News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:27AM (#38443595)
most consoles had their own build chain, most development studios had tools to use the different build chains.

starcraft made it onto that console, that in and of itself negates most of what is being talked about here

https://starcraft.fandom.com/wiki/StarCraft_64

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by scott_w on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @04:57AM (#38444166)
>> At any rate due to these factors you'd have to make various trade-offs when porting a game from PS1 to N64 or vice versa (cut back on multiplayer, reduce textures, adjust controls, compress audio, etc). There was also no such thing as a universal game engine like Unity or Unreal that could cross-compile for both platforms. On each system you'd have to bake an engine from scratch.

> starcraft made it onto that console, that in and of itself negates most of what is being talked about here

Your statement does not in any way negate the statement you're responding to. Or much of anything in the thread for that matter.

The core of what people are responding to is that you state "console exclusives are a scam," which, at the point in time in history we're talking about, is verifiably not the case. You can point to agreements between companies (Final Fantasy VII being the most famous example) but these are not console exclusives in the modern sense. They were agreements, which had a mixture of commercial and technical factors, to make a game on that console. Once that decision was made, it wasn't really necessary to contractually enforce exclusivity because, until the PS4/XB1 era, porting to a different console was really, really hard.

Did companies do it? Yes. Was it planned in as part of the regular flow of developing a video game? At this point in time? No. It was a decision taken later.

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @09:41AM (#38446210)
you're just wrong here.

https://gamerant.com/ps1-n64-popular-multiplatform-games-gen...

Here's the title

> PS1 Vs. N64: 10 Popular Multiplatform Games Of The Generation (And Which System Ran Them Better)

----

Also, this is what I said

> exclusives are generally a lock-in scam for the companies and say absolutely nothing about the games on a system.

> The question is, did the N64 have a lot of amazing games on it, and the answer is unequivocally yes.

stop attacking strawmen.

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by scott_w on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @10:30AM (#38446715)
> you're just wrong here.

Of this list:

1. Shadowman: maybe intended cross-platform? But wasn't very good

2. Tony Hawk's: was ported after success on PS1

3. Mission: Impossible: was ported to Playstation

4. Spiderman: ported to N64

5. Rayman 2: ported to Playstation

6. Resident Evil 2: ported to N64

7. Forsaken: different games (according to article)

8. The World is Not Enough: article says is a very different game

9. Mega Man Legends: ported to N64

10. South Park: ported to Playstation

---

Your list is total nonsense. Maybe one or two intended as cross-platform titles. Even then, the quality difference is so great, you're only supporting my point.

> exclusives are generally a lock-in scam for the companies and say absolutely nothing about the games on a system.

I'm questioning the "lock-in scam" for the time. It's not a "lock-in scam" if making it cross-platform produces shitter games for lots more money and risk. This is something you don't seem to appreciate.

> did the N64 have a lot of amazing games on it, and the answer is unequivocally yes.

I'm not questioning this point because it's true.

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by chrisco255 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @05:45AM (#38444442)
StarCraft 64 came very late in the N64's lifespan.

It was pretty awful as a console game (as most RTSes would be). It also lacked significant features like online gameplay, voice over cinematics, and significant changes were introduced to make it easier to play with a controller, although none of it worked well enough to make up for the clunkiness of the port itself.

The exception does not disprove the rule. The PS1 had almost 4x more games than N64. If it was trivial to port games then, it would have happened. But of all the generations of consoles past the 16 bit era, that generation in particular probably has the smallest venn diagram overlap of ports available on multiple systems.

Nowadays even indie devs creating experimental games can cheaply port their games to all consoles using a cross-platform engine like Unity or Unreal. Those tools weren't around for that console generation

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @09:34AM (#38446127)
That it wasn't great doesn't matter, the claim is refuted by its existence.
Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by chongli on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @11:40AM (#38447686)
How does StarCraft 64, a game almost no one plays (despite the original PC version being an absolute classic), refute my claim that ports to the N64 were hobbled by severe compromises? Seems to me that it provides overwhelming support for my claim. The game is absolute trash and not worth playing whereas the PC version holds up extremely well.
Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @12:53PM (#38448610)
The original claim is that exclusives somehow decided the quality of the console rather than the overall quality of the games available for the console.

The conversation then derailed into whether or not multi-platform was a thing back then. The answer is that it was, SC64 is a counter-example to the claim that it wasn't a thing.

There are lots of other games that can be brought up as well, such as Tony Hawks pro skater, as another counter-example.

That generation was the first generation where multi-platform started becoming common. It happened in the earlier generation as well (Street Fighter and Kirby are two easy examples), but that generation is where it started becoming common. It only got more common as time went on.

The mistake people are making is confusing "not as common as it is today" with "not common at all". You can literally find listicles of cross platform games for that generation.

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by anthk on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @03:21PM (#38450738)
I was there, I was born in 1987, so I lived thru it. And most of the time the "ports" were just new games up to the point of shifthing the genre because of some really limited platforms.
Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by PH95VuimJjqBqy on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @06:37PM (#38453216)
My first console was the Atari, what you're referring to are some of the games based upon movies that happened.

There were some games like that, but not nearly all.

Re:RPG Engine for the Nintendo 64 by anthk on Wednesday November 29, 2023 @07:57PM (#38467777)
Mine a NES, so yes, there were huge differences on game implementations between consoles and its games.

Even between a C64 and a NES you can' make cloneish ports without sacrifing performance because the NES' PPU it's far better than the C64 counterpart.