The idiocy here is that most of these publishers are likely customers of Google's ad networks anyways, and the clicks through to the articles are yielding ad revenue to them, and they likely are getting analytics and tracking that identifies exactly where the inbound traffic is coming from.
It feels like a shakedown by people who are in other parts of the business totally disconnected from the web content / publishing arms, who likely know better?
It's true that the links only increase the revenue/traffic to their website though, so they should really be supporting the referrers rather than blocking them.
But you wouldn't do that if you want the link to resolve. If you don't want it to work, why would you go to all of the trouble of creating the link in the first place?
But also, the technical solution to bookmarks and small-scale sharing between friends is quite obvious. You don't need referrers to solve that problem.
https://developer.mozilla.org/en-US/docs/Web/HTTP/Headers/Re...
Negotiations between Google/Meta and the news organization when defining the service contract can explore alternative options (access token, for example) should it be an imperative, for some reason, that the referrer still be inaccessible. People are allowed to talk to each other.
What about bookmarks? I don't think clicking on a bookmark on your browser is going to send any Referer header.
Now, each successful entrance into an article via allowable referrer would come with an access token to allow future access absent of referral. When sharing in the small scale, the news agency can simply allow these links to be shared. But if the reach grows wide, suggesting that a major tech source has picked up the link and should be using their contractually settled upon authentication mechanism instead, then the token can be invalidated.
The access token plan is workable, though still causes annoying linking problems.
Views don't pay the bills. They only want viewers who are willing to pay to play (even if by proxy). C-18 ensures that payment is made, else user access is restricted by legal force. Which is the same outcome if it were done by technical force. They don't care about the restrictions on users who are eschewing payment in either case.
Making them leave and half give up, half come back via a paying search engine or social media site, is not going to be the most effective use of them.