News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:SpaceX Loses Starship Spaceraft During Test Flight by hinkley on Saturday November 18, 2023 @10:59AM (#38320922)
People genuinely don’t understand how statistics work. Which is part of why Vegas still makes so much money.

When you put together a bunch of equipment with a small error rate, the time between errors climbs very fast. Build a RAID array with 33 disks and you’d better have a vendor picked out for replacements because you’ll be doing replacements fairly often, instead of every four to ten years with a single disk.

And they don’t understand dependent statistics either. Every failing rocket engine can potentially damage its neighbors. Every failing hard drive requires a stressful operation on the remaining disks (resilvering) that may push the next drive to failure.

Re:SpaceX Loses Starship Spaceraft During Test Flight by panarky on Saturday November 18, 2023 @05:24PM (#38325274)
> Build a RAID array with 33 disks ...

Yes, naturally 33 > 1, so you should expect 33 times as many failures of individual components.

But your analogy between arrays of rocket engines and disks is apt, because both have the redundancy to survive the failure of individual components.

For example, in the inaugural high-altitude flight test of the Starship prototype in May 2021, three of the 33 Raptor engines powering the first stage failed shortly after liftoff. The vehicle still managed to reach an altitude of 40 kilometers before failing due to a variety of causes.

If an individual disk has MTBF of 2 million hours, its probability of failing in the first year is 0.437%.

But put 33 of those disks in a RAID 6 array, which can tolerate 1 or 2 failures without replacement, and the probability of the entire array failing in the first year drops by a factor of 10 to 0.0413%.

The array is more reliable than a single component by itself.

> People genuinely don’t understand how statistics work

Indeed.

Re:SpaceX Loses Starship Spaceraft During Test Flight by Ingaz on Sunday November 19, 2023 @01:58AM (#38329937)
The interesting point for me was:

> Every failing hard drive requires a stressful operation on the remaining disks (resilvering) that may push the next drive to failure.

I saw something similar: RAID array with 5 disks and 3 spare disks. One night controller detected failure, ejected one drive and replaced with spare. After rebuild of RAID it ejected another disk and then another. In an hour all spare disks were used and on fourth failure it stopped work

What was probability of such series of failures?