News for hackers. Stuff that matters.

HN Idea: View of just Review requests

I'm not saying to remove the Requests for reviews from the main body, but I admit I like looking at these apps and would like an easier way to find them. Just like we have a jobs page, is there enough interest to convince PG that we might get a 'Reviews' page?
( 16 comments | 36 points | on HN )
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by Alex3917 on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:39AM (#383014)
Similarly, I had the idea a while ago to make a separate page for submissions that take over 1000 seconds (16.6 min) to appreciate. It sucks when someone submits a documentary and by the time the first few people have finished watching it and are ready to vote it up it's already off the front page. Same goes for the 10+ page articles in the NYT Mag on Sunday, video lectures, short stories, book talks, podcasts, etc.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by danw on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @06:43PM (#383754)
I find http://givemesomethingtoread.com/ good for finding long form content. It's become my preferred source for tasty brain food over HN.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by jgrahamc on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:47AM (#383021)
How about just adding tagging to HN and then RSS feeds by tag?
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by twism on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @11:08AM (#383138)
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by twism on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @01:27PM (#383375)
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by SingAlong on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:50AM (#383023)
yup! that would be useful. This way I can track topics by tags. Thought of this a couple of days back and also that someone would have already made such a feature request.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by jjclarkson on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @10:12AM (#383048)
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by axod on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:36AM (#383010)
I agree. I think the review posts are really useful - both for the people who created, and those reviewing.

It would be a shame if any are getting passed by, and would be useful to see the reviews on their own.

Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by SingAlong on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @10:01AM (#383036)
This actually helps a lot.

There's a time when people read HN and a time when people use the bookmarklet to post(varies from person-to-person depending on the timezone). So people posting via the bookmarklet wouldn't have taken a look at the interesting threads. So when this happens, all the other people's interesting threads would be gone.

People in different time zones have a problem. Yes time-zones do matter.

I reside in a time-zone totally opposite to that of SF or USA. I've noticed that when I post threads in 'my' morning, it rarely gets response. And when I post threads in 'my' evening/night, then there's response. Threads posted(by everyone) during 'my' morning are often pushed down by others new threads. I've also noticed that these new threads are being responded to during 'my' night. So those which are responded to are those which are posted recently.

So the most interesting part - the review threads are missed sometimes. So its better to have a separate section for it.

P.S: I might sound vague but I couldn't explain better.

Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by stillmotion on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:34AM (#383008)
This would be extremely useful. PG, please add it.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by wesley on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:40AM (#383015)
Yep, main reason I come here. Please give me an RSS feed for this alone.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by pedalpete on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @12:25PM (#383276)
Though tags and categorization are nice to have, I like the idea of getting a well rounded experience at HN. Forcing visitors to just reading the titles exposes them to all sorts of things they wouldn't have been exposed to otherwise.

I could see myself using categories or tags if they are available, but that doesn't mean it would be a better experience.

Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by trickjarrett on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @01:44PM (#383394)
Tagging has come up many times before as a suggestion for improving the user experience. I think your reasoning is one reason it hasn't come yet. One of the things about YC is that it pushes a broad spectrum of fairly low noise links across to the reader.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by tjr on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @12:41PM (#383309)
Maybe removing them from the main section would be just the thing to do, actually. I almost always ignore the requests for reviews, simply due to lack of time, but would appreciate getting to peruse them all in one place for anything I find particularly interesting.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by staunch on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @12:12PM (#383258)
I think it'd be awesome if there were some additional categories here. I wish Jobs was open to everyone (and allowed comments) and Reviews was a section.
Re:HN Idea: View of just Review requests by rokhayakebe on Tuesday December 02, 2008 @09:36AM (#383012)
You are absolutely right. I frequently find my self doing a Google search for it.