My argument is: leave charitable giving to individuals - individuals can choose their own charities or not to give anything. That seems far more democratic to me. It may be that this will result in less charitable donations overall but at least the money will be going to organisations individuals support.
For example, Coors used to give to a lot of right-wing organizations and also had a lot of anti-gay hiring practices. Gay organizations targetted them and eventually they not only stopped donating to those orgs, but they changed all their corporate policies.
I'll pass on that.
Government giving to charity, business giving to charity is good and should be encouraged.
If you work at a company that gives money to charity you can always find one that doesn't.
1. the grandparent should be free to direct his business anyway he wants and that includes giving 100% of his profits to charity;
2. people should have discussions about what is good, logical policy for a business or individual to practice. This includes discussing whether businesses should push profits to their shareholders/employees or pay them out to charity. I agree with the sentiment that funds should probably be distributed to the stakeholders (share- and employees), because having more diverse money encourages a more efficient market in philanthropy.
Money that is properly understood as "return on investment" can safely be "pushed" to charities without any moral or ethical quandaries.
Money that is owed to employees can't be donated to charities at all. Fortunately: nobody is suggesting that it should be.
It is not a valid criticism to complain that money that the owners of the company are entitled to anyways is instead going to charity. Let's let people do good things without looking for reasons to bitch at them.
(The number one limiting factor is the lack of any efficient market in utilons. See Givewell and Giving What We Can for optimal philanthropy background.)