Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:43AM
(#3846216)
AOL preceded Google by a large margin, and was much, much worse for the Internet. Google has its problems, but it has been by far a net positive.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by bluethrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:06AM
(#3846264)
AOL predates the modern commercial internet. Heck, the first HTTP spec came out 8 or so years after the company started and in the same year they named themselves America Online. Picking on them for not grokking the internet is a bit facile for my liking.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:15AM
(#3846290)
I'm not picking on them; I'm saying their approach to the Internet was similar to Apple's, and the antithesis of Google's.
Also, while they may have predated the web (not Internet), they still acted in direct opposition to it.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by bluethrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @08:14AM
(#3847016)
They did predate the modern commercial internet. Commercial ISPs didn't appear till the late 80s (at best) and AOL started in ~81. In that context they're a weak example to cite.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @12:02PM
(#3847893)
Did you a thallus create an account just to respond to me? I didn't think our exchange was so contentious as to merit a new account.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by talentdeficit on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:50AM
(#3846240)
google have slowly been rebuilding AOL's walled garden for five years now. if anything, they're jealous apple and facebook beat them to it
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:13AM
(#3846283)
You can't simply name Google a walled garden and expect the moniker to reflect reality. Android apps can be acquired anywhere, and most Google services allow you to export your data. Compare that to needing to jailbreak an iPhone to download an app Apple doesn't like, or the complete inability to get your data from facebook.
Google might not be FSF open, but it's far better than those it criticizes.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by Xuzz on Monday April 16, 2012 @03:33AM
(#3846355)
Like this, you mean? https://www.facebook.com/help/?page=116481065103985
It's certainly not a complete copy of everything referencing you in their database, and it only includes information you entered (not friends' details), but it does exist.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by intended on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:45PM
(#3848697)
Doesn't FB keep shadow information as well? Information onpeople who,likely exists, but aren't on FB yet?
So how do those people get their info out?
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by taligent on Monday April 16, 2012 @04:09AM
(#3846457)
FACT: Facebook allows you to get all your data. Google+ doesn't.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by magicalist on Monday April 16, 2012 @04:37AM
(#3846529)
As at least two other comments have responded to you
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by hristov on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:31AM
(#3846186)
You can still get access to the internet without Google. I do not get your point.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by epistasis on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:45AM
(#3846228)
Search is a popular internet service, of which Google is the primary, and for most people, only entry point. Unlike other internet services, such as Usenet or the web or email, there's a single actor that controls the vast majority of search. What's more, this actor will arbitrarily stop listing legitimate websites without explanation, they maintain little to no customer service force to deal with the cases where they mess up, and they seem to not care whatsoever.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by unimpressive on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:17AM
(#3846159)
Did you have something in mind for how a modern design of such systems would work?
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by philwelch on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:31AM
(#3846185)
The better question is, why are people wasting their time trying to invent a federated Facebook instead of a federated Google? People already have lots of ways to share pictures of their cats. But they only have one way to find information on the internet, and if the people running that monopoly did something like compromise the quality of that service to promote their sharing-cat-pictures product, we'd be screwed.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by redthrowaway on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:46AM
(#3846229)
>But they only have one way to find information on the internet
That isn't remotely true. There are dozens of alternatives; Google's simply better. That said, the difference in quality is not so pronounced as it used to be.
Re:Sergey Brin: Facebook and Apple a threat to Internet freedom
by unimpressive on Monday April 16, 2012 @02:37AM
(#3846205)
And yet better still, why implement a federated anything when you can hypothetically have a framework off of which you can spawn a whole host of distributed integrated web services.
Or maybe that's just impossible, haven't really done the research.
All popular internet services used to be designed in a distributed fashion, with no central servers, no single point of failure and no single organization to tell you whether you get access or not.
Then came Google.