News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by rkuodys on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:31AM (#38329764)
Interesting that instead of addressing real problem - incompetence in driving, is solved by making world slower instead of forcing to learn to drive. In Germany it normal to drive way faster and noone has any problems
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by hn_throwaway_99 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:38AM (#38329798)
What I would give for an eyeroll emoji. Yeah, I'm sure that the story outlined in the article of a guy that killed 9 people in a single accident while on PCP and cocaine could have been avoided if he just had a few more drivers' ed courses...
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by TheFattestNinja on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:47AM (#38329860)
I agree with your comment but otoh would a guy on pcp no be just as deadly at 90 mph?

If we doing this we should rather do automated reaction speed/sobriety tests. Had a friend almost die bc he drove the day after being drunk bc he fell asleep from being sleep deprived even if he was "sober" by then

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by twiceaday on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:55AM (#38329914)
Hard to quantify 'deadly' but kinetic energy is proportional to velocity squared. 100mph has 23% more kinetic energy than 90mph and 56% more than 80mph.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by hellisothers on Sunday November 19, 2023 @03:54AM (#38330623)
Let it go, while your unrelated point may be true either way the car will pulverize a body so it’s a moot point.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by oliwarner on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:00AM (#38331465)
This reductive comment only applies to car vs person.

The real world has buildings and vehicles that offer protection against impacts. The faster you go, the higher the likelihood of multiple fatalities.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by Nursie on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:49AM (#38329868)
In the case in the article, when talking about geosensitive limiters, presumably they would have been limited to somewhere around the 35mph speed limit in the area.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by nullindividual on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:02AM (#38329960)
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by Nursie on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:13AM (#38330026)
Sure. But it’s not really on the same level as 105.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by oliwarner on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:57AM (#38331447)
I think that's rather the point in TFA: both the chance of accident and realised impact force goes up with speed, regardless of cause and fault.

We codify limits. What's the advantage of allowing higher performance hardware on our roads?

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by adapiz on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:11AM (#38331925)
It's just: I can go faster, if I want to (or for some reason need to). I'm really not a fan of doing the Apple thing and to infantilize the user by disallowing sideloading because it's dangerous. The discussion got dragged to compare force and impact but similarly to train tracks, highways are usually a place of motion. People don't walk around and cars are usually also fast. We counter the emergency situation such as the infamous end of a traffic jam by adding brake assistants that warn the driver to brake and then hit the brake on their own. This kind of technology seems to reduce traffic incidents so that the most danger comes from older cars without this technology.

I completely agree, that we don't need hyper cars or racing cars on the road. But the 100 mph limit wouldn't help at all in cities. There are better ways like obstacles that force a driver to slow down or routing with curves instead of straight lines.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by oliwarner on Monday November 20, 2023 @10:54AM (#38349721)
I really don't care for your analogy, speeding is a choice that puts others at risk and I think safety rules that protect everyone from each other, are far from infantilism.

But also, we shouldn't let perfect get in the way of good. Blocking 100mph+ may only improve safety on faster roads, but that's still a gross improvement. A few people a year are caught doing 150mph on 60mph single carriageways near me. Far more nationally, far more never caught, and exponentially more on superbikes.

If there's no legal reason to do 100mph on any road, why not just stop it being an option? Remove that temptation. It will save far more lives than it costs.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by Gibbon1 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:36AM (#38329790)
I think the problem is someone has a 'technology' they want the government to force people to pay for.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by mattlondon on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:43AM (#38329832)
People regularly drive way faster than 100mph through towns and through junctions at red lights and everyone is fine? I doubt it.

Doing over 100 on the motorway/highway/autobahn is a totally different proposition.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by devjab on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:44AM (#38329840)
I think it’s a weird issue. On one hand the governments probably shouldn’t do this, on the other hand we had 1902 vehicles permanently confiscated by our government between 1. April 2001 and 20. March 2023 for our “Insane Driving” (vanvidsbilisme) law here in Denmark, so it would also sort of make sense to find a limit a little above our maximum speed limit.

In one “hilarious” case some Norwegian rich guy went to Germany to buy a Lamborghini (or maybe it was some other super car, but I think it was a Lamborghini) and then proceeded to drive through Denmark at 100 km/h above the highest speed limit we have. Then got caught and lost his brand new car before he reached the ferry to Norway.

Of course a maximum speed limit in your car also wouldn’t solve the most dangerous of these cases. Since they occur when people drive more than 100 km/h through cities, and since our speed limit on the highways goes up to 130 km/h a car limit would probably need to be around 140-150 km/h. I’m Which wouldn’t solve the dangerous driving in cities at all. So unless you can regulate the top speed by location, it won’t save that many lives.

It would be sort of cool if you could regulate car top speed by location, but I’m not sure that’s really feasible. I think it’s far more likely that we’ll do it through mass surveillance. We’re already doing that with the diesel cars that are now illegal in certain city zones, where you’ll automatically get a ticket when your plate is registered by the city surveillance cameras. Once they can monitor speed, and the legalisation moves forward we’ll absolutely start doing this with speeding drivers. I’m not really a fan of the increased surveillance, but it’s not really like it’s going to stop.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by fragmede on Sunday November 19, 2023 @12:59PM (#38335527)
> It would be sort of cool if you could regulate car top speed by location,

They do that in Japan on the GTR, where the top speed limiter is removed when you're flying down the track.

https://www.autoblog.com/2007/12/22/nissan-gt-r-recognizes-t....

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by anarazel on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:50AM (#38329874)
Getting a driver's license in Germany costs well over an order of magnitude more than in the US and takes quite a few weeks. And speed limits are much more enforced in the Germany compared to the US.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by esoterica on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:01AM (#38329953)
Do you think Germans get to drive at 100mph on city streets? They have speed limits too where necessary.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by jnsaff2 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:26AM (#38330080)
In Germany it's also controversial.

There is car manufacturers and petrol heads lobby to not touch the unrestricted speed limits on the autobahn but there are also people who lobby for sensible speed limits as most people drive at about the speed a speed limit would be at anyway (120-130km/h) and the added energy used at speed along with dangerous situations coming from very high speed deltas are not good. A truck is always going to be 90-100 km/h and when a thrill seeker whizzes past them at 250 then the reaction time available and potential energy is killer.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by rasz on Sunday November 19, 2023 @05:16AM (#38331185)
So "dangerous" Autobahns are right in the middle of the pack suggesting speed limits have nothing to do with it https://www.statista.com/chart/25098/fatality-rate-and-speed...
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by oliwarner on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:09AM (#38331522)
Almost like speed is only one factor in road safety.

Autobahns are designed for faster traffic with various features and rules to avoid common collisions. It may be possible to upgrade all the highways designed for 60-70mph to the same specs, but that does seem unrealistic. Just maintaining the surface condition is a common problem in the UK and US.

https://www.german-autobahn.eu/index.asp?page=design

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by adapiz on Sunday November 19, 2023 @07:18AM (#38331977)
You could lock it away so people start messing with their cars to unlock it again. Yes. I wish people would realize how dangerous it is to be so much faster than the adjacent lane.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by Already__Taken on Sunday November 19, 2023 @10:33AM (#38333561)
people only drive 120/130 now because that's what seems right. have this conversation 50 years ago and 60/70km/h seems right. oops we'll never increase it and now everyone speeds anywhere because there's clearly no research put into it. trucks are limited purely on economics €/kmh we do not want the industry racing to use more fuel.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by OrderlyTiamat on Sunday November 19, 2023 @02:30AM (#38330100)
In Germany the speed limit is frequently much lower that that, and driving faster than about 80 mph (130 kmph, called richtgeschwindigkeit) incurs increased liability even on the autobahn without any speed limits.

In my experience not many drivers cruise at speeds of 100 mph (160 kmph). The richtgeschwindigkeit is much more common.

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by adapiz on Sunday November 19, 2023 @06:57AM (#38331812)
I see that, too. It's not even 130 km/h it's often between 100 and 130 km/h. Depending on the speed limit, traffic, lanes available and routing I would say that there are about 5-10% of cars that go faster and maybe 20% that want to go faster but cannot because of traffic. I would agree with a general speed limit of 160 km/h. If you drive around conurbation area "Ruhrpott" you rarely have the chance or aren't allowed to go faster than 100 km/h. Personally I've set my car to alarm me on 200 km/h, just to remind me, that I'm about to do something stupid. When someone is with me, they are also alarmed because it's the usual cockpit beep that tells you, something important popped up like engine failure or tire pressure. I once drove a Ford Focus with an electrical speed limit of 160 km/h in place because it was a company car. But because of this I ended up in a dangerous situation where I was overtaking a slower car that started accelerating. With enough engine power I could accelerate faster up to the point where the limit kicked in and we were at the same speed. As usually I've monitored the situation behind me and I've noticed that there were faster cars approaching. In conclusion I was mislead by the engine to have enough power to handle the situation with ease but the electric limit just cut it of. My foot said: There's more available, but the car suddenly locked it away. Stupid situation. yes. In driving school they teach not to accelerate when someone is overtaking you. Of course this rule changes a bit on the Autobahn, but in this case, speculative driving forced the cars behind me to hit the brakes which is weird when you think that everything will be fine because the slower car just accelerates and overtakes. Stopping the maneuver of all sudden and let the car on the right lane pass you again is is the worst outcome for everyone behind you.

That's why I suggest to not limit the car's acceleration curve so the driver notices that the engine is on its limit. Rather I would implement an audible signal at 160 km/h and a repeating signal for over 190 km/h. Because to be honest: It's rarely possible to drive that fast for just a minute. I would also suggest to get these street legal racing machines like Audi RS-models off the road. There's absolutely no sane use for such overpowered cars on public roads. And finally: Company cars should be limited or regulated in some way. Most aggressive and fast drivers seem to be representatives. They don't pay the high prices for fuel and don't care about wear of the car (especially brakes).

Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by rkuodys on Monday November 20, 2023 @02:02AM (#38343685)
Well that's kind of my point. People opt for what is right rather what is maximum allowed
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by sumuyuda on Sunday November 19, 2023 @04:17AM (#38330771)
Yeah that’s not true in Berlin. There are regular crashes where people race through the city and end up killing people.
Re:You shouldn't be driving over 100 MPH-and your car should... by seanp2k2 on Sunday November 19, 2023 @11:49AM (#38334481)
Also interesting that the first paragraph cites 103mph as the speed in a deadly accident. Would 3mph have made a difference here?

Volvo already limits top speed to 112mph in all their models since 2021 https://www.goodwood.com/grr/road/news/2020/5/does-volvos-ne....

Then there’s the time-honored tradition of car mods and the legacy / grandfathering problem. Plenty of cars out there today can hit 160mph or more easily, even pretty modest vehicles like a V6 Honda Accord. Is a 6000# Tesla limited to 100mph much safer than an Accord that weighs a little more than half as much going 160?

It doesn’t mean we shouldn’t try, but the problem is much bigger than what limiting vmax on new vehicles will solve. 100mph is still many tons of force depending on vehicle weight, very much enough to do a lot of damage. Politicians love fixing the easy problem instead of addressing the cultural issues at play here in our society. Listen for how many cat-less exhausts you hear in California as evidence of how effective CARB and inspections have been. Again, it’s not that it’s a bad idea, just that there are too many ways around it and too much will to avoid the law. The best laws are the ones people want to follow. How do we steer society to a place where reckless driving isn’t so appealing?