Your idea has been suggested many times but as other sibling comments already noted, Spotify didn't have the leverage in business negotiations to implement that type of payout.
In other words, Spotify needed the vast song catalogs from the Universal + Sony + Warner -- more than those Big 3 Labels needed Spotify.
Your idea has higher payouts (i.e. "more fair") for independent musicians at the expense of less payout for the Big 3 Major Labels. In contrast, the current payout system favors the Big Labels at the expense of independents. Why did this happen? Because the Big Labels have more leverage.
Some factors leading up to the Big Labels negotiating from a position of strength to get more favorable treatment from the "weaker" Spotify:
- 2000: Napster lost its case against Metallica and RIAA
- 2000: mp3.com lost its case for "users CD-ownership-verify-then-playback service"
- 2003: Big Major Labels felt they got screwed by Apple & Steve Jobs iTunes deal with the flat 99 cents pricing.
By the time of 2011 licensing negotiations, they were already winning their lawsuits against the internet "stealing" their music. They were in no mood to give Spotify a sweet deal for access to their song catalogs.
This is why the no-name artists get fractions of pennies adding up a few dollars while Taylor Swift gets millions from Spotify. This unbalanced financial arrangement was the carrot to help get the Big Labels on board. To add to this, Spotify also gave the labels part ownership stock[1]. In contrast, smaller independents like CDBaby and TuneCore didn't get offered Spotify stock. Examples like that should give an idea of how much leverage the Big Labels had.
[1] https://thehustle.co/the-economics-of-spotify/#:~:text=The%2....
Is there an actual statistic around this? The linked article you provided doesn't have it. I'm curious:
1a) What is the average per-stream rate for a song from one of the Big Labels?
1b) What is the average per-stream rate for a song from one of the Big Labels, that is then passed along to the artist after the label takes their own cut?
2) What is the per-stream rate if you self-publish your song via DistroKid instead (that then publishes it to Spotify), that goes directly to the artist?
It's not obvious to me that 1b) is larger than 2). Maybe it is -- but are there actual numbers here? Especially for "average" or "median" artists at a label, not Taylor Swift.
I find the explanation easier to believe that "per stream" is a much simpler & transparent system for the artists that causes less outrage towards Spotify[0]. And to cater to big labels, Spotify just increases their specific per-stream rate (as parent's article explains).
Still, it causes issues like the botting ones in the OP. I don't know, it's really hard to make a conclusion here without the actual numbers.
[0] Imagine you get more streams but less money than your friend with the same indie deal, just because his listeners listen to less music overall. You could convince ME that it's fair from an outsider perspective... but probably not an artist who's trying to make a living.
And honestly, I don't know if that's bad for indie? I mentioned this elsewhere on this thread but anecdotally my friends who listen to a LOT of music mostly listen to indie, not big label. Maybe I'm wrong/my bubble doesn't generalize? I'd love to see numbers if anyone has them.
Whether royalties are calculated per-play-per-user or per-play-per-all-users, I don't see any evidence there's any meaningful difference at all.
Most people who subscribe to Spotify listen to lots of different stuff -- that's the entire point of streaming. Virtually nobody is listening to one song a month, or 2 albums per month. They listen to playlists and radio and their 8,000 liked songs on shuffle. None of the examples you give are very realistic. (Somebody who only listens to one album is just going to buy the album, not subscribe to Spotify.)
In the end, the two models are going to average out to essentially the same.
If you don't think they do, that means you think there's some correlation between the amount of music listened to per month, and whether a person's tastes skew more mainstream or niche. Can you show that's the case, and in which direction? Because that's entirely non-obvious.
(And commercial settings like stores are a drop in the bucket of Spotify subscriptions, they just don't matter. Big places like grocery stores and department stores and fast food don't use Spotify, and coffee shops or clothing boutiques are just as likely to be playing niche stuff.)
Another way they're screwing smaller artists is next year they'll be requiring each song to have 1k streams _per year_ before qualifying for monetization. They estimate that'll steal another ~$40M/year from smaller artists to help line the pockets of majors. It's actually sickening to watch from the sidelines.
I don't see it -- how?
> requiring each song to have 1k streams _per year_ before qualifying for monetization
Each stream is ~$0.004. It doesn't seem unreasonable at all to require a song to hit $4 per year -- or $0.33/mo. -- to qualify. There is some level of overhead involved here, after all. These are ludicrously small amounts of money.
Also how does this "help line the pockets of majors"? It's all just going back into the same pot of revenue that gets shared the same as before. So proportionally it's helping the artists with smaller songs still over 1K streams just as much.
And even if it's $40M, that's just 0.3% of Spotify's overall revenue. Proportionally, it's pretty irrelevant.
This is also compounded by their refusal to adopt a user-centric payment model where the artists you actually listened to that month are the ones your money goes to. Look at comparisons others have published and you’ll see how their current model siphons money from smaller artists towards major label artists (I’m discretely typing this in bits from our local chamber orchestra’s AGM and can’t look up facts for you atm).
With this change, it ensures that even moving to a user-centric model they’ll still be able to underpay smaller artists. It’s not so alarming on its own, but it ensures they can continue to keep the status quo even if they give in to pressure and adopt a user-centric payment model by being able to not have to pay for much of their catalog.
Considering the asks you're making, I imagine you'll have no problem substantiating this?
Here's another article on it: https://www.engadget.com/2019-09-11-deezer-royalty-system-sm...
Unfortunately, they've since changed it to a model that the labels wanted.
Which is very much in favor of the actual people (Major labels) who needed to be convinced to license all their artists to Spotify in the first place. So not really surprising.
Also, would law of big numbers make it so that this kinda evens out like this anyways with today's system?
Shorter tracks would also mean users have more opportunity for listening to a variety of songs/artists. A single user can only listen so much in a day (capped at 24 hours, and more likely 12 hours if they aren't doing some kind of phantom streaming). This would then ultimately dilute the payments to artists releasing a large number of shorter tracks.
This seems a better approach, but in reality I don't know if it is actually better.
I can already see the internet:
"Don't listen to your discover weekly or new music friday it hurts the artists you like."
The first $4 of your monthly sub is divided amongst all artists you listen to based on time spent listening, and any additional money you decide to add to your subscription is distributed to artists as you see fit. You can elect to use the same distribution algorithm as the first $4 of your subscription, use the same algorithm with different weights (e.g. your favorite artists listen time is doubled before payout is computed) or you can choose to have an arbitrary percent of it go to whatever artists you want, even if you don't listen to any of their music. Spotify already has to have a payment engine to support paying all the artists anyway, generalizing it beyond fixed subscriptions seems like an organic way to address the issue of unfair income distribution if they were interested in doing so (I don't think they are).
In the above system, the issue of "don't listen to other artists" only comes up if you don't have enough money to give to the artists you want to support, no different than the incentives of "don't buy the CD of artist A or you won't be able to afford the CD of artist B, who you like and wish to support more."
It would be split into tons of artists for most people but a guaranteed chunk of the monthly would be nice.
It doesn't really address the problem of paying artists per stream, it just means that the per stream rate is variable and dependent on how willing your fans are to play your music on repeat each month.
It's still probably better than the current model, but the only way I'd really be comfortable with it is if we cut out the middle-men. For example, a service owned and operated as a non-profit (or profit-capped) organization owned by an artist collective. The artists set the monthly price based on what makes sense for them to make a living, and the cut given to the service can be minimized to what it takes to run and build the service rather than what it takes to make a profit on top of the work of the artists.
Examples:
- I only listened to one song this month? The full 4$ go to that artist.
- I listened to 2 albums by 2 artists this month, on repeat? 2$ each (assuming the same number of plays for each)
- I listened to 399 tracks from one artist, and one track for another? 3.99$ to the first and 0.01$ to the second.
- The gym next door is streaming Mariah Carey's Chrismas album on repeat? Their 4$ goes to Mariah Carey and mine still goes to the artists I enjoy.
I think the current model of per-stream across the whole platform distorts the playing field towards more popular artists that play in commercial settings.