News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be best kept open?

Ever since The Code of Hammurabi, we have benefited from the advantages of laws being public, and therefore open source.

Today, as software eats the world, we allow "proprietary knowledge" to enforce laws. If not make the laws, we at least allow black box code to enforce them. Arguably, this is the same thing.

As "AI" progresses, this seems like it could only get worse, and yet more acceptable.

This could be facial recognition, or social media metrics, or otherwise.

Is it realistic, possible, and necessary to require all software which is used by government to be open source as it is an extension of the law?

I am slightly conflicted. I believe that open source is not a panacea. For example, bio-weapons should not be open sourced.

However, I would argue that we will regress as a species if law, and its enforcement, is not open.

Maybe this is one of the more complex questions that we could consider.

What are your thoughts?

( 15 comments | 5 points | on HN )
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by uberman on Sunday November 26, 2023 @07:37PM (#38426750)
While I dont agreed that all software used by the government needs to be open source and it strikes me that certain software needs to be more than proprietary even top secret. I do agree with the notion that software used to incriminate or identify or charge or sentence people must even should be open source.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by jruohonen on Sunday November 26, 2023 @07:49PM (#38426824)
Much more than that. Insofar as we are talking about public law, I'd argue that ML for granting welfare benefits, calculating taxes, loaning books from a local library, ticket reserving for public transport, and whatever else goes on in mundane public administration should be open source or at least transparent. Note that the argument about trade secrets, by definition, cannot apply in this context, although a practical problem is that public administrations have outsourced their stuff to the private sector (sometimes with catastrophically bad outcomes). It will be interesting to see whether people will increasingly challenge public sector algorithms through FOIs in the future, as I am pretty sure they'll do.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by acdha on Sunday November 26, 2023 @07:44PM (#38426794)
I think there’s also an interesting angle around how and when it becomes open source. You could imagine an escrow-type model where someone selling, say, law-enforcement software might not be required to release it publicly but would be required to escrow every version used by clients and make it available to auditors or defense teams. There’s an interesting balance between allowing people to keep competitive secrets while still allowing oversight and that’s going to require some adjustments over time.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by codingdave on Monday November 27, 2023 @01:04PM (#38435735)
> we allow "proprietary knowledge" to enforce laws.

I'm not sure what you are referring to - do you mean law enforcement using specific tools to decide whom to investigate, or are you talking about actual arrests?

Maybe some examples of what you are thinking of would help?

Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by hardkorebob on Monday November 27, 2023 @10:11PM (#38441827)
Legalese is proprietary knowledge. All law requires a license to practice. We all are wards of the state, children to be taken care of. Blacks Law Dictionary 1931 or sooner. New definitions do not supersede old ones just obfuscate them. The reality is far more interesting when you find out that the IRS and USA CORP is incorp'd in Puerto Rico which is pirate booty(possession). And under Admiralty Law(world law), these 2 corporations are given interesting(defacto) powers over the people in the united Soil of the North American Continent. There is no dejure govt. It is all stolen. Plus the fiat currency produced at a loan from the US Corp to the British Crown owners of the World Bank and IMF. The rabbit hole is not as deep just convoluted to sound like plain English when it is in fact a copyright closed-source system that is forced upon us using indenture contracts. Berth is for boats at a port. Go read about it instead of arguing with me. Go learn the powers of the post office. Understand why a notary is such an important asset and how they are all scared because big bro is over them telling them not to witness. You dont need a notary but you need 2 more living beings that are willing to sign. An interesting world we live in and I just want to be left alone. The system is broken utterly. Just let me open source my life and deal with everyone in peace. Screw us law.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by benf76 on Monday November 27, 2023 @11:27PM (#38442333)
You have any sources or references to chase the rabbit down the hole here?
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by hardkorebob on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @09:02AM (#38445748)
I already gave it to you. Go buy Black's Law Dictionary from 1931 or sooner. Then go understand red-tape and administrative process.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by benf76 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @09:32AM (#38446103)
Is blacks law dictionary addressing the incorporation of US corp in Puerto Rico?
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by hardkorebob on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @10:07AM (#38446495)
That is a matter of public record in Puerto Rico. All copies are available for a fee. Due diligence. Go to San Juan looking like an American Senator, go into the courthouse and pay the monies to get all the info you want. Of course you need to know how to read Spanish and how to ask for the right documents. Lost to the citizens is the understanding of how to really do business(law).
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by benf76 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @11:04AM (#38447179)
What documents? Why the reluctance to provide any clear details or sources? Where do you have this knowledge from? A book would be easier to start with than impersonating a senator and going to Puerto Rico. Are you trying to inform or dissemble?
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by hardkorebob on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @01:59PM (#38449727)
There is no book other than Admiralty Law and Black's Law Dict. No one said impersonate. I said look like one. That means be an old white man. See the difference? Reluctance? You don't understand what the Public Record is? I can only point to the direction. The knowledge comes from follow the money. The knowledge is in the Public Record. You can't access documents from the US. How is none of these details clear to you?
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by benf76 on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @02:27PM (#38450077)
And which document do I request upon my arrival to San Juan?
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by philipkglass on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @08:46PM (#38454386)
This poster's theories sound like creative legal interpretations (not recognized by courts) from the "sovereign citizen" movement:

https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Sovereign_citizen_movement

Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by coretx on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @08:43PM (#38454370)
"His" "rabbit hole" went mainstream since Lessig released his book "code is law" while everyone was partying like it was 1999. Massive amounts of both amateur and academic discourse followed, got picked up by civil society world wide, all with their own take. Think pirate parties, NGOs like EFF, the Free software movement, and so on. Yet here we are today, a ever growing need for these questions and a equally rising unlikeliness for universally workable answers. I for one don't care much about open source if i can't have a free and informed vote for a legislator.
Re:Ask HN: Software is now an extension of law, would it be ... by eimrine on Tuesday November 28, 2023 @11:09AM (#38447254)
> I believe that open source is not a panacea. For example, bio-weapons should not be open sourced.

What benefits it brings to society if to restrict some but not other parties from researching bio-weapons? For example, would you be happy if some domains of Physics/Mathematics is banned for everyone except some US students of some limited set of universities?