News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by bluedino on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @02:54PM (#38384268)
What is the enterprise virtualization alternative?

Is everyone on Hyper V already? Does Citrix still exist?

Are SuSE or Red Hat offering an 'open source' alternative? Surely people aren't using Proxmox in production?

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by jzb on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:16PM (#38384529)
Red Hat has/had Red Hat Virtualization but has transitioned that to Red Hat OpenShift Virtualization as a successor. I think RHV is set to phase out in 2026, and I'm not sure if they're currently selling new subs or just servicing existing customers with other folks pointed to RHOV.

The oVirt community's most recent release is from last December, so I'm not sure whether that project is going to thrive now that Red Hat has largely stepped away. (Last blog update is also December 2022.)

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by _jal on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:35PM (#38384738)
RHV is dead, they're trying to move people over to (the much more expensive) OpenShift. Support for it has gotten predictably worse.

I don't expect Ovirt to survive, the vast majority of development was RH.

"The market" seems to "deciding" that in-house virtualization will be insanely expensive, and otherwise you need to rent OCP.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by tlamponi on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:14PM (#38384513)
> Surely people aren't using Proxmox in production?

Lot's do, e.g., the Austrian domain registry:

https://www.proxmox.com/en/about/stories/story/nic-at

And many others (albeit the big ones aren't listed there, a bit harder to get real testimonials from them, and we do not pester everybody):

https://www.proxmox.com/en/about/stories?f=7

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by noinsight on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:42PM (#38384815)
Red Hat used to offer Red Hat Virtualization (RHV) - based on oVirt - but they killed that at approximately the same time this VMware deal was announced (supposedly coincidentally).

Now they bolted on virtual machines onto their OpenShift container platform and are pushing that.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by sebazzz on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:26PM (#38384639)
Hyper-V server is killed by Microsoft, though you can of course install Windows Server in Core mode and install the Hypervisor component.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by tonoto on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @04:01PM (#38385040)
Keep the eyes open on https://oxide.computer/ - they are building hyperscalar racks with open source components. Using bhyve as the hypervisor, API as a first class citizen, Terraform/Opentofu, live-migration. Can't wish for much more
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by 0dayz on Thursday November 23, 2023 @07:27AM (#38392032)
Why... bhyve, there's 0 advantages to kvm.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by steve1977 on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:55PM (#38396817)
Not being GPL might be one
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by tonoto on Thursday November 23, 2023 @03:18PM (#38397065)
The question was "What is the enterprise virtualization alternative?"

..and your answer is kvm? KVM in itself is enterprise? ..or was it in context to my response referring to Oxide as an enterprise alternative? Well, in that case I can tell that there are only advantages to bhyve as the code base of kvm fork is old and all focus shifted to bhyve which build with todays hardware in mind.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by keep_reading on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:53PM (#38397982)
Massive IO performance over KVM due to the emulated NVME driver. Bhyve may be juvenile compared to KVM but it seems to have a better design and a better license.

https://klarasystems.com/articles/virtualization-showdown-fr...

edit: also bhyve runs on SmartOS too, and I think Bryan is going to be more comfortable with a Solaris OS under the hood

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by Always_Anon on Monday November 27, 2023 @10:31PM (#38441988)
>Massive IO performance over KVM due to the emulated NVME driver.

That is incorrect. It's faster than KVM's virtio, not faster than KVM's NVMe. They didn't bother to test KVM's NVMe virtualization[0]. To quote your source: "As it turns out, bhyve/NVMe isn’t just faster than bhyve/VirtIO—it’s faster than KVM/VirtIO as well" They're comparing apples to oranges. Why would they do that?

"Meet the Author: Jim Salter"

Oh, that's why.

>Bhyve may be juvenile compared to KVM but it seems to have a better design

Likely not, debatable.

>better license.

Debatable, but I get it.

>also bhyve runs on SmartOS too, and I think Bryan is going to be more comfortable with a Solaris OS under the hood

Most definitely why. KVM uses a lot of Linux kernel specific interfaces and functions. Bhyve is easier to port due to this.

[0] https://qemu-project.gitlab.io/qemu/system/devices/nvme.html

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by mvdwoord on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:07PM (#38384435)
Containers containers containers ;)

In all seriousness, I think it is a hot topic in Enterprise Architecture (tm) meeting rooms ever since the merger was announced (I know it was in ours). But even if you find an alternative, you need to move, and a lot of companies have a lot of hard to modernize workloads which are skillfully managed by a lot of VMware trained personnel. No easy task.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by navaati on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @03:01PM (#38384351)
RedHat and a couple other companies will sell you OpenStack clusters, up to a certain size.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by nullindividual on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:11PM (#38386548)
Hyper-V isn't dead by any means, however I would have a very difficult time recommending it in a greenfield environment. Microsoft's focus is clearly not A) Windows Server and B) Hyper-V.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by MrDrMcCoy on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @06:54PM (#38386982)
OpenNebula is what my current employer is looking at for our next move.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by remir on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:08PM (#38387185)
XCP-NG + Xen Orchestra is a solid combo. XCP-NG is based on Xen.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by totallywrong on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:12PM (#38387242)
OpenStack was all the rage some years ago, but I rarely hear about it these days. It does seem like a mature, viable option.
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by rrdharan on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @08:20PM (#38387926)
You never hear about it because it’s mostly dead.

Would love to hear a counter argument or evidence otherwise but my impression is there are very few successful openstack deployments out there and mostly it just is useful to provide some negotiating leverage when talking to your VMware rep.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by lta on Thursday November 23, 2023 @02:16AM (#38390268)
OVH uses OpenStack to power a large a amount of it's offering afaict, and they're a pretty large provider
Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by johnvanommen on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:47AM (#38391096)
> OVH uses OpenStack to power a large a amount of it's offering afaict,

YMMV, but I think one of the main drivers of OpenStack is that it can be modified, because it's open source.

IE, if you're Verizon / AT&T / T-Mobile, it's valuable to be able to modify the product to suit your needs. I did some work on an OpenStack project a couple of years ago where the client wanted to leverage some hardware that was absolutely cutting edge. Literally so new, that engineers from the hardware vendor were involved in tweaking and optimizing things.

Try doing that with VMWare; it's impossible. With OpenStack, there's nothing stopping you from modding the product to suit your needs.

Obviously, this works particularly well if you're running hundreds or thousands of servers and you can justify the investment. If I were only running a few dozen VMs, OpenStack is probably overkill.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by johnvanommen on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:41AM (#38391072)
> You never hear about it because it’s mostly dead.

> Would love to hear a counter argument or evidence otherwise but my impression is there are very few successful openstack deployments out there

I've been doing OpenStack continuously for 10+ years, and it's never been more popular than today.

It's bizarre how people think it's dead.

The biggest difference between OpenStack in 2013 and OpenStack in 2023 is that in 2013 there were a dozen different vendors promoting it, and in 2023 it's basically Canonical and RedHat.

The CEO of Canonical wrote an editorial years ago, basically arguing that the implosion that happened in 2017-ish, when Cisco/VMWare/HPE/Pistoncloud/etc threw in the towel would be good for OpenStack. And I think that was true.

It's very similar to what happened to Linux, remember how there was a period where there were 20+ distros vying for supremacy?

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by mschuster91 on Thursday November 23, 2023 @07:39AM (#38392129)
> It's bizarre how people think it's dead.

Lots of reasons:

- the Python 2-3 migration clusterfuck (which is when I got to play around with it) burned a lot of people

- the learning curve just to get it set up and running is absolutely and horribly insane. It's understandable given its history of being open-source and because of that loved by universities who could shoehorn their existing crap infrastructure/hardware/designs into it. But that makes setting it up very very tedious and annoying, because there's countless options in the depths of its configuration files that you all need to go over so you don't miss anything.

- related: the effort required to set up clusters is soooo much higher for OpenStack vs VMware. VMware ESXi? A day or two, including racking and wiring, and I got something to show to my boss. OpenStack? Talk about three weeks until the myriad of its services are running without crashing under your feet twice an hour. Been there, done that, for both.

- the amount of people and skillsets you need to keep an OpenStack production cluster alive are, I'd say, double the headcount required for the usual VMware+Cisco+Netapp "standard" environment.

- there's barely any commercial support for OpenStack. And that's not "just" the usual vendor support side, but also the management side... finding freelancers or staff that has experience with VMware+Cisco+Netapp is easy, there's tons of people and MSPs with certifications on the market, but for OpenStack? Whoops.

Basically, even a small shop can't go wrong with a basic VMware setup, but OpenStack just doesn't make financial sense unless you're either an university (where you can hand over parts of the ops and support to students, and that has large enough demand for homegrown QEMU-KVM libvirt setups just being Not Enough anymore) or a huge institution (ISP, hosting provider, telco, large multinational megacorp) that wants to save the fuckton of money to VMware for licenses and has enough scale that the headcount for ops staff + Python developers is cheaper than VMware licenses.

What also killed a lot of demand for OpenStack (and a lot of other on-prem) was the general availability of reasonably-good-enough cloud providers. Why invest into an OpenStack environment and all the effort associated, when you can just rent servers on AWS?

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by transpute on Wednesday November 22, 2023 @07:21PM (#38387372)
> Does Citrix still exist

Yes, https://www.xenserver.com/ and French OSS derivative https://xcp-ng.org

Citrix is now a private company run by former Broadcom head of software who negotiated VMware acquisition, https://www.crn.com/news/cloud/citrix-tibco-new-ceo-tom-krau...

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by edwintorok on Thursday November 23, 2023 @04:06AM (#38390891)
Xenserver is not part of Citrix anymore. It is a sibling business unit, part of its parent company Cloud Software Group. See https://cloud.com and https://www.xenserver.com/story

Disclaimer: I work here

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by merlyn on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:08AM (#38389877)
Hyper-V as most people actually use it is more like single-host VMware ESXi.

VMware's true magic is with vCenter. While Microsoft has an equivalent to that (SC VMM), nobody seems to use it because it is virtually unusable. I've never seen a successful production cluster of VMM running.

Re:VMware is now part of Broadcom by locusm on Thursday November 23, 2023 @01:47AM (#38390086)
My picks would be - Proxmox 8 if you predominately run Linux workloads - XCP-NG + XOA - XenServer