Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by porkbeer on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:31AM
(#38288293)
Its not self expression when something else does the expressing.
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by j4yav on Thursday November 16, 2023 @06:36AM
(#38288321)
[delayed]
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by jerojero on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:13AM
(#38288600)
Machines cannot express, as far as I know. They're sophisticated tools but still tools.
If someone feels these tools help them express what they want, if they are satisfied, I would call that a form of self-expression. I mean, who am I to deny them that feeling?
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by emanuele232 on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:48AM
(#38288912)
this is getting philosophical, but maybe humans are sophisticated tools
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by hurryer on Thursday November 16, 2023 @07:59AM
(#38289006)
A director directing the orchestra...
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by butlike on Thursday November 16, 2023 @01:13PM
(#38293215)
Case: I create a painting. When it's done I say: "yes, this represents how I feel, and I want to share it."
Case: I create a painting with a prompt and when it's done I say: "yes, this represents how I feel, and I want to share it."
What's the difference?
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by jacquesm on Thursday November 16, 2023 @02:09PM
(#38293914)
That you created a prompt, not a painting.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by butlike on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:03PM
(#38294697)
I like your answer. I also didn't create the prompt if we're going down that road. I just spoke.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by jacquesm on Thursday November 16, 2023 @03:07PM
(#38294744)
I think you enjoy twisted arguments too much for me to continue this conversation.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by vunderba on Friday November 17, 2023 @02:48AM
(#38300698)
This 100%. I'm amazed that people somehow are unable to distinguish between the craftsmanship of a painting, and writing a prompt that an external system uses to paint.
What I always emphasize is that if the input and output are sufficiently divergent then your sense of accomplishment at the resulting creation should be proportionally diminished. But what do I know? People use ChatGPT to write a story and midjourney to illustrate it, then make a viral post with the caption "I just wrote a book in under 24 hours."
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by sifar on Thursday November 16, 2023 @04:40PM
(#38295949)
It is the act, how that experience shapes us.
Re:Google: Transforming the Future of Music Creation
by helboi4 on Friday November 17, 2023 @06:25AM
(#38302048)
Have you ever told someone you code and they say "I have an idea for an app!", proceeding to explain in like one sentence the vague idea of an app? Would you call that person a creative? An engineer? An inventor? An entrepreneur? Do you really ever feel that they added any value to you? Do you not find them incredibly naïve? If you did create the app, do you feel like they did 90% of the work of creating this app, because the rest of the process is that meaningless? If you created it from their one line prompt of their idea, would you agree with the concept that the final result was actually all a direct expression of their idea?
The difference is clearly massive.