News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by GuB-42 on Monday November 20, 2023 @07:42AM (#38347156)
There is also that Star Wars is quite loose in its narrative, requiring a significant amount of suspension of disbelief.

Star Wars, if you look at it closely, has many inconsistencies, and it is rather shallow. But it does a great job at letting our minds fill in the gaps. The trench run is, I think, an unwanted result of that. It is almost set up as if they want us to believe that the final trench run happens at the equator, so that's what we believe, because we have been trained for the entire movie to ignore small details and think big.

This is in contrast to films like, for example, Inception, that clearly encourages the audience to look at every little detail.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by pjc50 on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:34AM (#38347764)
> Star Wars is quite loose in its narrative, requiring a significant amount of suspension of disbelief. Star Wars, if you look at it closely, has many inconsistencies, and it is rather shallow

This is the duality of the original trilogy.

(Since we're talking about the trench run: if you've not seen it, please enjoy the audio of the trench run played over the corresponding sequence from 633 Squadron, itself based on true events.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=4OZq-tlJTrU )

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by hotnfresh on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:34AM (#38348839)
633 isn’t as based-on-true-events as Dambusters. AFAIK there was no actual collapse-a-cliff mission, though various sub pen destruction bombing attacks were carried out.

It’s true that the action in 633 is closer to Star Wars, though. Dambusters is what Lucas cribbed some lines and the cutting between the action and the control room thing from, but the action itself is more from 633. It’s also a better movie. The action in Dambusters is remarkably ugly and hard to follow even by the standards of contemporary (and much older!) air combat movies.

[edit] oh, and talk about ripping off 633—the new Top Gun! Complete with all the mocked-up training runs! Hahaha.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by NelsonMinar on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:40AM (#38350243)
This side-by-side treatment of Dambusters is good fun too https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=lNdb03Hw18M

No trench at all! They just had to skip the bomb off the surface of the water...

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by davidw on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:07AM (#38347419)
> Star Wars is quite loose in its narrative, requiring a significant amount of suspension of disbelief

"Hey, kid, it ain't that kind of movie"

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by ethbr1 on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:31AM (#38347723)
The maddening thing is that it is that kind of movie in many places.

It has rules, it has structure, it has proposed reasons that things work the way they do.

People wouldn't be nearly as obsessed about Star Wars if it were all just handwavey reasoning.

One reason, for all it's flaws, Last Jedi is my favorite new film. It simultaneously admits (through character dialog) that "there are rules" and "there are egregiously no rules".

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by throw_m239339 on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:49AM (#38347997)
> One reason, for all it's flaws, Last Jedi is my favorite new film. It simultaneously admits (through character dialog) that "there are rules" and "there are egregiously no rules".

To each of their own, the meta in the Last Jedi is precisely why I hated that movie. Too many times it was the director speaking directly to the audience, in particular "the fans". This is simply not why I watch Star Wars. It also plagiarized a Battle Star Galactica episode a bit too much, and who the hell puts an epilogue in the middle of trilogy? Clearly Rian Johnson didn't care about what was going to be next.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by quacked on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:27PM (#38355069)
I can't stand that guy. In Johnson's last three movies, the only skill as a storyteller he demonstrates is castigation of the audience for their provincial admiration of "traditional" values like strength, heroism, stoicism, self-sacrifice, elitism, narrative predictability, etc. Oscar Isaac's mistrust of Laura Dern's brilliant plan to mock him in front of the soldiers and then take no action against the pursuers, Mark Hamill's apathy and cowardice in the face of renewed galactic domination, Chris Evans's deception and murderous intent to acquire his inheritance defend "his birthright" (which was actually built by a foreigner in 1980.)

I've heard he's making a third Knives Out sequel. To save time, here's the twist: whichever character(s) Johnson has picked to represent "Norman Rockwell America" did the crime, and they did it for a stupid reason they didn't think through. Whichever characters Johnson picked to represent the antithesis of tradition will come through and expose the villainy and stupidity of the old guard, while remaining morally pure of heart.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by everdrive on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:50AM (#38348023)
The Last Jedi was an abomination, filled with misdirection for misdirection’s sake, at the cost of a coherent or entertaining narrative. It’s also filled with awful postmodern tropes that it conjures out of nowhere. “Hey, it turns out there are ancient Jedi texts” But their whole purpose in the film is so that they can be burned and discarded. “Oh, they were never all that important anyhow, just make your own rules.”
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by IggleSniggle on Monday November 20, 2023 @08:58AM (#38348153)
I dunno, compare that to any holy book. It's incredibly important, but also it never really mattered anyhow. Of course it matters because of its impact on society, but the lessons are universal with or without the sacred text.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by everdrive on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:44AM (#38350297)
But what if you’re 15 books into your fictional universe, and during one chapter, it turns out a major faction has extremely important ancient texts. And then as soon as those texts are discovered, they’re flippantly burned because actually they’re not important at all! The most important thing is to just be yourself.

It’s bad writing. If they wanted to discard something sacred, they could have taken something which was actually in the series and discarded _that_. They sort of did this by ruining Luke’s character, only to reverse it at the end and have him save the day anyway. Really, Luke’s characterization really follows the same pattern. He was strongly characterized in all the other Star Wars films. Then Last Jedi throws this out the window for no reason whatsoever. Then by the time you’ve accepted that he’s a loser now, he steps up and saves the day. All more or less within the blink of an eye.

They’re just setting up a subverting expectations for the sake of doing so. It’s terrible writing, and terrible storytelling.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by hotnfresh on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:05PM (#38350619)
> They sort of did this by ruining Luke’s character, only to reverse it at the end and have him save the day anyway. Really, Luke’s characterization really follows the same pattern. He was strongly characterized in all the other Star Wars films. This was thrown out the window for no reason whatsoever.

This complaint about TLJ resonates the least with me, as a (super, at one time) fan from well before the prequels. The seeds of this later Luke and of the situation of the Jedi are there in the OT, and I’m not sure what else you do with hermit-Luke in the setting established for the new trilogy. Sticking with “he’s still a gung-ho hero” doesn’t break “routine” (Johnstone’s terminology) and wouldn’t be good storytelling, and the way in which the routine will be broken has already been hemmed in by choices in VII (he’s withdrawn from taking an active role in galactic politics). At least with this direction, there’s somewhere to go with the character, and conflict for his scenes that’s not a straight repeat of him and Yoda in Empire.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by robto on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:59PM (#38355510)
The books weren't actually destroyed, there is a shot of Rey with them on Millenium Falcon at the end of the movie when they pick up all the survivors. I was actually really excited about this foreshadowing a Jedi reformation - a rediscovery of true orthodoxy a la Luther and a rejection of the corrupt ediface of the Jedi Order, as seen by its fruits. This was further paralleled by the stable boy at the end using the force to summon his broom - a parallel to turning over of interpretational authority of scripture from the ecclesiastics to the laity.

Of course, all this was thrown away in the next installment, so it turns out I'm the fool!

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by dbingham on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:21AM (#38348611)
There are a lot of things I really loved about Last Jedi and a lot of things I really hated about Last Jedi. It was such a mixed bag.

I hate the way it threw out the Star Wars universe's physics - because it took me right out of the universe. Yes, the Star Wars universe never had realistic physics, but it did have reasonably self-consistent physics and Last Jedi threw them away. It had bombs falling in space (as opposed to being projected as missiles), it had turbolasers arcing (not something it ever had before), it introduced hyperspace fuel in order to make the finale escape make sense (they could have just used an interdictor instead). It was maddening.

But they almost did something really cool with the force, throwing out the dark/light dichotomy and replacing it with balance. They could have had Rey and Ben actually see eye to eye and both become grey Jedi after dispatching Snoke and finally obtaining the prophesied balance in the force. That would have opened up all kinds of interesting new places to take Star Wars and new stories to explore. But they chickened out at the last second.

And then yeah, the whole last half of the movie with the slow space chase, escape plan, side quest... none of that made any sense in terms of its writing.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by iainmerrick on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:31AM (#38348787)
I strongly agree on all counts. Overall, the bad outweighed the good for me; but at least it tried and I give it points for that. The other two sequels were just lazy.

The best modern Star Wars movie by far was Rogue One. In some ways Rogue One had an easier job because it was explicitly an exercise in elaborating on the original movies, rather than trying to expand in a brand new direction. But it did its job tremendously well. (And the TV show Andor is taking things in cool new directions.)

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by ethbr1 on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:15PM (#38352945)
At this point with movies, especially franchise movies, I'm more interested in how high the highest points of a film hit than the average level.

If you do 1 really cool thing and 99 shitty things? Still into it! And TLJ does better than that.

There's far too much average pablum out there. Or almost worse, a movie that's entirely just slightly better than average... but never exceed slightly better.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by hef19898 on Monday November 20, 2023 @05:23PM (#38355760)
Rogue One was great. The moment I saw Jyn being transported in Jaggurnought, I was sold. The Star Wars universe, from the original triology over the Clone Wars to the extended universe from the days of Westend Games, has so much stuff to work with. Stuff, that is now free to use since it is not canon anymore. The sequel triology did nothing of the sort, insetad it took the idea of a reborn Emperor, IMHO among the worst ideas of the Legebds EU, and made somehow even worse.

When the hinted at a fleet of hidden star destroyers in Rise of Skywalker, I so hoped they would steal some elements of the Katana-fleet story arch. But nope. Funny how all the series set after Endor do their utmost to ignore the sequel movies, at least it feels like that to me.

Fo rTgrawn so, they could have skippes the zombie stormtrooper part. Star Wars zombies were a bad idea when introduced in that book about an infested star destroyer, written at the hight of the pop culture zombie craze, and are an element the new canon could have well lived without. After all, Thrawns thing in Timothy Zahns book triology was cloned soldiers. But we will see how that story goes, Thrawn is bavk, and I'm all for it!

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by servercobra on Monday November 20, 2023 @09:44AM (#38349006)
Most egregiously, IMO, was the Holdo Maneuver (jumping the rebel cruiser into the pursuing First Order ship). If that's a thing, why didn't they use that on the Death Star, the Executor, etc. Why weren't people building massive objects with no guns or shields, just a hyperdrive? It just wrecks the internal consistency for an admittedly awe-inspiring moment in theaters.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by Lord-Jobo on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:24AM (#38349431)
They specifically had a line about the pursuers rushing to catch up and dumping all power into that effort. Diverting from shielding and anything that would protect them. After all they had a much larger more powerful force, hubrus lead them to believe that they were safe enough to do so.

As for the "why not just build a hyperdrive shell that you can use to javelin a planet into dust" this is a problem that is ignored in MUCH more serious science fiction than star wars. Because it's a pain I nthe ass to explain away.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by regularfry on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:12PM (#38350743)
They could have bought themselves some points by saying "...and that's how the Death Star works, you need a massive space station as a power source if you want to do it more than once."

But no, lasers.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by btach on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:13PM (#38350776)
Gravity well. You would exit hyperspace before hitting the planet. Same concept as how the Interdictor class Star Destroyers prevent hyperspace/pull ships out of hyperspace.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by LorenPechtel on Monday November 20, 2023 @01:38PM (#38352313)
We never see Star Wars ships moving at relativistic speeds. Jumping to lightspeed takes you into hyper, it doesn't let you engage in a ramming attack.

Besides, we don't know that shields won't stop a ramming attack. The only time it was done it appears the shields weren't being used.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by cgriswald on Monday November 20, 2023 @04:24PM (#38355038)
We see a few collisions major in the original trilogy. I don't think it necessarily clears anything up. I haven't watched in some years so the details are a little hazy and might be wrong:

In ESB:

- An asteroid collides with a Star Destroyer. Communications with the Star Destroyer are lost, but nothing past the hit is shown on screen. (Presumably shields are active since they're putting these ships in the asteroid field.) [Just to speculate, the asteroid itself might have been pulverized and its materials interfering with communications, or some other shield/asteroid interaction causing loss of communications.]

In ROTJ:

- The Executor loses its shields and the A-wing crashes into the bridge. (No shields.)

- The Executor subsequently loses control and crashes into the Death Star. (No shields.)

And in Rogue One:

- The corvette pushes the two Star Destroyers together and they take major damage. (Unknown shield status.)

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by regularfry on Monday November 20, 2023 @12:10PM (#38350708)
Interaction between hyperspace and non-hyperspace is (unintentionally) telegraphed in episode IV when Han says "Without precise calculations we could fly right through a star or bounce too close to a supernova, and that’d end your trip real quick, wouldn’t it?”

That being said Star Wars script-writing has been totally winging it on surprisingly big plot points from the start. It's frankly astonishing that it's even as consistent as it is.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by klyrs on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:44PM (#38353431)
This is my complaint about approximately every sci-fi that has both "shield" and "warp" technology. Just warp a large mass into the bridge, or a bomb if you're feeling nasty. Add instantaneous "subspace" communication a la Star Trek, and you can call in the equivalent of an air strike from the nearest hub. Warp core goes boom.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by twic on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:47PM (#38354476)
"Any interesting space drive is a weapon of mass destruction. It only matters how long you want to wait for maximum damage."

-- Jon Souza

https://projectrho.com/public_html/rocket/prelimnotes.php#jo...

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by gamblor956 on Monday November 20, 2023 @03:12PM (#38353920)
Even within the SW universe there were limitations on the practicality of this strategy: (1) a large enough mass relative to the target so as to cause enough damage, (2) enough armor or shielding for the sacrificial mass to get within hyperspace jump range of the target, (3) a very limited window of space in which to actually hit the target while making the jump to hyperspace, and (4) a crew willing to sacrifice itself in such a manner (because droids and others couldn't simply be ordered to do something like this within the cannon of the SW universe).

But more to the point: we don't know if the Holdo Maneuver became more common in the SW universe because the only subsequent film decided to try and ignore everything that happened in the previous movie in favor of having space horses galloping on the exterior of a starship.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by eddieroger on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:51AM (#38349692)
Given that it's that time of year when the cable channels show Star Wars in entirety, this thread and your comment reminded me of a thought I had last year when rewatching Ep4 on cable. The amount of content that has come from throwaway one-liners that Lucas probably gave nearly no thought to is insane when you consider it. "I fought with him in the Clone Wars" has given us a whole movie in the saga, which then gave us a whole animated series, when then begat a handful of additional series. And that's just one example from one line. It's crazy to think about.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by trilbyglens on Monday November 20, 2023 @11:57AM (#38350486)
This is why I tend to roll my eyes at this sort of Tolkien-level analysis of the story and universe. It's just not a high-quality enough thing to really stand up to that sort of scrutiny. It's like talking about Jelly beans the same way you'd talk about wine. There's just not much there, and so much of it is just inventing things in the murk of the story.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by hardlianotion on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:25PM (#38353118)
The thing that has always bothered me about the Death Star is what a lethal place it was to work. Wrong turn and you plunge down a vent to space. Open the wrong door and you’ll be fighting for your life in a garbage compactor.
Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by NateEag on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:38PM (#38353337)
> Open the wrong door and you’ll be fighting for your life in a garbage compactor.

Technically the heroes blast a hole in the wall to get into the compactor.

Re:The Death Star and the Final Trench Run (2017) by autoexec on Tuesday November 21, 2023 @02:09AM (#38360375)
Risk of being force choked to death too. The pay must be great.