News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by netsharc on Thursday November 23, 2023 @08:12PM (#38399718)
> It'll be a different being, that just so happens to be a perfect clone.

But will you even be aware of that?

> Even if to an outside observer it'll be indistinguishable from you

And how about the inside observer?

I used to think like you do. But now I think, Logan2 will have your memory, it should even think "well that's done, now where's my wife, she said she'll meet me and after this procedure we'll go get ice cream.". Or things like "Ah yeah I got to deal with my brother, he said something hurtful and we need to fix this conflict.". And your "soul" should not notice anything being different.

If the copies are identical, shouldn't they generate the same thoughts, be triggered by the same things, like the smell of the wife's perfume or be e.g. irrationally angry at someone revving their car, and are we aware enough to think "Hang on, something's different?".

To be technical about it, it's like having a virtual machine's state be copied onto a new host system, I think even the process called awareness or soul is a result of our software/hardware configuration, and nothing external, and the awareness would be an identical copy.

Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by brhsagain on Friday November 24, 2023 @04:13AM (#38401957)
Thought experiment: what if you copied and restored the backup into two bodies, and both bodies were a state continuation of the original? Would the two existences be simultaneously the smae person? I think it would make more sense to say that at the moment of cloning the two bodies are separate consciousnesses with the same state.

In your analogy, if you copied the VM state onto two different host systems, I would think each host system would be a separate conscious experience. It's whatever being a host system is that generates consciousness, not the state itself.

Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by netsharc on Friday November 24, 2023 @12:38PM (#38406259)
I'm sure there's been movies about the scenario.. But yeah, it'd be weird to look at another person and he thinks he's me. It'd be hard to look from the outside at my copy and think "That's me, with all my knowledge and my thought processes", but.. it'd be the case.
Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by LoganDark on Friday November 24, 2023 @09:08AM (#38404074)
> But will you even be aware of that?

Can people stop missing the point and asking if the clone will know that it's a clone or not? Because that doesn't really matter. It doesn't matter what the clone thinks - I still died.

Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by netsharc on Friday November 24, 2023 @11:14AM (#38405407)
RIP.

I see you're in no mood to argue, but to me this death seems like the view of an external observer. As I say, I think my clone will happily live on thinking he's me, with all his (my) memories and his feelings and thoughts about the world, and about his own mind...

Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by LoganDark on Friday November 24, 2023 @12:10PM (#38406012)
It's not that I'm not in the mood to argue, it's that the life and experiences of my clone won't matter to me. If I wanted to carry on a legacy or something that was larger than myself, then sure, I'd want that clone in the world even if I wouldn't get to see it myself. But in the sense of "I want to carry on living", I'd rather not die to get there, you know?
Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by netsharc on Friday November 24, 2023 @12:27PM (#38406163)
I've been trying to argue that my "self" will think I've continued on living, I'll have my old memories, the happy and painful ones; I'll have the stuff I have in my agenda for next week, I'll have my likes and dislikes, the only difference is that they're stored in a different physical place (brain or SSD?). In that sense, did I die? I'll feel as content as my old self about the things I feel content about, etc, etc...

I think the soul is just like an instance of a software running on hardware, and if the software and hardware are identical, why should the copy of an instance not think "I'm instance 'LoganDark'"?

Subjectively, true, your original died, but if there's an identical copy, won't this perspective of the subject just be transferred over to the copy, with all the identical historical past?

Re:A startup is pitching a mind-uploading service that is "1... by LoganDark on Friday November 24, 2023 @02:02PM (#38407027)
The thing is that you're absolutely right and I never meant to dispute what you're saying. However just like the teleporter that deconstructs you and reconstructs you somewhere else, even though the person that comes out is entirely identical to the person that went in and will also feel as such (i.e. nothing went wrong from their perspective), the person that went in experienced death, and will never actually get to be the person that came out.

Basically, you killed someone, then restored a snapshot of when they were still alive. The one you killed will never know of the snapshot or get to be that snapshot, while the snapshot will live on exactly as the original would have. I don't want to be that original who never gets to see the snapshot.

Yes, the snapshot will inherit everything that makes me "me", and yes the snapshot will get to live life normally. But I die.