News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by legutierr on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:24PM (#38359211)
> And given that we've seen exchange after exchange fail to perform basic tasks like "don't commingle customer funds," I have a hard time feeling any sympathy for cryptocurrency companies here.

There is nothing per se nefarious about co-mingling customer funds, provided that you are otherwise compliant with the law.

Banks, for instance, don't just co-mingle customer funds, they invest those funds on their own behalf and reap the profits for themselves. Sometimes a bank will share a portion of its profit with its customers, in the form of intest; more often, the bank pays little or no interest, and actually charges the customer fees. A bank will risk its customers' money, and its customers will pay for that privilege.

Kraken has been operating under the money transmitter licensing scheme for a decade, and like banks, money transmitters don't have any legal requirement to segregate customer funds—although they do have the responsibility to maintain sufficient cash balances or liquid investments to cover all of what they owe to customers.

Whether Kraken is breaking the law is something that will likely be decided by a court. The SEC asserts that Kraken has broken the law, but it is not up to the SEC to decide—it is up to the courts.

It is not illegal to operate a spot commodities exchange without approval from the SEC, unless those commodities are also the kinds of securities the trading of which require SEC approval. It is also not illegal to operate as an unlicensed broker-dealer of non-security commodities, or as an unlicensed custodian of non-security commodities. The SEC only has jurisdiction over securities.

It is not in the slightest bit clear yet that the crypto tokens for sale on Kraken are in fact securities of any kind. The SEC asserts that they are, but at this point it is just an assertion. The SEC will have to win in court.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by discodave on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:51PM (#38359417)
> For what its worth, banks don't just co-mingle customer funds, they invest those funds on their own behalf and reap the profits for themselves.

And that is why banks are regulated, must register, follow certain rules etc.

> Kraken has been operating under the money transmitter licensing scheme for a decade

Yeah, but that doesn't give them a license to operate a securities exchange, or a bank. How many other money transmitters (that are not registered securities exchanges or banks) have 'tokens for sale' like Kraken?

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by przeor on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:12AM (#38359588)
Please read more cerfully before commenting xD
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by legutierr on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:00AM (#38363090)
> How many other money transmitters (that are not registered securities exchanges or banks) have 'tokens for sale' like Kraken?

Quite a few. In fact, all of the centralized exchanges operating in the US are authorized to do so because they are licensed money transmitters (with the exception of some that might be operating under the NYS "Trust" licensing scheme). For years until very recently the money transmitter licensing scheme was understood to be the correct (and sufficient) licensing scheme under which a crypto exchange could legally operate in the United States.

It is only since the beginning of the Biden administration that the SEC has taken the position that crypto exchanges have an obligation to register with the SEC. The Ripple lawsuit was filed at the tail end of the Trump administration (after the election), but it was not targeted at exchanges. It's also worth noting that the judge in the Ripple case found that exchange-traded XRP tokens are not securities. In other words, the SEC's assertion of authority over exchange-traded Ripple tokens was explicitly denied.

There is good reason to believe that SEC will be unsuccessful in asserting even broader authority over all tokens that are available on Kraken.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by westurner on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @01:31PM (#38367907)
In order to justify such a specific claim against Kraken to be heard, isn't it necessary to first qualify that such assets are themselves securities?

Am I crazy to call this vexatious harassment?

If P then Q:

If {x,y,z} are securities, [ then {Exchanges a, B, and C} have provided securities exchange services of assets {x,y,z} without the requisite license are thus owe a civil fine. ]

But how is a suit against Exchange A the appropriate forum to hear whether assets {x, y, or z} are securities?

Given that - presumably - assets {x,y,z} are not yet ruled to be securities, there was not sufficient cause or standing to make a claim of bad faith or intent to provide exchange services for unregistered securities.

Exchange A operated in good faith, pursued the requisite state and federal procedures for assessing whether or not such assets were securities, and specifically does not intend to sell securities.

Should there be an is_this_a_security() function of a US government regulatory agency, defendants would be required to request such review before listing said specific types of assets.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by bbarnett on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:51PM (#38359422)
Kraken has been operating under the money transmitter licensing scheme for a decade, and like banks, money transmitters don't have any legal requirement to segregate customer funds—although they do have the responsibility to maintain sufficient cash balances or liquid investments to cover all of what they owe to customers.

I think you meant to say here and unlike banks, because banks absolutely do not need to have sufficient funds to cover all customer's savings.

Unless.. are things different in the US? It's been a decade since I've read the Bank Act (Canadian), and when I did, only 5% of customer's account holdings were required to be held in tangible assets (gold, cash, etc), and inspected yearly by the Minister of Finance.

And I believe even that requirement has been dropped.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by WinstonSmith84 on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @03:50AM (#38361099)
Yes, banks typically do not have sufficient funds to cover all customer's savings, and when customers realize their bank played with their money but lost, they freak out and do a so called "bank run". At least banks are regulated, so that's fine, right.

For those who have a short memory, a bank run last occurred earlier this year with the Silicon Valley Bank... https://www.investopedia.com/svb-financial-group-shares-crat...

By the way, if you put your cash money in a bank, your money is insured up to 250,000USD in the US and up to 100,000EUR in the EU. Anything above is your own risk. But it's perfectly fine because at least, it's regulated.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by lottin on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:16AM (#38361287)
Canada follows Basel rules for banking, which are much more complicated than that.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by bbarnett on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:18AM (#38362156)
Basel does not hold sway over the Dominion of Canada! We follow Her Majesty's Bank Act.

https://laws-lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/acts/b-1.01/

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by lottin on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @06:41AM (#38362334)
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by legutierr on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:18AM (#38362635)
You seem to be conflating “segregating customer funds” and “having enough assets to cover customer obligations.”

Both banks and money transmitters (including Kraken) need to maintain sufficient assets to cover customer obligations. The difference is that for money transmitters those assets have to be liquid, while for banks they do not have to be liquid (which is why SVB got into trouble).

On the other hand, neither banks nor money transmitters need to designate specific assets as being held on behalf of customers, specifically, separate and apart from their own capital or operating accounts. Designating specific accounts or balances as being held on behalf of customers is typically what is meant by “segregating customer funds”.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by vasco on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:40AM (#38360573)
> Banks, for instance, don't just co-mingle customer funds, they invest those funds on their own behalf and reap the profits for themselves. Sometimes a bank will share a portion of its profit with its customers, in the form of intest; more often, the bank pays little or no interest, and actually charges the customer fees. A bank will risk its customers' money, and its customers will pay for that privilege.

Banking has not worked like this in quite a few years.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by KRAKRISMOTT on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:54AM (#38360682)
Is Glass Steagall still a thing?
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by JohnFen on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @12:13PM (#38366585)
Sadly, no. It was repealed in 1999.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by 5ersi on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @04:23AM (#38361358)
Fractional reserve banking is exactly how this works, albeit banks do not "invest" the customers' money, instead they lend it.
Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by legutierr on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @07:08AM (#38362549)
What is a loan but an investment? What is government debt? What are mortgage backed securities?

The investments that banks can make are restricted, but it is not inaccurate to call them investments.

Re:SEC charges Kraken for operating as an unregistered secur... by nivertech on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @08:56AM (#38363629)
> It is not illegal to operate a spot commodities exchange without approval from the SEC

In the case of spot markets CFTC can only intervene if there is a fraud or manipulation. There is also “actual delivery rule”, I.e. if crypto “exchange” didn’t settled spot trade on underlying Blockchain or a ledger in 28 days - they effectively created a derivative, and fall under the CFTC mandate.