Re:The Mobile Paradox
by lazyBilly on Sunday April 15, 2012 @01:47PM
(#3844171)
You guys are missing the point. The problem with mobile is not the ads, it's return on investment. I make mobile apps, and if my profit on a one dollar app is 70 cents, that's a hard limit on my customer acquisition spend. Which is why we don't use admob any more. The clicks are there, they're just not worth much.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by veyron on Sunday April 15, 2012 @10:57AM
(#3843801)
The reality is that ads really have to be Re-envisioned for the mobile space. There's not enough real estate on a phone to put up massive banner ads on a phone, and there's good reason to believe we will see something similar to iAd for android and windows phone (which will benefit the handset and OS guys)
What I expect to see is a new wave of mobile utilities that approach advertising differently, integrating into the workflow rather than the real estate model of the web.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by eli on Sunday April 15, 2012 @11:29AM
(#3843867)
I think you're right about having new, different ways to integrate advertising, but don't forget that (compared to the web) it's much easier to charge the user directly.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by eli on Sunday April 15, 2012 @02:37PM
(#3844291)
That was definitely the rumor, but I think it was mostly speculation along the lines of: Google makes their money from ads, so of course their phone will be wall-to-wall ads.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by eli on Sunday April 15, 2012 @02:44PM
(#3844310)
It seems to me there's a lot of push back from users on the use of interstitial on desktop websites. You think they will be better tolerated on mobile?
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by alecco on Sunday April 15, 2012 @02:42PM
(#3844301)
Are these pieces paid for? The writer's company link (just.me) takes to a very crude homepage with an un-styled Google Spreadshet form requesting subscriptions.
There's nothing new in this article and a lot of speculation.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by joejohnson on Sunday April 15, 2012 @12:41PM
(#3844020)
Wow, there are a lot of typos and grammar errors in this piece. I don't want to sound pedantic, but the article was kind of hard to read.
However, I think that the thesis about mobile in some ways replacing older internet ad paradigms is true. Especially in emerging markets, mobiel internet is the dominant platform for most applications.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by hollerith on Sunday April 15, 2012 @10:27AM
(#3843749)
So apparently, since mobile devices use much smaller screens, it is hard to put an ad and content together on the much smaller screen without annoying the user, and Google has not yet figured out a workaround.
Re:The Mobile Paradox
by technoslut on Sunday April 15, 2012 @11:59AM
(#3843923)
I may agree with you on a basic level but this is far more trouble for Google than it seems.
Mobile apps are incredibly inexpensive compared to their desktop counterparts and a user will always prefer less ads.
Facebook's plan for mobile ads is to embed them in a user's news feed. Google can't do this with search or they will completely poison it along with G+ results.
All relevant info suggests that consumers are using dedicated apps for search and Google can't buy every startup to compete against Amazon, Apple and Facebook.
What I expect to see is a new wave of mobile utilities that approach advertising differently, integrating into the workflow rather than the real estate model of the web.
For better or worse, I can picture of future of free smart phones with unignorable interstitials.
There's nothing new in this article and a lot of speculation.
Michael Arrington is a just.me investor.
http://just.me/2012/01/seed-and-a-round-funding/
However, I think that the thesis about mobile in some ways replacing older internet ad paradigms is true. Especially in emerging markets, mobiel internet is the dominant platform for most applications.
Mobile apps are incredibly inexpensive compared to their desktop counterparts and a user will always prefer less ads.
Facebook's plan for mobile ads is to embed them in a user's news feed. Google can't do this with search or they will completely poison it along with G+ results.
All relevant info suggests that consumers are using dedicated apps for search and Google can't buy every startup to compete against Amazon, Apple and Facebook.