News for hackers. Stuff that matters.
Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by KronisLV on Friday November 17, 2023 @06:36AM (#38302134)
> Basically, he went to a therapist and they told him to confront himself with increasingly uncomfortable social situations. It was horrible but he managed to do it.

This does sound like confirmation bias, because you hear about the success stories where people successfully confront their issues and overcome them, not the people who fail miserably until they can no longer keep trying that approach. You also don't hear about people who fail and feel worse because the only things they've heard are success stories and that make them feel worse.

I went through that in university, decided to go to a tabletop game evening with complete strangers, had a breakdown, went back to the dorms and cried. Tried going to a few other hangouts, same outcome, feeling worse every single time, not better, which lead to lots of negative thoughts. I guess it might have been committing to doing too much, but the people were pretty chill and I still couldn't do it. Same with things like random small talk.

I guess I was lucky enough to have a group of friends that I opened up to and eventually got better at certain social settings - nowadays basically everything work related and things like giving presentations is a non-issue, where I feel like I have a "goal" and the terms for that social interaction are well understood, versus freeform interaction with strangers, that I've never handled well.

> After a few months and many more challenges, the therapist told him: "Do not, under any circumstance, accept isolation again. That will drive even a sociable person into introversion. Avoid it like the plague. There will be minor set backs, but we are now all equipped with the knowledge and techniques to overcome them - along with the memory that we've conquered it before." Every time we face the fear, and decide to go through with it anyway, we become a little bit stronger.

Some people get stronger, others get worse. I'm not saying that this isn't worth a shot, it probably is - but also consider seeing a professional who can advise on different things to try, identify patterns of thinking that could become an issue and how to address those, or possibly even certain medication should your brain chemistry need a little help to function better. Possibly even multiple healthcare professionals or different types of medication (if needed), until you find something that actually works for you.

Guess this is a bit of a vulnerable moment, but at the same time I don't entirely buy the narrative that exposure therapy of this sort will work for everyone and always, or people should go in with the expectation that it will. The advice of gradually ramping up seems good, as does actually trying to do something about it, though.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by Ensorceled on Friday November 17, 2023 @06:59AM (#38302335)
> > Basically, he went to a therapist and they told him to confront himself with increasingly uncomfortable social situations. It was horrible but he managed to do it.

> This does sound like confirmation bias, because you hear about the success stories where people successfully confront their issues and overcome them, not the people who fail miserably until they can no longer keep trying that approach. You also don't hear about people who fail and feel worse because the only things they've heard are success stories and that make them feel worse.

Well ... exposure therapy is an actual therapeutic technique that is used to successfully treat social anxiety and is usually one of the first methods tried, often as part of a CBT process, so let's not all jump on the "confirmation bias" band wagon. An anecdote is not data but an anecdote doesn't magically somehow prove the opposite.

As a fellow SAD sufferer, I'm trying not to be too harsh, but you clearly have a serious version of SAD, so applying your situation to this self-help site is a bit over the top. Yes, this may not work for a particular individual, but if you are having breakdowns you shouldn't be self managing your disorder anyway.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by CoastalCoder on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:07AM (#38302413)
I think you and the GP both make good points.

It seems like what we're really missing here is solid data about the success rate for the author's approach.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by going_north on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:47AM (#38302765)
Another important point is that exposure therapy needs to be tailored to your particular level of discomfort. If you do too little it clearly won't have any effect, but on the other hand, if you go too hard it can make your anxiety or phobias worse.
Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by Ensorceled on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:59AM (#38302879)
Yeah, I signed up to see the progression. I presume that a ramp up may start off too easy for some people but will eventually start challenging without going overboard.
Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by Ensorceled on Friday November 17, 2023 @12:38PM (#38306985)
Edit, got the first stage by email ... yeah it starts off really easy.
Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by Ensorceled on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:08AM (#38302958)
Exposure therapy is a proven technique for social anxiety and is the first line treatment. As long as the ramp up in exposure is gradual and doesn’t start off with “go to an extremely social event with a lot of complete strangers” on day one it shouldn’t be a problem and should be helpful for a lot of people.

I hope the program has disclaimers and warnings about when to seek professional help.

I feel for the original commenter, they seem to have traumatized themselves pretty badly, but I just don’t see how their experience maps onto this website at all.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by KronisLV on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:17AM (#38303064)
> As a fellow SAD sufferer, I'm trying not to be too harsh, but you clearly have a serious version of SAD, so applying your situation to this self-help site is a bit over the top.

I'm just trying to suggest that consulting a professional is probably a good idea - since someone running a platform like this won't be able to help with all of the cases. I still think the challenge is an okay idea for most people who need a gentle push, but won't work for everyone.

Just putting that out there, possibly "confirmation bias" is too strong of a suggestion to use here, that's a fair point, my bad. It's not that the method itself is bad, just that people are different and specialists should help with identifying what works the best.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by Ensorceled on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:56AM (#38303576)
> I'm just trying to suggest that consulting a professional is probably a good idea

I personally think everybody should go through at least one round of therapy, so I'm on board.

> It's not that the method itself is bad, just that people are different and specialists should help with identifying what works the best.

Unfortunately, not everyone has access to competent, affordable professionals in this area. Self help is often all that's available or all that some one is willing to do.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by IAmGraydon on Friday November 17, 2023 @07:03AM (#38302376)
>This does sound like confirmation bias, because you hear about the success stories where people successfully confront their issues and overcome them, not the people who fail miserably until they can no longer keep trying that approach.

What you’re referring to is survivorship bias, not confirmation bias.

Re:Show HN: I made a 30-day social anxiety challenge by KronisLV on Friday November 17, 2023 @08:25AM (#38303178)
> What you’re referring to is survivorship bias, not confirmation bias.

Thanks, edited, got those mixed up because it was early.