News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by alexkearns on Thursday April 12, 2012 @07:43AM (#3831929)
You seem to think that the total amount of charitable donations is all important. More is better, seems to be your argument, regardless of where that money goes, where it comes from or what it is spent on. What if all that money went to a charity you disagree with, say one that promotes eugenics?

My argument is: leave charitable giving to individuals - individuals can choose their own charities or not to give anything. That seems far more democratic to me. It may be that this will result in less charitable donations overall but at least the money will be going to organisations individuals support.

Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by tptacek on Thursday April 12, 2012 @09:25AM (#3832188)
Startups aren't donating to charities that promote eugenics.
Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by chc on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:58PM (#3833227)
This is an individual choosing to give to charity. I am an individual, and I'm choosing to give a little bit of stock in my company to charity. So what's the problem?
Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by drumdance on Thursday April 12, 2012 @12:01PM (#3832904)
I'm not a huge fan of corporate giving, but the counter-argument is that when you have one big donor instead of a lot of little ones, and objectionable decisions by the company can be boycotted.

For example, Coors used to give to a lot of right-wing organizations and also had a lot of anti-gay hiring practices. Gay organizations targetted them and eventually they not only stopped donating to those orgs, but they changed all their corporate policies.

Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by maratd on Thursday April 12, 2012 @01:04PM (#3833248)
Wow. So essentially you're saying people are too stupid to know who to donate to, so instead, let's have large corporations do it. They can be manipulated by special interests for the betterment of society!

I'll pass on that.

Re:Introducing 1% of Nothing by TomGullen on Thursday April 12, 2012 @09:54AM (#3832279)
Leaving charity solely to individuals would be a responsibility with dire consequences. Charities need money, and we all have a moral obligation to give that all of us including me fall far short of.

Government giving to charity, business giving to charity is good and should be encouraged.

If you work at a company that gives money to charity you can always find one that doesn't.