ask where babies come from.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by astine on Monday April 16, 2012 @04:37PM (#3849286)
For most middle-class Americans, sexual misconduct among youngsters is a more pressing issue than violent misconduct. Kids having sex and getting pregnant is fairly common while kids going on shooting sprees is very uncommon.

I can tell you though, that back in the 90's when there was a string of shooting crimes by middle class kids, there was a big outcry against violent cinema. Tarantino films, which were seen to glorify violence and some of the kids imitated to some degree, took an especially big backlash. For the most part though, that was just a passing panic.

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by 7952 on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:50PM (#3848728)
Violence is essentially fictional to the vast majority of Americans. It's something you see on television. Sex really happens. There is an awful lot of this [sex], largely because of the total lack of anything else to do.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:54PM (#3848743)
Violence really happens as well, especially where America is concerned.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by nitrogen on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:08PM (#3848814)
I think what the parent poster meant is that, for most first-world citizens, violence happens to "other people," making it seem less threatening or tempting than something that is an essential element of everyday life.
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by AceJohnny2 on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:09PM (#3848535)
I keep wondering about this. The argument comes back all the time, and yet sexual repression continues unabated.

I wonder if it's because violence doesn't provoke the same copycat response as sexuality does. After all, the whole existence of porn is based on it being a stimulant for sexuality. However seeing a violent scene doesn't stimulate you to go beat something up. Or at least any human that I know of ;)

Re:Parents: Read the damn box by kappaknight on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:18PM (#3848575)
I don't know about that... as a kid, I would usually jump off the walls for about 30 minutes after watching Jackie Chan flicks.

Luckily, he only fights bad guys. =)

[deleted]
Re:Parents: Read the damn box by derleth on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:24PM (#3848900)
> Nobody has urges to commit violent acts in real life unless provoked by an external (or even internal) force.

This is wrong. People have always been violent.