Re:Polio Is on the Brink of Eradication
by SpaceManNabs on Friday November 24, 2023 @10:10AM
(#38404737)
> And any utilitarian thinker who wanted to do the op would tell you that they weren't going to get caught
Then they aren't being utilitarian because they are not including the risk into their cost calculation.
Or at least not a good one. Definitely not "any"
edit:
Oh I see this now > who wanted to do the op
Yeah any person can make any false argument to justify a conclusion they wanna reach. You don't have to be utilitarian for that. Just unethical.
Re:Polio Is on the Brink of Eradication
by NateEag on Saturday November 25, 2023 @01:51AM
(#38411768)
> Then they aren't being utilitarian because they are not including the risk into their cost calculation.
Sure they are.
They just estimate the risk much lower than you do.
You have no way to know who's right for sure.
Maybe they legitimately have found a really low-risk way to massively increase utils by cheating / mistreating a few people.
I don't know of a way to protect utilitarian systems from such conditions.
Is that good reasoning? No.
Is it what some humans will do? Yes.