Re:Ask HN: Is Knuth's TAOCP worth the time and effort? (2023)
by adastra22 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @01:02PM
(#38448757)
But you’d get all that info, and more, from a numerical analysis textbook.
When I read TAOCP it was right after university at the culmination of an 8 year process where I had self-studied a literal heap of graduate level texts and papers. I had been wrongly advised that TAOCP would be better saved as a capstone, where I could understand better its depths.
It had no depth, and literally everything in it was better and more thoroughly explained by other works I had already engaged with.
Oh, I did learn one very valuable thing: not to blindly trust the advice of others. I wish I had learned that earlier, in which case I could have thrown it on the DNF pile and gotten that month of my life back.
Generally people that continue reading through TAOCP and invest the time and effort in doing so do get value from that or are foolish to keep going.
I read the early volumes thoroughly in the 80s and 90s and got a lot of insight into, for one example, methods for constraining error when doing chained numerical calculations.
His approach alone was inspiring at the time even if specific chapters weren't of any immediate interest.
They're not especially useful for general journeyman programmers and they're but one star in the firmament for people aiming higher .. but they are worth the effort if the material is of interest.