News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by mcntsh on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:04AM (#38302916)
Closing costs in Germany are quite high... about 12%.

- 3.57% RE commission

- 2.00% notary

- 6% for the land transfer tax

And the seller also pays 3.57% of the RE commission. So over 6% at the end of the day :)

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by benjaminwootton on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:07AM (#38302948)
In the UK, the market rate 1.5% paid by the seller on completion. Nothing to the buyer and rarely any fees for a failed transaction.

Then approximately £1000 in legal fees when buying or selling.

Then the big one which is stamp duty (a government tax) which is between 0 and 12% of the purchase price. Typically the lower end of that scale though. (https://www.gov.uk/stamp-duty-land-tax/residential-property-...)

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by enlyth on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:36AM (#38303313)
In the UK we also have one of the worst systems for buying and selling property which on average takes 3 months or more for a single transaction and everyone can walk away at any point until exchange of contracts for whatever dumb reason. As a buyer you will spend thousands on legal and survey fees before you even know if there is anything wrong with the property.

Legal fees are more like 2k+ these days (source: buying a house)

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by ck425 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:36AM (#38304177)
In England you mean. I'm not sure about Wales or NI but the system in Scotland is much better and still has similarly low fee's.

In Scotland sellers are legally required to provide a survey to potential buyer, known as the Home Report, which covers all the basics. While it doesn't go indepth on specific issues it does normally highlight them in the first place so you're far less likely to uncover surprise issues after buying. And if it does find potentially major issues the seller will often pay for a more indepth survey or to just get it fixed themselves as otherwise no one will consider the property. For example the home report for the first property I bought found damp which put most people off so the seller paid for a damp survey and quote to fix which they added to the HR. Even then it put a lot of people off and I got it £3k under valuation despite the quote to fix the damp being only £1.8k.

Also I'm not sure if it's the same down in England but "estate agents" in Scotland are all solicitors and thus regulated. Plus when you sell it's one fee to one company for everything and there's no faff about info going between agents and solicitors.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by harel on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:24AM (#38304808)
I hear complaints about it a lot, and I've nearly been burned by that system myself. However, it protects the people in the chain from becoming homeless or obligated to a sale if their buyer/seller falls through for example.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by rwmj on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:20AM (#38303111)
It's important to note that (in general) sellers pay the estate agents fee and buyers pay stamp duty. If you are both buying and selling then you'd pay both, but on different properties. However if you're moving to/from rentals, dead or moving abroad then you'd pay only one.

Also it's possible to cut out the estate agent if you really want to save money. There are a bunch of websites that for a minimal flat fee will let you DIY it, but be prepared to make your own for sale sign, photograph your own property, and show prospective buyers around.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by _benedict on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:30AM (#38303245)
Those websites usually include (or at least offer) professional photography, and some also offer various levels of agent assistance for viewings, negotiations etc. an a la carte offering of sorts. A for sale sign is often included as it’s free advertising for them.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by mytailorisrich on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:36AM (#38304178)
Well the estate agent is the agent (i.e. employee) of the seller: They work for the seller. It's quite normal that they are paid by the party who employs them!
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by onlyrealcuzzo on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:15AM (#38303039)
Why is the notary making 2%?!

Is that including all legal fees?

Even still that seems like a much bigger rip off than a buyer's agent in the US.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by thiago_fm on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:37AM (#38303330)
The 2% is worth it.

It's an expensive, but essential step in Germany.

Because there isn't a default real estate purchase contract, so you need to trust that you'll receive the property. It's like paying a lawyer to mediate an expensive purchase, and they carry some legal risks with it.

They also do the bureaucracy with the government to add your name to the Grundbuch (it's a book from the government about who owns what % of a property), and also clean up the previous debts that it had (they are written there).

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by hef19898 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:19AM (#38303088)
A nortary makes sure the sale ia properly exevuted and titles properly transferred, he is certifying the transaction and takes on some legal riks dor doing so. This provides legal security for seller and buyer, a service woth paying for in transactions most people only do once in their life (we talk about Germany here). For all others, it is just coat of doing business.

No idea why it is always everybody else who should work for free.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by tecleandor on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:33AM (#38303278)
Sounds more like a lawyer or several competencies at the same time.

In Spain the notary "just" works through the signature of the contract:

  - Checks the identities of the parties and their legal status
  - Makes "sure" both parties understand the contract
  - Verifies that the property can be sold (checks for legal issues in the national registry)
  - Serves as a legal witness to the signature
  - Sends a copy of the contract to the national registry (but AFAIK, doesn't follow up)
The cost here, for that, is around 500-800€. It's regulated by law.

Then you have to contact a registrar to make all the legal papers to make all the legal papers in the national registry. That's araound 300-400 €, I think.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by codedokode on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:50AM (#38304352)
Aren't most of the checks automated? E.g. you just fill a form in a government services website and get a PDF back?
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by PaulDavisThe1st on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:57AM (#38305303)
In the US, this can be done by a title & escrow service. They hold the deposit money (assuming there is some, which is normal), and then at closing they will do all of the above, as well as receiving and distributing funds from the buyer/mortgage company.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by mihaic on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:38AM (#38303338)
Validating property rights is a fixed-time operation that seems to be one of the basic services a state should offer. I read the parent poster naturally asking why 2% instead of some lower, fixed amount.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by esrauch on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:28AM (#38303226)
Does the notary provide the title insurance (as in: if it turns out later that the seller didn't actually own the house, the real owner shows up and proves it, the bank and new buyers have their money covered)?

That would make more sense for the 2% but it's not related to the notary in the US; notary literally just does "I checked the id of the person signing and it matches" which is a service that can be had for free at your bank or at most $50 if you have to pay someone, 2% of a house for that service obviously wouldn't make sense.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by dagw on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:40AM (#38303383)
A notary in the UK is a type of lawyer and requires special certification and training. Their job is to make sure all the paper work is in order and to sign off that is in fact so.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by hef19898 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:52AM (#38303532)
In Germany you cannot sell real estate thatbisn't yours, ownership is registered. The notary, as part of his job, makes sure this title transfer is done properly. If the seller isn't the owner, the sale is void, as far as I know sales price is to be paid once the title transfer was requested and approved, upon proof of payment the notary finalizes it. So basically no title insurance needed.

By the way, excerpts of the registry for the real estate in question are part of the sales contract (just remembered).

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by esrauch on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:18AM (#38303909)
Ownership is registered in the US and part of the sale is a "title search" to check that and then update the registered title when the sale is executed (both handled by an attorney).

The case of title insurance is only where something weirder happens with wills, contracts, or liens. If there was an owner that died in 2016 and his will said "split my house to all surviving children". And at the time one child shows up who believes they are the sole surviving descendant and claims the house and sells it in 2017, then 2018 a second heir finds out their estranged parent died and shows up to say "actually half of this house was mine, that guy didn't legally have the right to sell it even without any fraud occuring".

Title insurance ends up 'fixing' this problem so that the buyer and actual-should-have-been-owner can both be made whole (and they go after the seller for the amount they didn't actually own, but sometimes that won't be possible to recover). If you don't have title insurance you as the buyer just take the liability that you might not actually own the house (or part of the house) if the record was mistaken and needs to be corrected.

In Germany would this just be a case where if the will is executed and you find out too late the inheritor would be screwed with no way to get what you owned instead?

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by debacle on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:20AM (#38303110)
Might be a different meaning of the term notary. In the US, you can become a notary public for $35 and an online course in many instances.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by hef19898 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:24AM (#38303165)
You cannot be elected?

In all seriousness, notaries in Germany are all full lawyers and practices are highly sought after, as the numbers of lisvensed notaries is limited.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by tecleandor on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:47AM (#38303468)
In Spain, Notaries and Property Registrars are a weird thing.

You have to pass an exam, same as a public servant, and the number of positions is limited. But you don't have a regular salary like any other public servant: you set up a private office and get the money directly from your clients.

The price for the actions is regulated but it's high, and the number of licenses is limited, so generally they have hefty salaries, specially compared to the rest of the public servants and the mean of the population.

Their salary can be very variable based on location (as you get the money directly from your clients), but it's said to typically be from 100K to 200K€

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by mariojv on Friday November 17, 2023 @01:01PM (#38307352)
My eyes popped at that salary for a notary in Spain given most eng positions seem to pay under 60K euro.

It looks like they need a law degree, too, so I'm sure they offer legal services other than property transactions?

https://www.notariado.org/portal/en/how-to-be-a-notary

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by statusgraph on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:26AM (#38303194)
Seems like it, the parent poster is almost implying there's an element of underwriting the transaction/house for which 2% is not unreasonable (Title insurance is in the 1% (or a bit less) range in the US I believe)
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by Tangurena2 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:25AM (#38303180)
In many states, notaries can marry people as the actual legal step of notarizing the marriage license and returning it to the county clerk's office is the actual deed that makes people legally married.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by jcranmer on Friday November 17, 2023 @10:27AM (#38304862)
In the US (and I think most common law jurisdictions), a notary public is basically Certificate Transparency for legal documents. The notary records that so-and-so signed such-and-such on this date in their log, and if you have any doubts about that, they can produce that log for you to prove to that they witnessed it.

By contrast, civil law notaries are generally full-on lawyers who are trained and intended to perform several legal tasks.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by nmcfarl on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:31AM (#38303264)
This sounds a lot like a ‘title company’ to me.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by UncleMeat on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:20AM (#38303929)
"Free" and "paid $15,000" don't seem to be the only two options.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by pierat on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:16AM (#38303055)
That signature is made with a realllllly heavy pen, I guess?
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by mytailorisrich on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:39AM (#38304215)
Because they have a captive market: In general the use of a notary is mandated by law.

They could open this to competition and let lawers do the job as well, but that would go down badly with the notaries...

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by voisin on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:27AM (#38303213)
There are land transfer taxes in Canada too, and I presume our equivalent to notary are lawyers which are about $1,000-$1,500.

The actual in-and-out costs are significantly higher than just the agents, though the agents are the most expensive and of questionable value.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by geff82 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:11AM (#38302984)
Germany has high fees when buying a house, but compared to the US it is dirt cheap to actually own the house. „Ground tax“, similar ro „property taxes“ in the US is usually just a few hundred Euro a year. Which, compared to the US, is change money. A German house, when the mortgage is paid, feels like real property.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by benjaminwootton on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:19AM (#38303098)
I would hate the high US property taxes. It’s like you never really own the property if you are being taxed on it continually. It must play havoc with retirement planning?
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by Tangurena2 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:31AM (#38303260)
In most states, property taxes are what pays for schools, roads, libraries and things like that. When I was modernizing our state's motor vehicle registration system, I had to account for those fees in every vehicle (cars, boats, mobile homes, etc) registration cost. The state constitution states that things can only taxed based on value.

Taxed based on value: https://apps.legislature.ky.gov/Law/Constitution/Constitutio...

Value based on fair market value: https://apps.legislature.ky.gov/Law/Constitution/Constitutio...

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by criley2 on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:20AM (#38303108)
The tax man gets his one way or another. Imagine the shock of an American living without sales tax when they go to Germany and everything has a 20% government markup...

In Germany, the net average tax rate on a worker is 37.4%, in America it is 24.8%. That's a dramatic difference in taxation!

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by tempsy on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:27AM (#38303206)
Anyone living in California or NYC and making mid six figures and up is easily paying more than German tax rates then. You’re paying almost 50% around high six figure range.

I’ve never quite understood why people think the US is a low tax country.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by criley2 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:02AM (#38303664)
I used "net average tax rate" from the OECD as an apples to apples comparison.

Your reply is "what about the 1%ers who live in two of the most expensive cities in the world? What about THEM?"

What about the 99.9% of Americans who don't make six figures in one of those two cities?

I've never quite understood why people think America is a few million people living in 2 cities. You know there's 320,000,000 more us of right?

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by tempsy on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:46AM (#38304308)
There’s 50M-60M people between California and NYC.

At this point making “mid six figures” hardly makes you rich. You don’t have to be the top 1% to see a tax rate higher than the one you stated.

Point is arguing that Americans are low taxed when the highest paying jobs are concentrated in high tax states and cost of living is much higher ignores reality for many Americans who pay as much or more than Europeans.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by criley2 on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:50AM (#38304370)
Oh, my bad, you actually included all of California in your quote. I corrected it to SF because most people understand that California is absolutely massive.

The median household income in California is $80k and of the 40 million in California, very few work in tech.

California actually has extremely progressive tax laws and extremely low property taxes, so while you're right that the actually wealthy folks do pay a European-level of taxation, the working class actually pays a dramatically tax rate than their counterparts in Europe.

Anyone with any knowledge of California knows all of this, so when you made such odd points that seemed to challenge it, I tried to help you by assuming you meant SF.

Point is: the vast majority of Americans pay vastly less taxes than Europeans and no weird focuses on outliers is going to change reality.

Funny side note: I still am the only person who posted OECD apples to apples data, which you have rejected un-critically with no sourcing and nothing but hand waves about your feelings. Hmmm.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by PopAlongKid on Friday November 17, 2023 @09:56AM (#38304394)
>You’re paying almost 50% around high six figure range.

That's a gross oversimplification and thus very misleading. While your marginal tax rate on taxable income (not gross income) might be close to 50%, if you are married filing joint, a homeowner, and have children, you are not paying anywhere near 50% effective tax rate[0] on your total income, due to deductions and exemptions, credits, tax-deferred retirement contributions, tax-free health insurance, and progressive tax brackets.

[0] "effective tax rate" does not have a universally agreed single definition, but the statement holds for most reasonable definitions.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by eldavido on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:02PM (#38308328)
Not really. 20-30% effective on income including CA's 9.4% at ~40k, plus 10-20k in property taxes, 10%+ in sales taxes, excise taxes on everything from gasoline to alcohol, and various "fees" that are really taxes including auto registration, building permit fees, DMV charges, ride share fees, motor oil and battery disposal charges. Also, some cities (e.g. NYC) have a personal income tax.

Obviously you're right that marginal != effective, but Americans really do pay a LOT in taxes, when you add it up, for a relatively middling level of services (e.g. no public healthcare, no subsidized daycares, marginal-quality public schools)

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by 0xBDB on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:48PM (#38313231)
Depends on your definition of "mid six figures" and your source, but it at least doesn't appear very misleading. At $450k it looks like the federal effective tax burden is 35% and the New York tax burden is at least ~16% (the data are not broken out by income).

https://smartasset.com/taxes/income-taxes https://taxfoundation.org/data/all/state/tax-burden-by-state...

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by AuryGlenz on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:32AM (#38305821)
The US is a very low tax country for the bottom 50% of income earners compared to many countries.

From a quick Google: The US federal income tax rate for low earners is something like 12%. In the UK it's 20%. In Sweden it looks like the municipal tax is 32%. The few other countries I looked up had complicated tax systems that made it hard to compare, not that the above examples (and the US) aren't missing their deductions.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by kbf on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:21AM (#38305652)
I was surprised when I went to the US and had to pay taxes on everything I bought. On a logical level, I know I pay sales tax in Europe too, but it’s all integrated into the price tag of items so on a more psychological level it doesn’t really feel like the tax is there. Compare that to the US where you pick up a few items in a store, mentally add up an approximate price you have to pay and the cashier asks for significantly more. I’ve also noticed some products sold internationally will have very similar prices in the US and EU, probably because the company wants to hit some certain price for marketing reasons, but the EU price has the taxes included in it.
Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by runako on Friday November 17, 2023 @11:53AM (#38306193)
> That's a dramatic difference in taxation!

To be fair, we (US) outsource much of our taxation to the private sector, so that basics like healthcare fees/taxes are routed through private companies. If it comes out of your check before you get it, and it's not going into your 401(k), it might as well be a tax.

Re:Almost No One Pays a 6% Real-Estate Commission–Except Ame... by bequanna on Friday November 17, 2023 @05:21PM (#38311291)
Sounds like a tax problem, not a commission problem.