Re:The 'Georgists' Are Out and they want to tax your land
by sokoloff on Wednesday November 15, 2023 @10:34AM
(#38277780)
It's taxed now as well (in almost all jurisdictions). It's just also taxed on the buildings that sit on top of it (that latter portion of which provides a disincentive to development).
[ Parent
| on HN ]
Re:The 'Georgists' Are Out and they want to tax your land
by robertlagrant on Wednesday November 15, 2023 @10:48AM
(#38277980)
Understood, although not much of a disincentive. I think I have an aversion to just taxing what people own. When it's a building, at least that is related to services they're likely to consume; it's not just "we want a cut".
Re:The 'Georgists' Are Out and they want to tax your land
by artimaeis on Wednesday November 15, 2023 @10:57AM
(#38278089)
I think that's the jib though - in a lot of countries you don't really "own" the land. You and the government(s) get to just agree that it's your responsibility for a while.
LVT cleans up this incentive some by putting taxes in place in areas where the land is more valuable. I think Georgists would argue for doing that _and_ removing property taxes, specifically so you aren't taxed for the things you own.
Re:The 'Georgists' Are Out and they want to tax your land
by robertlagrant on Wednesday November 15, 2023 @12:45PM
(#38279758)
But... you are being taxed for things you own.
I'd prefer to have more direct spending on services than we have, so the money isn't proxied off a building, or how many windows you have, or whatever harebrained scheme local bureacrats might invent. So you just pay X a month to have trash taken; X for sewage, etc etc. But I'd say that moving to just taking money in a way entirely unrelated to service consumption is going in the wrong direction.