On the other hand, the technocrats are beholden to actual elected officials, instead of the current situation where a group of random people selected by private companies coordinate their work by consensus without much formal structure and the members are beholden to nobody by their company boss.

Rule by consensus is basically democracy by whoever is motivated enough to show up. It seems to have an extremely good track record, especially compared with rule by central bureaucracy.

The exception is if the consensus is only among a small handful of large corporations that lack competition and then become the unaccountable technocrats. But in that case what you want from governments is not to take over as the malevolent bureaucracy, it's antitrust enforcement.

And those elected officials are beholden to the highest bidder. In the current system, the people who make CA decisions acquired that power voluntarily and seem to have acted benevolently in the past, that's way more than you can say about government officials.

The current voluntary system is also very open, and anyone can get involved and participate to a much larger extent than people realistically can in an electoral democracy. To me, the voluntary system seems to be better and safer for everyone who doesn't have a very large amount of money to throw at elections.

And big EU tech successes like GDPR, DMA and many others. What's your point?

This is about identity regulation, not random rockets.

I certainly wouldn't call those successes.

What's your concern with Galileo? Many experts consider it to be the best GNSS currently available:[1]

> The US constellation isn’t as accurate as the newer networks, said Roberts, the Sydney-based professor. “It used to be GPS was out in front,” he said. Now, though, the EU’s Galileo is in the lead, with China’s BeiDou close behind, he said.

[1] https://www.bloomberg.com/news/articles/2023-09-20/russia-s-...

Thanks for backing up your point with a link. I agree that Galileo is more accurate than the much older GPS system. On the other hand, the GPS system became fully operational in 1995 as far as I understand, and the Galileo system is yet to be fully operational almost a decade after the original target date.